In post 446, Tchill13 wrote:He's a claimed Miller. A NEGATIVE town utility. Do I think he's scum? He could be. I've explained the motivation if he was. Either way we're lynching a suspect in my book. I'd like for everyone to take a hard stance on this circumstance. I obviously have.
Do you not agree though that at this point the negative utility for town is extremely slight? All it means is that a cop can't check him. But by lynching him we're not removing any negative utility, as a cop certainly can't check him if he's dead.
If I have a "must kill before lylo" list then at some point I'll have to deal with it. Sooner is always better than later in mafia.
That is a self-defeating argument. If we have a choice between options X and Y, then it works equally in favor of doing X sooner rather than later as of doing Y sooner rather than later.
i dont agree with your first point. in terms of the miller role specifically sure. he could still be scum and an investigative wouldnt help us due to his claim. as for "X and Y"... if we lynch a townie day one neither x or y is accomplished. so guarantee me we lynch scum day one and i'll agree with you.... You can't. you can't guarantee that.
I claimed miller d1 as town miller .... and became an obv town slot
Why tf can’t we just judge ESP on his play? If he’s scummy we’ll lynch him lol
I don’t like how TChill and SS are continuing to bicker. I feel like one of them is a scum buddy with someone who is a leading wagon. They’re doing an awfully fine job at distracting us
In post 134, JaydragonKing wrote:I don't know if anyone else here clicks on the activity overview, but there's a huge margin between me and Arch - tied with the second most at 14 - and Espeonage at 41.
Holy fuck.
But now I'm more worried about the silent ones. Aristophanes, the guy with his name in green text, stood out the most with literally only one post at the beginning.
I can take my vote of of you, but the last time I did that for Archwing he eventually started calling me scum.
Implying I scum read them because they took their vote off me? Please. You're being scum read because you're being scummy.
In post 220, JaydragonKing wrote:@Quick - I had read the format wiki and read general combinations they commonly used before I signed up for the normal Queue. I think it was "C9" something. It said 2-2-9, and where I learned there could be two separate mafia teams in the first place. Either that, or a Serial Killer.
And I should try to figure out who's lying between Archwing and Espeonage, but since I'm scumlean for the both of them anyway, I'm going to peacefully observe them try and kill each other.
@Tchill13 - Love your Avatar by the way. Reading your post in Tyrion's voice makes it perfect.
This post pings me. If you're calling out two of your scumreads, you should probably push one instead of doing nothing. Scum, or terrible town.
My alignment is town. I will follow the Majority. Unless said majority already wants to kill me.
@Una - I was joking around, considering acidphoenix had a litten icon and you were after each other. Your already trying to hard to distance yourself from me. If I was actually scum, I'd say you were my scum partner. Even saying you wouldn't lose sleep over it? Unnecessary.
I trust Quick much more then I trust Espeonage. I would think the person with 50+ posts already would have a more solid town read. Miller claim either way would buy them another day, and most Vigilantes, I think, wouldn't shoot them.
But if we're settling what we're doing today...
UNVOTE: Leaf VOTE: Archwing
Explicit admitting of sheeping.
In post 252, JaydragonKing wrote:Myself, Una, Espeonage, Tchill, AND doodle still have a vote on Archwing by the way, in case you've forgotten.
If he has five votes already on day 1, odds are he's not town.
This is such bad logic I don't really know how you get here. This is scum pushing a mislynch.
In post 257, JaydragonKing wrote:Well, Aristophanes, if somebody was able to be so suspicious that a third of the town has already decided he's evil - and a few of those five think some of the others are scummy - If we DID let him go now, what do you think is likely to happen? That he can magically gain the trust of the town back after such a blundering day 1?
He's either a mafia or a suspicious vanilla townie, and with it being day one, we can afford the mistake.
@
Assemble
, we're over 250 posts in, would it be fine to ask for an official vote count? I'd rather you check my math and confirm the other votes as well.
In post 455, WhyMafia wrote:I claimed miller d1 as town miller .... and became an obv town slot
Why tf can’t we just judge ESP on his play? If he’s scummy we’ll lynch him lol
I don’t like how TChill and SS are continuing to bicker. I feel like one of them is a scum buddy with someone who is a leading wagon. They’re doing an awfully fine job at distracting us
I mean, in theory the miller claim is part of his play.
