Mini 113:Peril in Per-Djehuty (Game Over)

[jadesmar]

Well, I am here. Probably should do some reviewing.

Anyone want to post a quick summary

BeyondTheGame, what are your thoughts currently?

I note this:
Maverick (Mafia) lynched Day 1
BlueSin (Mafia) lynched Day 2

Well done guys. Who were the lynchers? Or, I suppose, you can keep me in suspense until I read to that part

Anyhow, off to read the thread. More later as I get to it.

[jadesmar]

"Big Kahunia seems to be the best case.. at the moment.. but MeMe can also be Scum... "

At the moment, I would be prone to putting those people in the opposite order. However, this is probably mainly due to MeMe's attempt to plant suspicion on our mason group. Still reading earlier days.

If we have a doctor left.. (and it's likely we do) I would recommend protecting one of the masons randomly tonight. It will be 2 to lynch tomorrow and if both masons are alive, the town can not lose.

Remaining, we either have:
2 masons, 1 cop, and 2 scum
2 masons, 1 cop, 1 doc, and 1 scum

Just remember, folks...big_kahunia is the smart lynch because:
--If we have two scum left, big_kahunia is definitely one of them
--If we have one scum left, it's either me or big_k & it's an inevitable scum loss either today or tomorrow.

Can you repeat this analasis? I have problems with people who leave themselves out as possible scum simply because they "know they don't have to worry about themselves being scum".
I am more apt to trust someone who provides the town with useful analysis. This seems like an attempt to mislead.

[jadesmar]

4) If we have two scum left, we're in a lynch right or lose situation...and the scum MUST include big_k (either me & him or Argoti & him)

What about MeMe and Argoti? Why the MUST? I'm probably overlooking the obvious but, I don't see it.

[jadesmar]

That was not an attack on you Argoti. That was an attack on MeMe's logic in saying this:

MeMe logic:
1. If there are two mafia left we are in a lynch or lose.
2. If there are two mafia left there are only two options and both include big_kahunia
3. Thus, lynch big_kahunia

Please, let me know if that is the logic you are proposing MeMe.

I have issues with point two. And, I propose that MeMe may have purposely left off the third configuration to make her argument stronger. If big_kahunia/Argoti and MeMe/big_kahunia are possible configurations, why not MeMe/Argoti. There must be something I am missing.

[jadesmar]

There must be something I am missing.

If Argoti is scum, who's big_k backing up? No one.

That's what I was missing .. thanks.

In that case, unless Argoti is playing us. It doesn't entirely matter who we vote off today.

[jadesmar]

You are correct MeMe.

I still worry that you and Argoti are playing me here.

And, I would hate to come in as a replacement and cast the town losing vote. It's rather embarassing, trust me.

Anyhow.

vote: big_kahunia

8)

[jadesmar]

Thanks for letting me play. I am quite pleased at the result, though I did find MeMe more suspicious.

This was mainly due to her frustration at the day 1 bandwagon and then coming out with a guilty result as a "newbie" cop who I assumed would have been naive.

Sorry I doubted you MeMe, but I have done the same thing as scum when we needed a quick lynch on the final day.

[jadesmar]

Is it wrong that I still think MeMe is likely to be scum?