Mini Normal 1957: The Perfect LUV Game [Endgame]

[Animetrix]

Can we all compromise on a dunkerdoodles' lynch?

[Apple Jack]

Can we all compromise on a dunkerdoodles' lynch?

What’s your case?

[Chickadee]

Ok here it is:

This group:
Chickadee
Porkens
Derpy
Gurgi
Anime
Nauci
Xiao long

Lynches this group:
Mumble davesaz
Tchill13
Flavor Leaf
Dunkerdoodles

And we take it from there.

VOTE: tchill

Friends, thank you for your welcome.

This is my proposed townbloc.

Thoughts? Swaps?

I would move Dunkerdoodles up. While he hasn't done anything spectacular, I also don't see anything overtly scummy coming from his slot.

Flavor Leaf is in a neutral zone to me, so I really cant say wether I'd put him in either category.

Gorge might be moved down? His ISO is one I want to go through. I'll work on that today.

[Nauci]

Dunk being terse and weird is just Dunk being Dunk. I haven't seen anything AI from him.

I think people willing to wagon him could be scum going for low hanging fruit.

Looking at you, Anime.

[Apple Jack]

nah, dunkers isn't low hanging fruit. he has played long enough he should be doing more/better and the fact he isn't is scummy.

[Nauci]

Should be, yes.

But that's in theory, not in practice.

[Apple Jack]

well then he doesn't get a free pass and people suspicious of them doesn't deserve suspicion. so I guess you can stop looking at Anime, and maybe look at dunker a little more.

[Animetrix]

Can we all compromise on a dunkerdoodles' lynch?

What’s your case?

@Derpy

hello friends
VOTE: Xiao
scummy imo

@fl are you trying something new?

At this point of reading the posts, I noticed that others were picking up my scum vibes for Xiao as well. This post seems just like jumping on a wagon, though. Again no explanation, and it looks like trying to be busy by voting, while asking a question to deflect of the vote.

Hello, I'm replacing Sheep. Mod hasn't announced it yet, hope this is okay.

Gonna call Derp Hooves/Xiao Long team.

1. Xiao Long claimed scum in his first post.
   
2. When feuds aren't actually trying to lynch each other, it's a distancing technique. Seriously, they've been feuding since Derpy's first post.
   
3. First post admitting that they won't be lynching their reads. In this case, we even get an explicit admission that they won't lynch their read/feud in Derpy's first post. Second post admits to a desire to cast the hammer. Scum behavior.
   
4. Couching scumreads as "I don't like anti-town behavior". This is an attempt to build deniability for leaving the wagon if it accidentally grows. Calling it now that Derpy will attempt to defuse any Xiao Long wagon. "I just dislike him, that's not a reason to lynch him".
   
5. Always wagon "fake" hammers.

VOTE: Xiao Long. Starting with the one I'm more confident on.

PS. Hey Porkens, long time.

derpy's town meta is to bus other townies
i saw a game where derpy was scum though and talking about wanting to manipulate his meta by hard tunnelling someone
could be happening here, i''d see him hard bussing early

you seem smart, i'll trust you for now
VOTE: xiao

For someone who wanted Wossi so bad earlier, you were very quick to switch. You are just going to switch because "they seem smart"?

stop this tvt madness and lynch xiao
ty <3

i think there is a scum in (xiao, gurgi, derpy)

Isn't this a contradiction? You said that derpy and wossi were tvt, but then you put derpy in the next post? Dunkerdoodles has become highly suspicious after this post.

i guess ill lynch derpy if we want to

I think after this post, I'd be fine with lynching Dunkerdoodles.

This order of lynching preference for today: Xiao -> Dunkerdoodles -> Wossi

actually on second thought i will do this
VOTE: derpy

Why this sudden change?

Derpy why can't dunkerdoodles have decided to reevaluate? Your read on XL is not materially different from his read on you.

First of all, why are you answering for Dunkerdoodles? This looks a bit like defending. If we are trying to put pressure on him, how does it help for you to answer for them. Secondly, Dunkerdoodles never actually explained why they changed, which is the premises of the whole argument against Dunkerdoodles.