I understand Tchill’s hesitance. Risk/reward from lynching claimed miller in Esp is high reward, very little risk.
In post 134, JaydragonKing wrote:I don't know if anyone else here clicks on the activity overview, but there's a huge margin between me and Arch - tied with the second most at 14 - and Espeonage at 41.
Holy fuck.
But now I'm more worried about the silent ones. Aristophanes, the guy with his name in green text, stood out the most with literally only one post at the beginning.
@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
In post 462, Archwing wrote:@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
I was just questioning you. I wasn't scum reading you or anything.
why did you just get super defensive and hostile when i ask you one question?
In post 462, Archwing wrote:@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
I was just questioning you. I wasn't scum reading you or anything.
why did you just get super defensive and hostile when i ask you one question?
In post 462, Archwing wrote:@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
I was just questioning you. I wasn't scum reading you or anything.
why did you just get super defensive and hostile when i ask you one question?
bit of a stretch don't you think?
Possibly, but don't you think he overeacted to just one question.
Archie is giving me even more reason to not move my vote now.
If you want to Lynch me, take your vote off of Espeonage and fully commit. Right now, your just trying to set me up for a day 2 Lynch without even contributing to the conversation about Espeonage. You don't care about the Espeonage Lynch despite your vote being on him and that's bullshit.
I've made mistakes, but I'm still learning the game. Even if Activity is Nai, I'm happier that Aristophanes is contributing more. I asked for the setup because I thought it was possible in normal forum games that the mod have out the possible roles beforehand. I was clearly wrong on that front, but now I know for future games. I joke around in some posts because I like jokes.
Tchill, and everyone else here for that matter, listen to me.
What is it you'd rather have here on day two? A townie with a Negative Utility? Or a townie with a Negative Personality?
In post 446, Tchill13 wrote:He's a claimed Miller. A NEGATIVE town utility. Do I think he's scum? He could be. I've explained the motivation if he was. Either way we're lynching a suspect in my book. I'd like for everyone to take a hard stance on this circumstance. I obviously have.
Do you not agree though that at this point the negative utility for town is extremely slight? All it means is that a cop can't check him. But by lynching him we're not removing any negative utility, as a cop certainly can't check him if he's dead.
If I have a "must kill before lylo" list then at some point I'll have to deal with it. Sooner is always better than later in mafia.
That is a self-defeating argument. If we have a choice between options X and Y, then it works equally in favor of doing X sooner rather than later as of doing Y sooner rather than later.
There will ALWAYS be WIFOM around the Espe slot. And not the good kind where it confuses Scum. It's the bad kind that confuses Town. There is no reason to let Espe live because they might be Town because they also might be Scum.
In post 462, Archwing wrote:@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
I was just questioning you. I wasn't scum reading you or anything.
why did you just get super defensive and hostile when i ask you one question?
bit of a stretch don't you think?
Actually, I know UCV is a young kid (no offense UCV) and I also know he's not an idiot (tho some might disagree). I feel this play from UCV comes from Town most likely because as a young kid who is not an idiot I think UCV would play quite a bit more cautiously as Scum.
In post 462, Archwing wrote:@ucv
-I find it funny cause last game I finished with you, as scum, I tried pushing that activity was AI. obviously failed, and with reason. Now you're questioning me on it, and I'm really wondering why. People in this thread have already stated they come on ~once a day at most.
@uzi
tbh I kinda gut scumread him at the start and he nothing he's done has gotten rid of it. I should honestly go re-read his stuff, but I probably won't until d2 so I can see a flip and see what connections I can make with that. there's no reality in which whymaf is getting d1 lynched anyways. I guess his stuff, to me, has had an edge that I don't particularly find super helpful to town, but then again, you guys have like 3098320 times the meta info on him that I don't. meh. like I said... i'll wait for d2.
Can other people input on esp? What do people think about Elsa? If both of those are not your lynch targets, who is?
I was just questioning you. I wasn't scum reading you or anything.
why did you just get super defensive and hostile when i ask you one question?
bit of a stretch don't you think?
Actually, I know UCV is a young kid (no offense UCV) and I also know he's not an idiot (tho some might disagree). I feel this play from UCV comes from Town most likely because as a young kid who is not an idiot I think UCV would play quite a bit more cautiously as Scum.
TL;DR UCV is too Scummy to be Scum.
I remember the first time someone said this.
And anyone who has read newbie: basketball would know how that ended