The Mod Is Mafia (Game Over)

[CheekyTeeky]

Sup. No idea what I've got myself into. I've tried catching up (up to pg 17) but half the posts are mutilated and I can't tell what's what.

Have you all figured out how mastina works yet? Is there a pattern to her post manipulation? Do the majority think she would WIFOM, or treat her scum minions the same as us?

In a way if we can break mastina's code we can probably break the game and easy win. Any strat ideas, or important points in the game so far would help me heaps.

[CheekyTeeky]

Creature feels yuck. What's the VC?

I'll probs have to make reads from interactions in real time instead of sifting through the thread.

[CheekyTeeky]

UNVOTE: Just in case.

[CheekyTeeky]

Hi Key

Code/pattern. Awesome thanks heaps! It sounds like she's framing mulch, but you're right, it's hard to figure out if that's AI just yet. Were there certain types of posts/content that were deleted? I'll go back a few pages and feel things out and check last VC.

Pedit - well you're all wrong and need to get off lol.

[CheekyTeeky]

Why is mulch self-voting? With 4 scum, it's unlikely all 4 are on my wagon when there's 6 in total. Not_Mafia seems too proactive to get my wagon through. Doesn't he usually just lurk? Not sure what his lurk meta is: town vs scum. I think I'd be assuming too much to say he's scum for being more active this game, compared to the 1 game I've played with him. Hmm.

[CheekyTeeky]

Please. I'm town, and even if I weren't, better players than you have tried to come at me.
Also, after that shit you pulled fake-scum-claiming last game...I should by all rights grudge-lynch you for the next 6 months.

And I scumread you cuz you are a fucking automaton. You are the most robotic player I know, and your dumb latching onto what you convince yourself my meta is ...it's a crapcase, and crapcases are scummy.

And just cuz Mulch is checked out and you are checked in doesn't mean you are town.

This whole post is awful.

Ego + grudge + ad hom + bad logic (you play predictably and are bad at meta reading me, which is not a good argument...therefore bad arguments are scummy LOL) Also the last line is bad logic.

I'm sure you guys can see that this entire post is rubbish/fluff/non-content, intended to discredit the Prism/Keychain hydra. If I'm missing a pro-town point in here please let me know.

[CheekyTeeky]

Ffs... You feel exactly the same.

VOTE: mulch

YOU FEEL EXACTLY THE SAME!

Is your scumgame just that good? I don't think so.
Maybe I can never trust again, tho.

I want something other than a Mulch wagon.

look: Moonlight. Mulch. You are both town. So stop it. You guys are just wrong about each other.

Lets focus on the places we agree: Stalfos.
The ball is in my court, lets lynch them with it.

I don't understand Camn's read progression on mulch. Was the paranoia at the beginning a front? Also, not sure why she's voting Stalfos for sheeping mulch, when she town reads him. What is AI about sheeping? If anything it's usually town who sheep other town reads, scum are probably more afraid to overtly sheep imo. Also, OMGUS is how I get my reads as town, so NAI...this wagon is pretty shit for the reasons Camn is pushing it for assuming "etc" is bs reasoning.

I will ISO Stalfos and mulch next.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Mulch

Let's make this official for now. After all, it'll make mastina angry, and I think I sorta wanna do that this game in addition to hunting scums.

This is the scummiest thing I've noticed so far but I'm going to bed now. I'll give you all a break.

[CheekyTeeky]

Yup, this slot is scum

You're wrong. Get off :/

[CheekyTeeky]

I think we should start choosing a lynch.

Can we choose you?

[CheekyTeeky]

Can we choose you?

You can choose whomever you want, cupcake, but Creature's town and sticking hid neck out. You'd better have a damn good reason.

I was looking for a reaction from him, but yours will do instead. Why is he town? How is he sticking his neck out?

[CheekyTeeky]

Also his Creature vote has no trajectory, and fucking stinks because right now, Creature reads "hey guys, I give a shit and am town and getting sick of these shitty mechanics."

Is this why?

[CheekyTeeky]

So why would mastina target mulch and creature so often with deleting/editing posts in contrast to others?

[CheekyTeeky]

Yes I made an earlier post about it possibly being WIFOM and if any pattern has been detected yet. I suspect she'd be less likely to attract attention to her minions but not obviously so. In effect it's just another form of info we can use to assess people's alignments on top of scum hunting. Maybe we should quote what we're referring to so that players being quoted can dispute whether what we're analysing is true or not.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE PRISM HYDRA

BUT WHY

[CheekyTeeky]

I put more effort as scum than town

I think I actually believe this, but I hate self-meta. I also don't understand the readon for your Stalfos read. :/

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Mulch just gonna park tbh. No one wants to wagon not hebi for some strange reason.

Miltank's are distracting; their udders are hypnotic.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Cheekyteeky

Are you not a fan of Pokemon Go or do you actually, shock horror, have a read?

[CheekyTeeky]

Are you not a fan of Pokemon Go or do you actually, shock horror, have a read?

I am curious why you're bothering to interact with this, since grapes, according to his ISO, has done fuck all and I can't be bothered to remember he's actually in this game.

