Mini Normal 1941 - Game Over

[PantherPunt]

Lucky and Elena, who do yo think fits well with una?

Elena, are you all the way caught up? Anyone high up town for you and/or definite scum for you?

Yes I am all caught up! I'd like to vote in fliz/Unba today those are the 2 people I feel most confident will flip scum I don't see myself voting Lucky anytime soon he's my top townread everyone else has certain levels of towny to them if you have a question on someone feel free to ask I know I didn't post a huge catch up but I am 100% caught up

How did lucky/bbt end up as your top townread?

[PantherPunt]

Hm already 2 pages in and it seems interesting given this was a wagon on scum, Early townread on BBT given I don't see why he has to call out his partner like this and light sr on screen cause this interaction here:

Tired of your shit.
VOTE: vedith
That's hammer.

OMG I was scum!
GG TOWN
GL SCUM BUDDIES!

Feels a bit forced to me more so on Vedith side but still worth noting

UNVOTE:

You're a real dick.

Yeah I think I'm good for calling BBT town at the moment

This is the constitution of your top townread?

[Elena Fisher]

Yes his early reactions to Vedith didn't feel staged at all and he was one of the first few votes of ghost I feel good calling this slot town

[Elena Fisher]

Tchii/Fliz seems like a team I could get with
Unba is the more confident scumread but finding a "teammate" is hard. Everyone can be a teammate of course but you understand what I mean.

[Lucky2u]

I think this is where I am at now.

Town:
-Lucky2u -screen
-
-Elena
-Mulch
-Fitz
-Tchill
-Panther
-Una

In 12 player setup, still unsure we are even looking for a team. But I am ok with a Una panther team. Mulch has me kind of worried for reading my 180 as town, the way I did it should probably have pinged nothing or pinged scum. I'm not over all worried about it though since one interaction does not condemn a person. Fitz looks more town to me then before after the last few posts.i don't think I'll end today there.

So have you read the whole game?

And if you see my read list, I obviously fall into the category of "I think you're far off"

but I have you as a leading scum candidate, so that part can be held aside.

Why is screen top town for you?

What is the basis for your scumread on me?

I don't think we need to explain in too much detail about why we scum read each other. There is zero chance we share a PT. I'll sum it up for you though to give you and everyone else an idea of where I am at after reading day 2 again and paying attention to the interactions. Morality secured the Ghostlin lynch by throwing his towniness behind it. His last reads were that he was going to go after Una, your likely other scum partner who you haven't voted for today because you don't want to bus your last hope. You killed morality because you saw him as the biggest threat of organizing the players on Ghostlin's wagon before your scummy "hammer" and rolling that wagon on over Una and yourself the next day. I see your attacks on screen and myself as a way to undermine that possible town momentum.

Screen is super town, none of the cases you have made against him have swayed me in the slightest. Is there even anyone else that scum reads him right now?

[LlamaFluff]

Vote Count


UnaBombaH (3) - Lucky2u, Elena Fischer, havingfitz
havingfitz (2) - Mulch, Tchill13
PantherPunt (1) - Srceenplay
Srceenplay (1) - PantherPunt

Not Voting (1) - UnaBombaH

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline for Day Three is October 17th, 6:30AM PST. In (expired on 2017-10-17 06:30:00)

[Srceenplay]

3 days. We need to decide this weekend.

[Srceenplay]

Requesting pokes

[UnaBombaH]

Going to read today, and post too.
Stuck with phone though, but work pressure is starting to ease, so I should be able to provide more in the future.

[PantherPunt]

If and when I die please please please kill the living shit out of lucky(bbt)

Ignore whatever you think you know about interactions/votes/etc

That's the most narrative-y writing I've seen in a good year at least

Sheeping the dead not always play #1, but you all have to get on board for this one

[PantherPunt]

I think this is where I am at now.

Town:
-Lucky2u -screen
-
-Elena
-Mulch
-Fitz
-Tchill
-Panther
-Una

In 12 player setup, still unsure we are even looking for a team. But I am ok with a Una panther team. Mulch has me kind of worried for reading my 180 as town, the way I did it should probably have pinged nothing or pinged scum. I'm not over all worried about it though since one interaction does not condemn a person. Fitz looks more town to me then before after the last few posts.i don't think I'll end today there.

So have you read the whole game?

And if you see my read list, I obviously fall into the category of "I think you're far off"

but I have you as a leading scum candidate, so that part can be held aside.

Why is screen top town for you?

What is the basis for your scumread on me?

I don't think we need to explain in too much detail about why we scum read each other. There is zero chance we share a PT. I'll sum it up for you though to give you and everyone else an idea of where I am at after reading day 2 again and paying attention to the interactions. Morality secured the Ghostlin lynch by throwing his towniness behind it. His last reads were that he was going to go after Una, your likely other scum partner who you haven't voted for today because you don't want to bus your last hope. You killed morality because you saw him as the biggest threat of organizing the players on Ghostlin's wagon before your scummy "hammer" and rolling that wagon on over Una and yourself the next day. I see your attacks on screen and myself as a way to undermine that possible town momentum.

