Open 705: Polygamist - Game Over

[Mathdino]

pagetop

[Sky_Paladin]

Dino, you can’t go “I dont know how to scum hunt in this setup let’s just roll a dice” and then hand out town reads. You have said repeatedly that you don’t know how to scum hunt but you will give out town reads based on literally nothing.

When I posted I “lost points” but when sheep posted you literally didn’t care.

I accept that you may not know wtf to do but attempting to railroad town into dice rolling and now attempting to railroad town into sheepingnsheep - this and the prior thing reeks of hypocriticalness.

I’m concerned enough that I’m reversing my town read of you and I encourage other players to read the game and take their own view.

[cytheflyguy]

I don't want anyone to comment because I don't want my or Misa's townreads to be influenced by potential scum.

Sky loses massive points for doing the one thing I asked him not to do lol.

If you guys wanna keep have a conversation with each other, by all means do so. I just don't want you to butt into my conversation with Misa.

This game would be a lot more interesting with daytalk tbh.

I can and will respect this.

That being said I think I want to push the sheep counterwagon VOTE: Sheep mostly for wanting more content out of them.

[cytheflyguy]

Dino, you can’t go “I dont know how to scum hunt in this setup let’s just roll a dice” and then hand out town reads. You have said repeatedly that you don’t know how to scum hunt but you will give out town reads based on literally nothing.

When I posted I “lost points” but when sheep posted you literally didn’t care.

I accept that you may not know wtf to do but attempting to railroad town into dice rolling and now attempting to railroad town into sheepingnsheep - this and the prior thing reeks of hypocriticalness.

I’m concerned enough that I’m reversing my town read of you and I encourage other players to read the game and take their own view.

So what is your strategy? I understand where you're coming from, but what is it that you want to do instead? I'm not asking this in a snarky ass way, but if you find problem with him, what is the best course of action that you think we should take instead.

[LlamaFluff]

Vote Count

cytheflyguy (4) - sheepsaysmeep, Mathdino, Toranaga, MisaTange
sheepsaysmeep (3) - Sky_Paladin, DiamondSentinel, cytheflyguy
Kop (1) - Lalendra

Not Voting (4) - Kop, RedFlavor, momo, manrock

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline for day one is January 25th 7PM PST in (expired on 2018-01-25 19:00:00)

[Sky_Paladin]

Hold people accountable for their votes
Vote count analysis on day 2 if we miss.
Engage players in discussion and question strange interactions.
In short everything that you would do in a normal game.

[Mathdino]

Dino, you can’t go “I dont know how to scum hunt in this setup let’s just roll a dice” and then hand out town reads. You have said repeatedly that you don’t know how to scum hunt but you will give out town reads based on literally nothing.

When I posted I “lost points” but when sheep posted you literally didn’t care.

I accept that you may not know wtf to do but attempting to railroad town into dice rolling and now attempting to railroad town into sheepingnsheep - this and the prior thing reeks of hypocriticalness.

ok fine i'll respond to this

1. Scumhunting =/= townhunting. Townhunting is easier. It's extremely rare that my strongest D1 early read ends up being scum.

2. I thought it was obvious that I wanted to restrict that conversation to me and my lover because I don't want her to be influenced. Now that's unavoidable. You knew this. sheep on the other hand literally did not notice that I was lovers with that particular replacement. I give that a free pass. He didn't actually influence anything because he didn't know wtf he was talking about.

3. She's my lover, of course I'm going to ask her to vote with me. If there's one positive point to sheep's play (which isn't great) it's that he's actually paying attention to my strategy. I don't know wtf to do and I fundamentally believe towns IN GENERAL don't know wtf to do in this setup, even if they think they do.

@sheep:

I was hoping for a quicklynch by now but I might as well ask since you're gonna get a lot of flak for this. I don't particularly care either way but

Why are we all still voting cy when you said you had a townread on them earlier?

[Mathdino]

@Everyone:

You know the post by post tl;dr I did of the longer posts in the game?

I want everyone to post a tl;dr of their lover PTs with every single post included. Even if your lover already did.

[Mathdino]

I already claimed this as did Misa.

[Mathdino]

I want DiamondSentinel to go before SkyPaladin.

[Sky_Paladin]

UNVOTE: sheep
VOTE: dino

I am vla and been reading the game through a phone. I had literally no idea that you were talking to your replacement friend. Your assumption that sheep didn’t know is stretching and your explanation look like ass pulls to me.

I would be done with your open wolfing sir.

[Toranaga]

@Everyone:

You know the post by post tl;dr I did of the longer posts in the game?