Noted, maybe he only speaks his language.

VOTE: grapes

<<< Fixing capitalization. >>>

[CheekyTeeky]

uhh, you sure you're town Ghostlin?

That IS what my Role PM says. I didn't necessarily grapes was scum, just until NOW he was fairly useless, and the whole 'gasp, you hate Pokemon Go or do you have a reason' seems really weird on one vote that just sorta floating there. There's no reason for Cheeky to react. That's what I'm responding to.

You don't get my dry humour I'm trying to get reads based on whats in front of me atm. Maybe you'll get used to me maybe you won't - but like your suspicion seems really weird because how do you know how I should and shouldn't react?

[CheekyTeeky]

You fools. See I was right about grapes only speaking his language and he's shot down his own argument. Boom.

[CheekyTeeky]

Who do you think is scum cheeky?

I'm trying to work that out. I don't know if you're scum bro I just wanted you to talk. I promise I'll enlighten you all when I get some.

[CheekyTeeky]

Aronis I think you're blowing the pagetop thing out of proportion. How do you know mastina won't alter it later? How do we know you're not scum for struggling with mastina over pagetops?

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Aronis lets get rid of this.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Mathblade The pagetop slip is quite damming.

Why do you think this implicates math more than Aronis?

[CheekyTeeky]

Aronis didn't get the pagetop did he? #1325 belongs to Mathblade. Now, if Aronis initially had that number, but Mastina deleted his post to frame Mathblade with the pagetop, I'd string up Aronis in a second. However, I see no evidence such a thing occurred.

I think we're misunderstanding each other. I think the Aronis/mastina struggle over page tops is more scummy than Math holding one. That makes me feel like mastina is subtly framing Math. I might not be getting your point on what you mean by the slip though?

[CheekyTeeky]

The only person who ever fights me for Pagetops is mastina and she's confscum. So like there's no way you can't be scum too

It's pretty obvious that Math wasn't intentionally fighting for the page top? Wth am I missing here?

[CheekyTeeky]

Lmao. Look I page topped! I r scum.

Pedit - no I think he replaced out his head.

[CheekyTeeky]

NEVER GONNA SAY GOODBYE

[CheekyTeeky]

NEVER GONNA TELL A LIE

[CheekyTeeky]

And hurt yoooooooooooooou

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Mathblade The pagetop slip is quite damming.

Wut.

Mathblade doesn't mention a page top, that was Aronis and how does this inform you that they're scum?

Or to put this another way: what the fuck are you on?

Pretty sure ghostlins scum with mastina and Mathblade. No way they'd question something so obvious otherwise

A thousand posts after your initial scum read you now have this masterpiece.

[CheekyTeeky]

Creature you're all over the place but I'm getting town vibes. Esp at the beginning of your ISO.

[CheekyTeeky]

I feel like mulch is town and Stalfos is a concern. I agree with mulch on this one.

[CheekyTeeky]

I feel like mulch is town and Stalfos is a concern. I agree with mulch on this one.

Hi, I hope you aren't pocketing me Cheeks!

Dese pants don't have pockets yo.

[CheekyTeeky]

But seriously, when I ISO'd you, you raised points on them that matched my concerns. When I've looked at everyone I'll do a list thing.

[CheekyTeeky]

So far Aronis, Not_Mafia, massive, Stalfos, Camn feel weird.
Creature, mulch, massive, MM4 feel aight.

[CheekyTeeky]

UNVOTE: I am going to place my vote on VOTE: Salfos now for a few reasons:

1. The analysis, especially the original catch up post, are lacking in the complexity that I would expect of Prism after their newbie game;

2. I think that while I can see how a townsperson could believe not_mafia's behavior as scummy, I definitely see how that could be an easy push for scum to make, and I am sort of holding Prism to a higher standard because I think they would be the type of person to take the fact it might be a playstyle scumread into consideration;

3. The experimental scumtells that I notice are similar to my scum game and their perspective of preemptively finding flaws in their posts;

4. Another one where I can "see" how they might think this but it feels like it could easily be a scum push as well...the scumreading Aronist for their unwarranted townread of Camn. The thing is, I could easily follow Aronis here. I'm wondering if they are just doing this because it's easy to say "wow, a townread based on nothing!" when if they actually went into detail on it, they could follow their perspective....

5. Scumreading Camn for LAMIST type statements- ditto to numbers 2 and 4, could easily be from town or from scum as an easy push;

6. Finally, the one I think is the most damning- the scumread on Camn based on the fact they did not senor their thoughts seems like a real reach and not something people would do as town.


1- Meta
3. Experimental Scumtells
6. Very bad push
2, 4, 5- "easy" pushes that could come from scum OR town-basically "wrong" pushes, or pushing of NAI things, yet I could see town that disagree with my perspective on what is scummy doing this too...

This relates to point 1 as well because I consider Prism's towngame to be very good and somewhat less likely to do the "misguided" pushes.

There's more than awful meta to go off.

[CheekyTeeky]

Is it possible for you to lay out a case for mulch as scum without referring to meta Stalfos? I would really like to untangle both of you from the meta talk and look at your actions this game objectively. I haven't played with Prism and I have no completed games with Key or mulch. What is scummy about mulch this game?

