Okay, I'm gonna line up the info as we have gotten it from myself, MrBuddy, MMoD, the collarings, and random information. I consider the three of us the most cleared people in the game, with Anonymies being almost just as cleared simply for his claim and how it coincided with my claim. I'll switch my notes from "Night Zero - Night Six" to "Night One - Night Seven" to avoid confusion.
Night One
:
1.) PJ sends Ashaman to kill Mudbuck (Mudbuck already killed by somebody else)
2.) MBL investigates Pooky, gets an innocent result
3.) MMoD learns that there are neutral roles which can be won over by shadow
*4.) M-M tries to collar MBL, fails = MBL not a female channeler
Night Two
:
1.) PJ sends Ashaman to kill Broomhead/Ghyrt (refused)
2.) MBL investigates Broomhead/Ghyrt, learns "there is reason to fear, but not evil"
3.) MMoD learns something about "can protect, stop, and control shadow" (I don't understand this one)
*4.) TSS disappears
*5.) M-M tries to collar PJ, fails = PJ not a female channeler
Night Three
:
1.) PJ sends Ashaman to kill Albert the Great
2.) MBL investigates Logicticus, gets guilty result
3.) MMoD learns that on Night Two, TSS vanished, and a player refused to kill himself
*4.) Pooky (Moriane) finds PJ (Rand)
*5.) BJ collared, success = BJ a female channeler
Night Four
:
1.) PJ sends Ashaman to kill Logicticus
2.) MBL investigates TSS, led to ChannelDelibird, gets guilty result
3.) MMoD learns that on Night Three, BJ was collared and somebody found another person, who MMoD doesn't like (Moraine), but the result is good (i.e. two good guys hook up, PJ and Pooky)
*4.) Yos2 collared, success = Yos2 a female channeler
Night Five
:
1.) PJ sends Ashaman to kill Cyan
2.) MBL investigates Tamuz, gets innocent result
3.) MMoD learns that some people can communicate, but some of those communicators can't be trusted
*4.) Illumina collared, success = Illumina a female channeler
Night Six
:
1.) PJ does not send his Ashaman to do anything
2.) MBL investigates Machiavellian-Mafia, gets a "not malicious" result
3.) MMoD learns that on Night Five,
MBL did not catch anybody
, and that Illumina was collared
*4.) M-M claims to have collared Lordy, success = Lordy a female channeler
*5.) Lordy disappeared
Night Seven
:
1.) PJ sends his Ashaman to kill Spamwise
2.) MBL investigates Illumina, gets a "sense of growing fearsome power, but no evil"
3.) MMoD learns that on Night Six, there was not much hostile intent
*4.) M-M claims to have collared nobody
So actually, MMoD's role (I think) just helped clear Tamuz. Since MMoD was told explicitly that MBL did not "catch anybody", and that night MBL investigated Tamuz, it might add up to mean that Tamuz might not be a GF role.
Also, note that MMoD's role also goes to clear me: it verifies that I
did
ask my Ashaman Broomhead to kill himself on Night Two, and therefore I could not have been the cause of TSS's disappearance. Further, he goes to show that two people found each other on Night Three (Pooky and PJ), and that although he does not like one of those people (Moraine), the result is good (as in two good guys hooking up).
M-M can still be a GF role who investigates as innocent when he himself takes no action (as we know he took no actions on Night Six, the night MBL investigated him... but instead have ordered Illumina to use balefare on Lordy, although he
claims
to have collared Lordy). Further, we know there was "not much hostile intent" on Night Six from MMoD, and if M-M is hostile (but was simply "not hostile") on Night Six, that fits in him with investigating as "not malicious"
for just Night Six
, since it would have been Illumina using the balefare (not hostilely: she would be
forced into it
) rather than M-M.
Look what all can be done with a bit o' critical thinking!
In short...
Vote: Machiavellian-Mafia
. I think you are a GF role who investigates innocent so long as you yourself take no night actions on the night in which you are investigated.
People who I will
not not
want to Vig tonight:
1.) Myself
2.) MBL
3.) MMoD
4.) Anonymities
5.) Tamuz
6.) Illumina (Unless M-M specifically comes up as a Cult Leader role)
7.) Fritzler (I believe his claim of Aviendha, and that she would be pro-town)
People who I will very likely
fail
at Vigging tonight:
1.) Ghyrt (an Ashaman will not kill himself when ordered, as we have learned
I think the scum are M-M and Ghyrt.
I suggest we lynch M-M today. I would
also
suggest that Anonymities
role-blocks Ghyrt
, so that he cannot kill tonight.
Any objections?