Most screwed over player in MS history?

[Save The Dragons]

Brenda

I think she was in a bad spot, but she did have someone from her former tribe on that swap, and she was made a target for other reasons (as opposed to her tribemate, or Abi all alone getting a friend Alexis next round, or trying to cut down Moon's majority).

[Save The Dragons]

Also Carrie in BotB.

Regular first boot?

Is this regular, though? It's my understanding (i.e. correct me if i'm wrong) she went for the same reason Trappinch went, and that's because they missed the first 48 hours and it had already pretty much been decided what would be done. People were literally ignoring Carrie's attempts to communicate with them. I can't blame people for taking that route since I happily voted Trappinch but I don't know if this is necessarily a natural situation.

I would also argue neither are the most screwed over player though

[Save The Dragons]

I would argue having half your tribe spend an entire day actively not responding to your PMs as not necessarily playing bad but shrug ymmv