I want everyone to post a tl;dr of their lover PTs with every single post included. Even if your lover already did.

eh I mean, it's closed and neither me nor the guy who got replaced by sheep posted in it

[Toranaga]

MisaTange replaces Amrochora

RIP amrochora

hi misatange

[Toranaga]

Dino, you can’t go “I dont know how to scum hunt in this setup let’s just roll a dice” and then hand out town reads. You have said repeatedly that you don’t know how to scum hunt but you will give out town reads based on literally nothing.

When I posted I “lost points” but when sheep posted you literally didn’t care.

I accept that you may not know wtf to do but attempting to railroad town into dice rolling and now attempting to railroad town into sheepingnsheep - this and the prior thing reeks of hypocriticalness.

I’m concerned enough that I’m reversing my town read of you and I encourage other players to read the game and take their own view.

none of that is alignment indicative for dino. he doesn't know how to scumhunt because it's a lolsetup, but he is still seeing things he consider towntells and then he goes ahead and makes a read. if you see e.g. how he lock cleared our slot as 'literally nothing', then you don't understand where the read is coming from.

IDK how these things are basis for you to reverse your read on dino but maybe you're scum so it would make sense to start casting shade on him. what do you think of cy?

[Mathdino]

Tora, sheep, how many posts are in your PT?

[Mathdino]

Hold people accountable for their votes
Vote count analysis on day 2 if we miss.
Engage players in discussion and question strange interactions.
In short everything that you would do in a normal game.

You know this statistically makes us more likely to lose. Like, you know that. We've had this conversation. Not gonna have it again. But if you're actually interested in reading me and you've been paying attention, you should know exactly what my motivation is. Tora/sheep don't seem to have trouble understanding me.

I am vla and been reading the game through a phone.

I had literally no idea that you were talking to your replacement friend

. Your assumption that sheep didn’t know is stretching and your explanation look like ass pulls to me.

Ok I mean I believe the underlined. So you regain lost points for that.
But calling my response/explanation "ass pulls" and making it sound not-obvious that sheep didn't see, AND THEN STILL misunderstanding the reason that you lost points and why I'm trying to restrict my conversation with my lover? Loses the same points.
I'll give you a tempo free pass since you're phoneposting so you do have an excuse to be paying 0 attention. But your case on sheep is balls and all 4 of you have been completely ineffective at actually addressing why I'm townreading that slot, so your slot is clearly uninterested in diplomacy. Hope things get better after your V/LA.

IDK how these things are basis for you to reverse your read on dino but maybe you're scum so it would make sense to start casting shade on him. what do you think of cy?

Couple things.

1. If you're town, which I assume you are, understand that scum knows this is an accurate townbloc and if we truly lynch randomly among the remaining slots, there's a 1/6 chance they'll make it out alive. This is another case of "town COULD be doing this, but scum MUST do it". Scum HAS to break up the townbloc in order to win. Unfortunately it doesn't make Diamond/Sky obvscum. But it definitely clears them against being locktown.

2. Do you have a good explanation as to why you're not playing your own town meta? I know you rely on meta a lot. Have been meta-ing you.

[momo]

Okay guys i'm going to read now...until I finish, nobody is to vote.

If you must use the hurt tags like so:

Code: Select all

[hurt][/hurt]

Scum only needs two mislynched to win, in that time, we must get a lynch...so, this is the day before lylo....no hasty votes or anything of the sort...

we will come to a hurt majority through discussion before actually lynching

[sheepsaysmeep]

Tora, sheep, how many posts are in your PT?

only two of llama's

[Mathdino]

Tora, sheep, how many posts are in your PT?

only two of llama's

Wait what? Dude there should be 3.

Did you read the post numbers and see the last one read #2?

[sheepsaysmeep]

nope
#0 was this is your pt for pregame
#1 was just this is now closed
nothing between

[Mathdino]

Did you just scumslip? There's definitely 3. Two initial Llama posts and one "this is closed".

VOTE: Tora

[momo]

md, we only have 2 llama posts in our pt.....

however, I'm tonwreading you for that post because scum wouldn't insist

[sheepsaysmeep]

however, I'm tonwreading you for that post because scum wouldn't insist

lie
nai

[Mathdino]

momo ruined it. Hope the reaction test wasn't too obvious or it's NAI for sheep. But for now sheep is locktown to me again.

VOTE: cytheflyguy

Sheep, please answer my question in post 256

Momo, please answer my question in post 257.

[Mathdino]

Okay guys i'm going to read now...until I finish, nobody is to vote.

If you must use the hurt tags like so:

Code: Select all

[hurt][/hurt]

Scum only needs two mislynched to win, in that time, we must get a lynch...so, this is the day before lylo....no hasty votes or anything of the sort...

we will come to a hurt majority through discussion before actually lynching

This is extremely anti-town (I don't think you realise it). Hurt votes are unaccountable and can be easily used by scum to muddle up their associations.

Sorry but speedlynching > speedhurting.