Dance of the Title Fairy: Accepting Applications

[beeboy]

wait how do you easily rainbow text?

[beeboy]

^ exactly what a Shotty alt would say.

[beeboy]

What's wrong with saying you think a title is bad?

[beeboy]

That's also stupid because excluding people isn't nice

edit: I am just going to edit this in instead of double posting, I think people should be ok with the title fairy thread having periods of inactivity rather then trying to force titles whenever this thread gets inactive for an extended period of time.

[beeboy]

Nth I Deleted My Main

[beeboy]

He lost his title.

[beeboy]

nth

I really like this title

[beeboy]

nth

I actually like this.
Sums up mastina discussion posts (I mean this in a nice way)

[beeboy]

Sorry when I read that title I can't really identify RC's personality, full name, address, interests, occupation, birthday, his dogs name and it doesn't embody everything RC has ever done on this site.
So I guess this just isn't special enough.

Next idea pls.

[beeboy]

I'm taking this opportunity to say that the current title system is super awful and needs reform

I am not really sure I agree with this, I think the title fairy thread should be a needless circle jerk instead of a place to give people good titles.
Imo the more aspects of this site that resemble an actual game of mafia the better.

[beeboy]

Vonflare for Doot 2018

Nth

pedit: I mean I think that it being shoved down everyone's throat is what makes doot a recognizable title? Kinda like how the shit surrounding Kayak turned a really shitty title into an ok meme.

[beeboy]

nom vonflare for doot

In case it wasn't clear, I typed 4484 before 4477 was posted, but since the nom has now officially been made, consider my 4484 an explicit

anti-nom

.

Where does doot exist outside of this thread?

It's a serious question.

When has a doot nomination ever referenced anything except for content from this thread?

Still a serious question.

I am not really sure why the bolded is needed? Like the title fairy is part of the site, there are titles based on survivor meets and other specific events so I don't see how that's a valid argument in regards to doot? It's just as recognizable and fits the same niche as Kayak which people obviously keep talking about because it's funny to them.

Like the "title must appeal to the broader community" argument is silly because people just bring it up as a really vague statement to disapprove of titles. It's why vague guidelines/rules in general tend to be pretty bad.

[beeboy]

I am not really sure why the bolded is needed? Like the title fairy is part of the site, there are titles based on survivor meets and other specific events so I don't see how that's a valid argument in regards to doot? It's just as recognizable and fits the same niche as Kayak which people obviously keep talking about because it's funny to them.

This is roughly my pro doot argument as well.
It fits the same niche as Kayak does as a title that is just funny as a result of it being a meme created in this thread.

Also Doot does represent a part of Vonflare's personality as well as he tends to shitpost at times. (I don't really think that titles need to say anything about someones personality but it is there)


Pedit: <3 sorry

[beeboy]

I don't really want wordplay with the title.
I feel like part of the point of it is that it would simply be "Doot"

[beeboy]

I don't think MattP's posts main argument was that Vonflare wanted the title and if Vonflare was neutral on the title people would still be asking for him to have it. I don't think him wanting the title actually means anything either way.

pedit: Also that.

[beeboy]

We should start a new era where we give people titles they don't want!

[beeboy]

Doot nomination process has given me a lot of entertainment value, I don't think the last point stands.

I also heavily disagree how this is comparable to Shotty given many people on there own accord are campaigning for the title and the current movement hasn't been directly influenced by Vonflare?
I also don't think this argument is actually relevant at all in regards to whether or not the title is good and if you have an ethics issue with how this is handled I think you should talk to that with Psyche directly.

[beeboy]

nth

I don't really think this in poor taste, good meme.

[beeboy]

The sheep ban is a legal issue it's not like he did anything wrong.

[beeboy]

You don't give people gifts for bad behavior.

If you think lying about your age while registering to a website is bad behavior then I am not really sure what to tell you.

[beeboy]

It isn't good behavior.

I don't disagree, it's just a title isn't a reward for good behavior.

[beeboy]

I mean you have to think about the purpose of the rule right?

The rule is in place because COPPA protects children 13 and under from having their personal information from being collected. It's not like the site has an issue with having young users it's just the law. It's not like Zor doesn't want him on the site he just literally didn't have a choice in the matter.

[beeboy]

I don't think Shaziro is saying that he thinks Sheep did something wrong, I think he is saying Sheep knowingly broke a site rule. (These are different statements)
But I think the rule being broken doesn't actually hurt the site in any meaningful way.

[beeboy]

Shaziro what problems did Sheep cause for the site?

[beeboy]

Potential legal problems for having somebody underage on the site.

COPPA imposes certain requirements on operators of websites or online services directed to children under 13 years of age, and on operators of other websites or online services that have

actual knowledge

that they are collecting personal information online from a child under 13 years of age.

It isn't a legal issue for the site since they had no knowledge he was under 13.
Operators are also protected if they take reasonable effort to delete said information, aka banning him after he says he lied.


Shaziro I just think your missing that lying about your age actually has no legal consequences for anyone.

[beeboy]

Yes, and when they gained the knowledge (because he was very open with it) it became a legal issue.

You are protected if you delete the information from your site.

There isn't a legal issue, you are arguing something you have 0 understanding of.

[beeboy]

I'm not sure what you'd call having to take special nonstandard action to avoid breaking laws other than a legal issue, man.

If someone lied about there age and later reveals they are under 13 deleting the information they provided the site is a standard action and by following that you are never at any risk. I don't think it's fair to say the site is at legal risk because they could decide to be really ignorant and ignore Sheep.

I also don't think someone needing to delete the personal info he provided the site is a massive issue either considering we aren't really a site that collects that info anyway.

[beeboy]

nth

[beeboy]

1. Troll nature
2. Always laughing

Morpheus

or

Neo

would be better

[beeboy]

Nominate Ellibereth for "Big Brother is watching you"

I think this fits elli a lot.

[beeboy]

I don't like the Chosen one tbh.
I think that's more for like "Luke Skywalker" and "Harry Potter"

[beeboy]

I don't think the tech part should be the primary focus

[beeboy]

Yeah,

Deus Ex Machina

?

Refers to his tendency to just sort of come in at some point during a game and just solve a lot of it.

3rd

This is the best one so far

[beeboy]

I feel like there's room for a pun here.

Your post was so good that I read it all as well ):