In post 2939, Kmd4390 wrote: In post 2933, Chara wrote:sure it's common sense, but a night 1 kill isn't just "take out confirmed town". there are other utilities of the scum kill besides removing an IC. taking out a strong town voice makes more sense. even if confirmed town, how much sway does Cabd have in the game?
That's one of many strategies, yes. So is killing confirmed town before they get confirmed.
___________
Mathdino says:
-he hasn't even analyzed since the flips and will give better reads later
-Almost50, RC, Eddie, and Bins should be able to back him up on Cabd being town by team composition even though his play is scummy. Tora, Firebringer, and Implosion should ask them. He's surprised Cheet doesn't see it.
-Tora is town by team composition
-Most of his reads come from about Page 60 when he was telling me to just lynch Mulch.
-when he's scum, confirmed townies are his priority NKs.
As expressed, MathDino's thought process is something I find dumb when it comes to composition reads, its basing it on odds when on the big scale it's entirely possible multiple teams rolled 2-4 scum pms. I think Cabd could be town for ... different reasons, but he's also pinged me a lot.
In post 2906, Kmd4390 wrote:Firebringer,
Mathdino says cabd is town because he believes the claim but he understands the need to Lynch him. I'm less sure of the claim myself mostly because I'm not sure scum would shoot him but Mathdino says it makes sense to shoot someone who is about to be confirmed and who they can't block and I can't say I fully disagree with that. I think I'm leaning town pending scum's kill being stopped some other way.
He says unabomb and Aris are still town. I agree on Aris. Unabomb I want Eddie's thing sorted but I have a guess what unabomb is going to claim and I don't trust it.
He's got Eddie as cleared by the flip. I mostly agree. I'm not seeing Eddie scum anymore.
He's got ginngie also town. I had the same read Day 1 but mulch's flip makes me less sure.
He says don't rule out Kagami. Scum can be counterwagons to scum. I don't personally think that's the case here though. If Kagami is scum, his entire day 1 was hard bus mulch.
He's not sure on scum without intense reading and says sheep Ginngie.
I also have cheet as obvtown and Chara likely town. Tora obvtown.
Could see either way on anyone else.
Haven't gotten recent reads from North, Dave, or guiltylion. Will ask in PT.
kagami isn't scum. i'm aware scum can bus, but this wasn't that. he is the only player besides our hydra that scumread mulch at first, and before i subbed in he was the bastion of sanity the thread needed to not just lynch transcend. also, show me why tor is obvtown please for shits n giggles.
In post 2899, Firebringer wrote:“If I am wrong on one of those it’s implosion
Also I think there’s quite a bit of scum equity in Eddie slot that people aren’t considering”
-Cow
again, literal lmfao
In post 2882, UnaBombaH wrote:I'm now going to sleep, but I'm very much interested in Eddie's theory on scum!Una.
The best thing about all of this is that I was willing to townlock Eddie after Assemble flipped red, but the way he entered this day made me question his motives again..!
So especially this game-day, I can say that Eddie re-created his own pet-peeve - paranoid!Una.
i'll probably be casing you when i'm done this post, don't worry. if you seriously think i'm scum with mulch then i literally laugh at you.
In post 2870, Spiffeh wrote:Can people unvote to ensure that Eddie Cane can say all of his words?
i appreciate you and Patrick (too lazy to go quote him) btw! I will be posting after this, but I'm not going to claim a guilty on anyone or anything, just felt like posting some shtuff.
In post 2856, Chara wrote:Cabd's friendly neighbour claim that no one really believed? yes, definitely, scum would nightkill that.
i mean, from a scum pov if cabd is town then they would "know" it was true, and with their roleblocker eddie'd they couldn't do anything about it. its not a likely nor a good kill, but its a potentially possible one. it isnt a ridiculous notion. though, myself and Kagami are basically ICs at this point so that kinda makes it redundant, its not like this is a game where there's no clear town and low info kills are useful.
In post 2843, Cabd wrote:Ya'll are prolly gonna mislynch me for my gambit working, whatever.
I'm actually bulletproof; fake softed then fake-harded friendly neighbor to draw the nightkill; we ended up on day two with a scum lynch (despite my poor read thereof) and no night kill, so yeah.
Anyone who thinks I willingly signed up to be scum with mulch's team is like.. beyond insane given the history between him and I.
i believed this at first but someone said you don't know your teammates until after you pick pms? which is it? cause if you pick scum pms after seeing the team then i actually buy this. otherwise, considering one of your teammates flipped scum, i find it very disingenuous seeing as you'd know how picking scum works regardless...
lmfao
In post 2839, Firebringer wrote:Rc says he can’t talk about chara because he is factoring teams composition into it
And unabomeh he says ur just obv town and didn’t pick up on crumbs
you can talk about some parts of this, he can at least hint what he's getting at
In post 2837, UnaBombaH wrote:Can you ask RC to go any more in depth?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")
Does he know I've been crumbing my role all game?
I also think that Eddie should humor me, since I'm willing to humor him:
@EDDIE - ASSUME I AM AN INVESTIGATIVE ROLE - WHO DO I CHECK N1?
... if its watcher me or kagami, if its something targeting a scumread ... a scumread? lol. and ftr, if you've crumbed i haven't noticed it. have not gone back in your iso to crumbhunt as of now.
In post 2853, Cheetory6 wrote: In post 2843, Cabd wrote:Ya'll are prolly gonna mislynch me for my gambit working, whatever.
You really think you were the nightkill?
P-Edit: You pick a rolePM, not a team composition.
egos are a powerful thing.