Screen is super town, none of the cases you have made against him have swayed me in the slightest. Is there even anyone else that scum reads him right now?

lol seriously read that "you killed morality because.." sentence and tell me how that isn't just a story he wrote

[PantherPunt]

Also, if this game is lost to mulch at some point, you're a pussy for avoiding this game

[Lucky2u]

Eh. I told you not much of a point in us talking about why we scum read one another. One thing though, I've been gone from the site awhile so maybe Im out of touch on this. What's wrong with narritive writing? Are we only allowed to make cases and thoughts in bullet points and quote walls now?

[Mulch]

What do you mean with 580??

it's hard for scum to say that they think one wagon is probably the mislynch wagon that scum want in favor of another wagon, when both of those wagons are actually just town wagons

he didn't need to be deliberating on that thought / imo wouldn't think to show that 'fake' thought as scum, because it's a hard thought to fake when you're looking at town/town wagons on the lynchblock

Ok, agreed.

[Mulch]

h has me kind of worried for reading my 180 as town, the way I did it should probably have pinged nothing or pinged scum.

That's exactly why I townread you for it, I don't understand why you would do that as scum

[Mulch]

Mulch you still don't have this game figured out?

Not really, I'm getting townreads from a lot of people right now. lol. Scum are playing really well

[Mulch]

His last reads were that he was going to go after Una, your likely other scum partner who you haven't voted for today because you don't want to bus your last hope. You killed morality because you saw him as the biggest threat of organizing the players on Ghostlin's wagon before your scummy "hammer" and rolling that wagon on over Una and yourself the next day.

this feels scummy

[Mulch]

Everyone has some sort of townyness to me right now except for Fitz. Panther is becoming townier

[havingfitz]

v/LA for weekend. Will post if I get the chance.

Mulch...why don't you make a case on me so I can tell you why you don't know wtf you are talking about?

[Mulch]

Mulch...why don't you make a case on me so I can tell you why you don't know wtf you are talking about?

I don't have a case on you, I'm sorry

[Lucky2u]

Mulch...why don't you make a case on me so I can tell you why you don't know wtf you are talking about?

I don't have a case on you, I'm sorry

Not sure if you're just kidding here because Fitz asked or if you really are voting on pure feels, but with less than 3 days left I'd like it if you had some reasoning for your only scum read.

[Mulch]

Mulch...why don't you make a case on me so I can tell you why you don't know wtf you are talking about?

I don't have a case on you, I'm sorry

Not sure if you're just kidding here because Fitz asked or if you really are voting on pure feels, but with less than 3 days left I'd like it if you had some reasoning for your only scum read.

Cases are forced reasoning for people, and therefore are for scum. I have reasons but I'm not going through every single one of his posts and trying to spin it in a scum light.

My main reason is that everyone else is townier, he was scummily wrong on ghost lynch, and that post where he was trying to scumread someone for wording was bad . Also he feels scummy to me

[Srceenplay]

Busy times in my work-project have continued..
I'll unvote for now, because apparently Panther is obv.scum(?) that I have missed..
UNVOTE:

VOTE: pantherpunt

I dislike this as a move.
If you are town, unvote please.

I know this game has died down (I'm very busy IRL myself), but Town shouldn't vote for themselves.
I think only scum do it for emotional plays - town does it out of frustration, but it messes reads up.

I wasn't scumreading Panther previously, but just this one self-vote made me feel like it was manipulation.
And town shouldn't need to do that..

I'll try to have time and read tonight - I want to find another perspective to all this, otherwise I'm stuck with sheeping and tunneling.

Why did you stop sheeping and unvote fitz?
You say Panther is obvious scum? But don’t follow up on it. Again you seem to use that as a reason to unvote Fitz.
You say you weren’t previously scum reading Panther but now you are?
Who are you talking about tunneling?

[Srceenplay]

Mulch...why don't you make a case on me so I can tell you why you don't know wtf you are talking about?

I don't have a case on you, I'm sorry

Not sure if you're just kidding here because Fitz asked or if you really are voting on pure feels, but with less than 3 days left I'd like it if you had some reasoning for your only scum read.

Cases are forced reasoning for people, and therefore are for scum. I have reasons but I'm not going through every single one of his posts and trying to spin it in a scum light.

My main reason is that everyone else is townier, he was scummily wrong on ghost lynch, and that post where he was trying to scumread someone for wording was bad . Also he feels scummy to me

Scum reading someone for wording. Show me that post and explain it please.

Could you not also say una was scummily wrong on ghost? I mean honestly una has been right on all the town flip and ghost scum flip was the first he was wrong on.

[UnaBombaH]

You say Panther is obvious scum?

I don't know if my english just sucks, but these kind of misinterpretations seem to happen quite frequently..

I meant that in a more sarcastic and frustrated tone: it seemed like he was scumread by almost everyone, to the degree of "obv.scum". I already misread Ghost myself, so I felt like I'm not going to be able to read anyone correctly this game, if Panther is indeed scum.

Him selfvoting made me REALLY question him, because its not pro-town.
I always hate self-voting, even as a "move", because if town does it, its selfish.