Mini #704: Hunchback of Notre Dame, Game Over

[petroleumjelly]

Day Five Vote Count #1

3 destructor (Machiavellian-Mafia, Urzassedatives, ortolan)

With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch, and

2

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 20, 9:59 pm CDT.

Not Voting - 2 - destructor, Korejora

~

And the crowd burst into a laugh, especially the boys and young girls.

destructor, Mafia, has been lynched!

It is now

Night Five

. Choices are due to me by February 11, 9:59 pm CDT.

[petroleumjelly]

Now that spirit seemed to have departed; the cathedral seemed gloomy, and gladly remained silent; festivals and funerals had the simple peal, dry and bare, demanded by the ritual, nothing more

Korejora, Town, has been killed!

It is now

Day Six

. With

3

alive, it takes

2

to lynch, and

2

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is February 25, 9:59 pm CDT. I may extend deadline once by one week if two players send me a PM asking for such an extension.

[Thestatusquo]

So uh...
Orto, MM...

Which one of you is scum?

(Did I mention I hate this game?)

[ortolan]

trick question???

at present there's no way I'm going to vote MM over you.

Should you be town, would you care to list you who you think is scum out of myself/MM and why?

[Thestatusquo]

No.

This is the worst mafia game I have ever played in my history on the site. I have given up. Vote me and let me lose already.

[ortolan]

That's not going to help your case, in my experience if someone tells/asks you to lynch them your best bet is to comply.

[Thestatusquo]

i'm not trying to help my case. I'm serious. I've lost all will to play this game. I did so about 2 game days ago.

[ortolan]

Well this endgame is going to be interesting...

I'm waiting for Mr. MM to make an appearance

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

As I have said all along, I like TSQ as scum.

[ortolan]

TSQ; do you have a reply?

Both MM and I are going to vote you as it is

[Thestatusquo]

no. GG scum.

[ortolan]

Vote: Thestatusquo

[Thestatusquo]

Vote: Thestatusquo

GG scum.

[ortolan]

good game. Kind of dissapointing that you threw away the end-game like that, but I'm still confused as to whether you could have even won?

MM- were you the traitor, or not?

[ortolan]

if not then me and destructor spend the whole time from night 2 onwards thinking you were the traitor, lol

If it wasn't you it would have been CarnCarn.

[Thestatusquo]

P sure it was mizzy.

This is the worst game I've ever played on this site. I knew I wasn't going to convince either of you to vote for the other (if they did I was just going to hammer that person pronto)

The only chance I had is if it had been kore at endgame today.

[ortolan]

Yer I toyed with the idea of leaving kore alive, but no way was I going to kill MM either way cause I thought he was the traitor so if I didn't kill her it would have been you instead.

[ortolan]

no way Mizzy was the traitor, ironically Mizzy actually picked both of us at various stages, but I pretty much counter-attacked her so hard I convinced her I, at least, were town.

[Thestatusquo]

P sure that if MM were traitor, today wouldn't have even happened... Am I missing something about the role?

[ortolan]

I thought so too, but when I asked pj for clarification on how it worked the answers were kind of ambiguous. But even according to what he told me I would have thought if MM were the traitor, today at least never could have happened, even if yesterday did.

[CarnCarn]

waiting for petroleumjelly to call the game.

[destructor]

Pretty sure it's over.

Good game guys. I had a hoot.

I'm interested in seeing the full reveal, but I'm thinking Nat may have been the Traitor. LOL

I was serious about thinking that bussing was like an absolute last resort in this game. I don't see what scum had to gain through bussing besides in end-game, just like ort did.

ort was right, we both thought MM was the Traitor coming into Day 4, which is why I claimed a guilty on ThAd. We thought we'd win with one more mislynch. MM voting him straight away only made me more confident of this, which led to me being real surprised when Day 5 began. haha. I'm not sure if anyone realises how much MM looked like the Traitor. He named me as not being a suspect in Day 2 for reasons that I didn't really see and his method of analysis meant he didn't have to comment on ort either. Then throughout the game, he just kept seeming to side with either ort or I. It was nuts.

We thought a few players might have been the Traitor throughout the game, including CC and even TSQ/Caboose. I personally ruled CC out because he was making a case on me, and I didn't think a Traitor would do that. Same went for Mizzy, I don't see why she'd make cases on ort and I if she were the Traitor.

On Mizzy, she was pretty much right about me. My Day 1 play was shoddy, and I think that's what she picked up on. I was just lucky that she never made a very tangibe or solid case and that I was able to keep her on the back foot.

I'd like to know if rofl followed the game and what he thought of how things went. It was pretty much on my insistence that he was killed night 1, hehe.

[ortolan]

I thought CarnCarn was the traitor because just before he got lynched he said "even though destructor is attacking me I don't think he's scummy for it", took his vote off and said I think Urza/ThAdmiral were scummy and voted one of them. I thought as the traitor he was trying to use the town cred he's get on his flip to direct suspicion away from destructor. I was surprised no-one else picked up on it actually cause it looked like a traitory move- especially because he'd previously been attacking destructor quite fervently, yet he suddenly changed his mind.

The other thing was that while he attacked those two who'd been on his wagon, he didn't even mention me, although I'd also been on his wagon.

But we shall find out soon.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

So I played like a traitor by accident? I was actually a vanilla townie.

[ortolan]

lol

oh well