Guardian wrote:Jitsu wrote:I like Opie's post above.
What about it? Do you agree?
A fair question. I should explain further. I do agree with the points he brought up. I agree with Opie when he said that he most associated "arbitrary" with Xyl's meaning 3b. That is how I most often use the word as well. And I also echo Opie's uneasiness about you pushing the Erg0 wagon.
You seemed to be leading the discussion on Erg0's possible lynch without really stating much of your own case on him. I've seen that tactic used by scum before to distract townies if they are pushing a lynch and don't have a strong case to cite. Does that mean you are scum? Not necessarily, but I find it at least somewhat suspicious.
As for the Votes and FoSes, I obviously agree with the one on Oman.
As for you, I can see the reason for some suspicion against you (
FoS: Guardian
), but I'm not ready to put a vote toward that right now when I think Oman's actions are worse.
I am reserving judgment on Adel because I thought her gambit was easily seen as such, thus not much of a tell. Gambits and high-risk moves are a big part of Adel's play style, so it is harder to tell from that whether she is town or scum.
Guardian wrote:I'm not sure who is most deserving of a vote right now. Erg0 has since claimed he does this every game, but the "hang separately option" and "I just want you to hang" bit raised my eyebrows, and made me think he was the best wagon at the time.
The (presumably fake?) day vigs don't really say anything to me.
Opie's post actually heightened my suspicion there -- I'd really like a good explanation from both opie, and Jitsu who categorically "liked opie's post" to explain why everyone voting Erg0 is worthy of suspicion.
Opie's post heightened your suspicion of what?
The "hang separately / just want you to hang" thing is worth remembering to me (I never said Erg0 was completely innocent), but I don't think it's worthy of a vote by itself. Since you feel that the fake dayvig's don't say much, your reason for voting Erg0 boils down to the "hang" statements above?
You don't know who is most deserving of a vote right now? That's a funny thing to say from someone who is pushing Erg0's wagon and asking the players to explain their votes for him and justify votes elsewhere when your own vote for him seems to be lacking in terms of a reason.
And saying I "categorically" liked Opie's post is an overstatement of my opinion. I said "I liked it", not "I categorically agreed with every word".
So, let me ask this: Why don't you feel Oman was acting suspiciously?