[Chickadee]

well then he doesn't get a free pass and people suspicious of them doesn't deserve suspicion. so I guess you can stop looking at Anime, and maybe look at dunker a little more.

Not a good post.

You're shading Dunk for his play style, and protecting Anime here. Why?

[Animetrix]

it's highly likely that dunkerdoodles and Lord could be teamed because of that last quote.

[Animetrix]

You're shading Dunk for his play style, and protecting Anime here. Why?

Protecting? How? He clearly asked for my case on Dunkerdoodles and was waiting for one. Are you telling me that after ding those quotes I just posted, you aren't the least bit suspicious of Dunkerdoodles?

[Chickadee]

You're shading Dunk for his play style, and protecting Anime here. Why?

Protecting? How? He clearly asked for my case on Dunkerdoodles and was waiting for one. Are you telling me that after ding those quotes I just posted, you aren't the least bit suspicious of Dunkerdoodles?

well then he doesn't get a free pass and people suspicious of them doesn't deserve suspicion.

so I guess you can stop looking at Anime, and maybe look at dunker a little more

.

[Chickadee]

It's not about the quotes you posted, it's about what Derpy, telling people to stop looking at you.

[Apple Jack]

well then he doesn't get a free pass and people suspicious of them doesn't deserve suspicion. so I guess you can stop looking at Anime, and maybe look at dunker a little more.

Not a good post.

You're shading Dunk for his play style, and protecting Anime here. Why?

it absolutely is a good post.

Dunkers is playing scummy so he doesn't get a free pass. Anime has noticed it and wants to scum read him for it. That shows sign of a good player.

You want to ignore it and scum read people who find dunkers scummy aka chainsaw defending dunkers. This is a sign of either scum or a bad player.

[Apple Jack]

@anime - thanks. I could be down for a dunkers wagon.

[Apple Jack]

find it funny that chick comes to dunkers defense first and has the nerve to ask why I am defending somebody.

so chick, why are you defending dunkers?

[Chickadee]

Well by your logic Derpy, you've also been playing a long time, and should be better in regards to your tunneling. So why do we give you a pass and not Dunk? I don't see anything from him that's scummy. Nothing overtly towny, but also nothing scummy. And I never said I scum read Anime.

[Apple Jack]

and i'm sorry but "dunkers being dunkers" or "this is his playstyle" don't work for me.

[Chickadee]

There's no compelling evidence telling me Dunk is scum.

[Apple Jack]

So why do we give you a pass and not Dunk

I honestly don't know why anyone does tbh. They shouldn't. I could totally be scum here pulling the wool over everyone's eyes.

but I find it odd that wossi (who is now confirmed town) got to L-1 without me placing a vote on him.

I'd rather examine the people on that wagon which is sort of what i am doing. I am suspicious of 2/3 people on the wagon and 1 off

[Apple Jack]

There's no compelling evidence telling me Dunk is scum.

his play this game is compelling evidence he could be scum. There isn't much you can point to that looks town.

[Xiao Long]

Don’t start AtE now after all the other stuff you said on D1 about other people being bad players.

whats your Dunkerdoodles read.

Scum

All of his posts are about him not having any reads and just voting randomly which makes me think he’s having trouble developing honest reads cause he already knows who is and isn’t scum.
He also doesn’t ask questions or scumhunt.

It’s possible he’s just a really invisible town, but since I don’t know how he plays, I’m assuming he’s scum.

[Apple Jack]

Don’t start AtE now after all the other stuff you said on D1 about other people being bad players.

whats your Dunkerdoodles read.

Scum

All of his posts are about him not having any reads and just voting randomly which makes me think he’s having trouble developing honest reads cause he already knows who is and isn’t scum.
He also doesn’t ask questions or scumhunt.

It’s possible he’s just a really invisible town, but since I don’t know how he plays, I’m assuming he’s scum.

so he is pushing a dunkers case and has made a bunch of posts explaining why he is scum. that sort of contradicts what you are saying, so what are your thoughts on his case and what is your read of dunkers?

[Xiao Long]

Is that directed at me?

[Tchill13]

I was looking for someone to make the point nauci made when I asked about flavor leaf. So I feel pretty good about nauci being town. Then derpy then chickadee. That's all my town reads. Xl and porkers are my scum reads.