Open 705: Polygamist - Game Over

[sheepsaysmeep]

pagetop

[RedFlavor]

u r right sky....red's entire iso is setup spec to appear towny and a random vote on cy that says let's go...indicating that he is scum going for a push...i'll bite

VOTE: RedFlavor

Ill sheep math cuz I think he is town and we are likely to win when we follow a townie even its rng

[Mathdino]

u r right sky....red's entire iso is setup spec to appear towny and a random vote on cy that says let's go...indicating that he is scum going for a push...i'll bite

VOTE: RedFlavor

Ill sheep math cuz I think he is town and we are likely to win when we follow a townie even its rng

Would you sheep me on anyone?

Like is there anyone I could vote that you wouldn't vote for?

[RedFlavor]

Yeah hyung (IDK where are they)
Also whoever is your hydra

[hyung]

Hi everyone. This is my first game and I'm definitely a bit behind but I'll catch up when I can.

[Mathdino]

Oh dear god.

[Mathdino]

Hi everyone. This is my first game and I'm definitely a bit behind but I'll catch up when I can.

hyung, you were sent a link to a Lover Private Topic in your role PM.

Please go post by post in the topic explaining/paraphrasing what happened.

[Mathdino]

From what manrock said (your replacement) there were 3 posts in your PT, yes?

[hyung]

If you're asking about the person I replaced, all they said was that they were gonna hit a lot of posts but I'm guessing that never happened. Not claiming my Lover or their stuff yet though.

I'll be back later, at work right now and just wanted to check in.

[Mathdino]

I'm lovers with MisaTange. Most of us have claimed already.

Can you at least summarise your lover's posts if you don't want to claim lovers?

[Mathdino]

Wait okay I found scum guys. Never reread the early game lol.

Read pages 1 and 2 (the source of the best reads) and see how I know a certain couple of players are scum.

[DiamondSentinel]

Wait okay I found scum guys. Never reread the early game lol.

Read pages 1 and 2 (the source of the best reads) and see how I know a certain couple of players are scum.

Is it Tor? Because that's the most likely scum-slot in that list aside from you and sheep.

[Mathdino]

Wait okay I found scum guys. Never reread the early game lol.

Read pages 1 and 2 (the source of the best reads) and see how I know a certain couple of players are scum.

Is it Tor? Because that's the most likely scum-slot in that list aside from you and sheep.

If that's your guess, tell me how I know.

[Sky_Paladin]

Overnight I reflected on whether there was any value in continuing the dice discussion. I think that I'm investing more ego into 'being right' than 'this is good for town'. All the math talk is non alignment indicative noise that shits up the thread with posts that make it harder to follow through. So I'm going to let it slide and revisit the math after the game, once alignments are known, and for now say "Mathematically you are likely correct, however I would prefer not to psuedo-random lynch because game enjoyment reasons". AKA in the cold light of dawn I wonder if this was just a giant town-v-town rant and I need to revisit.

Dino

Wait okay I found scum guys. Never reread the early game lol.

Read pages 1 and 2 (the source of the best reads) and see how I know a certain couple of players are scum.

Well your options from pages 1-2 are Tora, Red, Sky, Sheep, Diamond (I think that's everybody) and since we presume you're not scum, I'm not scum, and le-diamond are not scum, that narrows it down pretty quickly. There's the Sheep/Tora slot and the Red-slot. That's not enough to find 'all the scum' but since one hit counts for all it's good enough ^_~ I'm going to presume that you are still townlocking sheep/naga until otherwise specified so that narrows it down to Red.

I don't really like the Sheep-Tora slot as you are no doubt aware but I am increasingly less inclined to see the Dino-Tora connection that I thought was concrete yesterday.

My main issues with Red are what Momo pointed out (and incorrectly attributed to me), which is reflected in pages 1 and 2, that Red is super casual with his vote and just parks it wherever, and immediately subscribed to the dice roll idea, while Manrock (his partner iirc) was against it. However Manrock never really did anything and replaced out. This did not look like a strategic replace-out in any way so I don't think that replace is AI.
Red completely slipped under my radar to the point that I was passively town reading them. I'm not entirely sure how that happened and that bothers me a lot.

Consequently I am super interested in seeing what Hyule brings to the table.

[sheepsaysmeep]

ooh finding scum

[sheepsaysmeep]

let's find scum before hyung gets to do anything

[Sky_Paladin]

I'm going to clarify why I think Red subscribing to die roll is a scummy thing even though we might presume that random lynch is towny - he did so apparently without evaluating if it was good or bad, and it looked like "Here is an opportunity to vote park without having to be accountable for my vote". Even Sheep has expressed some distaste for that which shows they've put in some thought and -ugh- is indicative of town alignment.

[Mathdino]

sheep please do the work I asked you to do xD

No one has told me why I know a certain player/player pair is scum.

Edit: @Sky: Yeah your logic on Red is valid from your perspective as town (PoE helps a lot). I just don't know you're town so it's not nearly as valid to me.

[sheepsaysmeep]

wait what i have to do work
what now

[sheepsaysmeep]

what work i probably wont do it lol

[sheepsaysmeep]

i didnt find scum in the first two pages :/

[Mathdino]

Look harder. Think about the kinds of things that I would see. You should know me as a player pretty ok by now.

[sheepsaysmeep]

or i can go to soccer practice
be back in some hours
i can hold off on homework tonight

[DiamondSentinel]

Wait okay I found scum guys. Never reread the early game lol.

Read pages 1 and 2 (the source of the best reads) and see how I know a certain couple of players are scum.

Is it Tor? Because that's the most likely scum-slot in that list aside from you and sheep.

If that's your guess, tell me how I know.

All my reads are gut.

[LlamaFluff]

Mathblade replaces MisaTange