[CheekyTeeky]

Mulch why did you stop pushing Stalfos?

[CheekyTeeky]

It was probably exhausting, Cheeky.
Are you seeing the size of those words?

On a scale of small to supercalafragilisticexpialidocious, I'd say a 6?

[CheekyTeeky]

Mulch why did you stop pushing Stalfos?

Sounding scummy to me

Wtf?

[CheekyTeeky]

You realize the last few posts of mulch have literally been 'you look scummy', 'mislynch foiled', one (to me, for full disclosure) 'you're next' (I admit, I giggled at that one), and votes on the lynch that's not him du jour. We have no reads, no substance, and dealing with him has been a gigantic pain in the ass. If Mulch ISN'T scum due to some miracle not observed by normal mortals, and fucking somehow that's a mislynch, he's so negative utility to Town, mastina might as well have fgiven him a scum PM that literally said 'you are the uberscum. Your post restriction is that you need to be scummer than me in the thread and I'm CONFIRMED SCUM.' While I could lynch Theta, we should really make this scumtard eat dubious amount of rope first. Typing this entire post on what a scumfuck Mulch is IS ACTIVELY MAKING ME ANGRY HOW YOU'RE LETTING HIM GET AWAY WITH IT.

Dude, you are added to my townblock.

Too bad you and Not Mafia disagree on reads.

Dude you are NEVER having a town block. You are going to eat rope if I have ANYTHING to say about it.

Is this a scum claim Math? How does this come from a townie?

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Not_Mafia

[CheekyTeeky]

So Cheeky, you finally voted Not Mafia. That feel good?

Hell yeah OMGUS always feels good.

[CheekyTeeky]

What's the VC on mulch?

[CheekyTeeky]

Index
Top of OP.
Game Status.
Deadline.
Players.
Rules.
Notable Events .
Current VC.
Mechanics.
Log: Voted.
Log: Voting.
Log: Chronology.
Log: S-Peaks.
Log: C-Peaks.
Log: Base VCs.
Log: Ghosted VCs.
End of Day VCs.

Game Events/Links

Notable Events

:

Role PMs are sent.
Day One Begins.

Spoiler: D1 Events

Votecount 1-1.

Most Recent Votecount

Current Votecount

:

First Votecount

:

Mulch - 1 (Smocaine)

Not_Mafia - 1 (Mulch)

Creature - 0 (

mastina

)

Not Voting - 16 (Mathblade, Aronis, camn, SnarkySnowman, Theta Alpine, MarioManiac4, hebichan, Stalfos, Yume, Not_Mafia, Nosferatu, Kise, grapes, Creature, Radiant Moonlight, massive)

With

18

alive, it takes

10

to lynch.

At deadline,

Mulch

would be lynched.

Day 1's deadline is Sunday, October 15th, @ 2:30 PM PDT: (expired on 2017-10-15 17:38:19).

V/LA Notices/Mod Notes:

• mastina, the moderator, is V/LA over weekends.
  
  

Extras

Spoiler: Changes from Last Votecount

(+1)

Mulch - 1 (Smocaine)

(+1)

Not_Mafia - 1 (Mulch)

(+0)

Creature - 0 (

mastina

)

(-2)

Not Voting - 16 (Mathblade,

Mulch

, Aronis, camn, SnarkySnowman, Theta Alpine, MarioManiac4, hebichan, Stalfos, Yume, Not_Mafia, Nosferatu, Kise,

Smocaine

, grapes, Creature, Radiant Moonlight, massive)

Last votecount was post 138, page 6.

Spoiler: Player Vote History Day One

• Mathblade(0):
  
  
• Mulch(1):
  Not_Mafia
  
• Aronis(0):
  
  
• camn(0):
  
  
• SnarkySnowman(0):
  
  
• Theta Alpine(0):
  
  
• MarioManiac4(0):
  
  
• hebichan(0):
  
  
• Stalfos(0):
  
  
• Yume(0):
  
  
• Not_Mafia(0):
  
  
• Nosferatu(0):
  
  
• Kise(0):
  
  
• Smocaine(1):
  Mulch
  
• grapes(0):
  
  
• Creature(0):
  
  
• Radiant Moonlight(0):
  
  
• massive(0):

Spoiler: Players Who Have BEEN Voted Day One

1. Mulch:
   - 1 (Smocaine)
   
2. Not_Mafia:
   - 1 (Mulch)
   
3. Creature:
   - 0 (mastina)

Spoiler: Voting Chronology Day 1

On Sun, Sep 09/24/17 @ 02:39p,

Smocaine

Voted

Mulch

in post 139.
On Sun, Sep 09/24/17 @ 02:40p,

Mulch

Voted

Not_Mafia

in post 140.
On Sun, Sep 09/24/17 @ 02:59p,

mastina

Voted

Creature

in post 142.

Return to top of post.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Mulch L-1 yo. If you have any last words please say so now. The one beheading needs to announce intent to sever prior to swinging the blade.

[CheekyTeeky]

I don't think scum self-hammers in that spot.

[CheekyTeeky]

GG scum