Open 708: Pick Your Poison - Game Over

[mozamis]

moz, penguin, thor town. P.O.E ahoy!

moz,penguin,thor, beef town

[mozamis]

i liked Athena's post because she go stuck into the scumhunting straight away and i liked Penguin's initial response endorsing the line of enquiry.

call it gut or w/e. Maybe my standard of having a early town-lean is looser than other people's.
and as you can see with my current read on Penguin - it's not binding anyway

agree with thtese reads, cult looked town.
max look stown.

[mozamis]

moz, penguin, thor town. P.O.E ahoy!

moz,penguin,thor, beef town

moz,penguin,thor,beef,cult,max= town.

s

o scum in Klick, Hewho,Errant,Flubber,Bella, Tex,Moneybags

3scum in 7, not a bad lynch pool for day 1.
Before people go mental, these are PROVISIoney
ONAL DAY 1 reads. I like to be captain obvious, get a sensible lynch pool going for day 1.
I AM NOT SAYING THAT TOWN POOL are confirmed. It just helps me focus.
But yeah, we should defintely be looking at those 7

[mozamis]

the edit went weird
*provisional day 1 reads

[mozamis]

flubber is close to that towbloc as well

[mozamis]

anyone else think that those interactions between Bella and Klick were scum and scum? they didnt seem very suspicious of each other?
totally happy with calling scum team of Bella, Kilck and Hewhoswims atm.

[texcat]

It didn't look like scum & scum to me. Did I miss something that you saw?

[Maxous]

back.
gimme a bit to get caught up

[Moneybags]

moz, penguin, thor town. P.O.E ahoy!

moz,penguin,thor, beef town

moz,penguin,thor,beef,cult,max= town.

s

o scum in Klick, Hewho,Errant,Flubber,Bella, Tex,Moneybags

3scum in 7, not a bad lynch pool for day 1.
Before people go mental, these are PROVISIoney
ONAL DAY 1 reads. I like to be captain obvious, get a sensible lynch pool going for day 1.
I AM NOT SAYING THAT TOWN POOL are confirmed. It just helps me focus.
But yeah, we should defintely be looking at those 7

I'd like to know why you, or anyone else who agree, thinks PP is town. I can see someone not thinking he's scum. I can why someone wouldn't be ready to come to that conclusion. I can't see how someone could think he's confirmed town simply based on "timing argument is bad." Just because the argument is null doesn't confirm or exempt PP from being town. It's his reaction that counts.

[Moneybags]

Addendum: I realize your list is not confirmed town, and I shouldn't have used the sentence " I can't see how someone could think he's confirmed town..." as that leads to confusion. It should more accurately read " I can't see how someone gets a town vibe from him simply because he was on the receiving end of a null argument".

[Beefster]

VOTE: CultOfAthena

Let's try something completely different.

But why? We have several fairly good leads right now.

The flubber wagon felt stale at the time, but it seems to be picking up momentum. She's been pinging my scumdar. She feels very methodical/mechanical in her posts.

VOTE: Flubber

I am still suspicious of COA.

[Beefster]

These posts look like newbscum, but mozamis is obviously no newb.

why?

The posts I pointed out looked a bit like alignment overcompensation, but it probably would only be a scum tell if you were new to the site. It's the kind of thing I feel like new players tend to do often as scum. At any rate, it's not a very strong overcompensation, so it probably wouldn't be all that telling even if you were a newb.

[Maxous]

Maxous, why wouldn't you want t engage with Q and A over your early town reads?

is this the question?
Because i thought it would be rather tedious...which it has been.
They were only early town feels and explaining them felt like pulling out teeth.

[Maxous]

I feel like this miscommunication is due to a very polar difference in our play styles. So far I've been making passing comments to generate discussion. You have been interrogating people which gets reactions and also generates discussion. I can see why you would take an issue with me being less confrontational.

It's not a playstyle issue.

You opted to call me out.
You did not opt to call out anyone else.
I'm asking why and you're not answering yet.

@Moneybags - 5th verse, same as the first.

Thor, what changed from 110

Nothing.
What do you think changed?

I like the idea of a Flub v. Tex wagon adventure.
Bella is now an acceptable lynch to me also.
Beefster is wasting time.
Errant is playing right near the very edge of strategic lurking and should knock that crud off.

VOTE: Flubbernugget

uhhhhhhh
this is a poor vote
why exactly is he voting flubber?

[Klick]

I'm not comfortable with this Flubber wagon. This feels misguided and fishy.

Looking into this later today.

[Klick]

UNVOTE:

[Moneybags]

That's really strange considering some of the decent evidence to be had against him.

[Maxous]

not entirely sure if it's playstyle or alignment but texcat is a little quiet.
she's only talking about a select few people.

[Maxous]

i kind of want to vote penguin because of his messy early-game defence and weird vote on me but i did say i would give him a chance to get back into the game and judge from there

i'm still very meh on Bella, so i'm alright leaving the vote here. her last few posts won't particularly scummy but i didn't see anything towny from them either

I don't approve of a Flubber wagon

[Thor665]

I replied to that post in 168.

To clarify my issue - it's the timing for me.
You attacked me in a sideline way.
When asked you stepped back to try to call it a neutral opinion (ignoring that your initial comment was straight up attack) and also then tossed out other thoughts that you didn't opt to share until called on it and then claimed those thoughts were actually similar/identical to your initial call out even though you didn't initially state them at that time.

You're scummy to me now.
If you get a better answer to that issue feel free to toss it out.

EP said they have been sick. Even still they've contributed more than Tex and PP.

Are you calling that scummy?
Are you saying you think EP needs votes?
You're sidelining again.

Errant is playing right near the very edge of strategic lurking and should knock that crud off.

I'm disappointing you yet again! I'm in travel all of today, driving back to uni. Scout's honor I'll be here when I get back.

You've already lied to me about when you'd post next once, I'll try not to be too disappointed if this is another lie.

s

o scum in Klick, Hewho,Errant,Flubber,Bella, Tex,Moneybags

3scum in 7, not a bad lynch pool for day 1.
Before people go mental, these are PROVISIoney
ONAL DAY 1 reads. I like to be captain obvious, get a sensible lynch pool going for day 1.
I AM NOT SAYING THAT TOWN POOL are confirmed. It just helps me focus.
But yeah, we should defintely be looking at those 7

Have you looked at those 7 yet and come to any thoughts?

I am still suspicious of COA.

Why?

uhhhhhhh
this is a poor vote
why exactly is he voting flubber?

Why is it a poor vote?

Also, if you dislike my vote, why are you totally fine with Beefster's 210?

[mozamis]

It's his reaction that counts.

exactly.his reaction looked town toe me, he gave as good as he got, didnt try and shirk the issue, slightly annoyed, all town tells. probably lol

[mozamis]

that was about Penguin.

[mozamis]

later saying he wouldn't clarify bc he didn't wanna get into q and a about it? hiding information isn't helping town.

but he was OPEN about saying "dont wat to get into yet, and then he DID gvien them when pushed.
Think you are really reaching/sheeping what someone else said about max.

[mozamis]

Due to request, I will use a darker blue for now

POWER TO THE PEOPLE!

[Flubbernugget]

Thor voting for me after "not pushing me" because they're interested in me vs tex interactions is some absolute weaksauce