Open 191 - Paris Mafia II (Game Over!)

[VP Baltar]

Vote Count 1-4

:

kyle99 ~ L-4 (xRECKONERx, Looker, XScorpion)

Kise ~ L-6 (Cat)
Cat ~ L-6 (Rhinox)
Gerty ~ L-6 (Dry-fit)
XScorpion ~ L-6 (flinter)

Not Voting: Kise, Gerty, xofelf, Mylynes, kyle99

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to lynch. Deadline is January 18 at roughly 8 a.m. (GMT-5).

[XScorpion]

@all references to previous 141:
I honestly don't know what the hell was going on in that game. From my perspective, there were about 6 mimes (all from SA), hence my withdrawal from that game. I really don't see how being in a game that didn't even get to day 2 makes me any better at telling mime from scum than anyone else?

[kyle99]

@Kyle
I wouldn't stress it if I were you, it's just that you came after him and reiterated what he said. Naturally, this makes you look scummier because he performed the act (unvote) first, but it's nothing to get upset about. If anything, I'd say you push a case on Melinda and see where it gets you.

Who's Melinda?

[Looker]

It doesn't. (Don't take the bait!!)

[Looker]

Damn it, Mylynes. Dude, let's seriously lynch him right now simply for his name. I'm game.

unvote
vote mylynes aka melinda aka mae ling

[Mylynes]

Vote: Kyle99

Right now I am suspicious of Kise and think vig killing him sounds like a good idea. I'm also suspicious of Kyle99 and cat.

Cat hasn't posted in a while and still doesn't have an avatar.

Damn it, Mylynes. Dude, let's seriously lynch him right now simply for his name. I'm game.

unvote
vote mylynes aka melinda aka mae ling

You are the only one having trouble with my name. I don't know how you could possibly get melinda or mae ling. My name is Mylynes..

@Kise - Vote and we'll see if the Mod counts it.

I agree that sounds like a good idea.

[kyle99]

Vote: Kyle99

Right now I am suspicious of Kise and think vig killing him sounds like a good idea. I'm also suspicious of Kyle99 and cat.

Cat hasn't posted in a while and still doesn't have an avatar.

Damn it, Mylynes. Dude, let's seriously lynch him right now simply for his name. I'm game.

unvote
vote mylynes aka melinda aka mae ling

You are the only one having trouble with my name. I don't know how you could possibly get melinda or mae ling. My name is Mylynes..

@Kise - Vote and we'll see if the Mod counts it.

I agree that sounds like a good idea.

Why are you suspicious? Voting without giving reason is pretty stupid and scummy imo.

[Kise]

Raffle. You all really think I'd make myself obv-Mime like that? This is an open set-up... being voteless is not present here.

[Dry-fit]

I think claiming not to know what a mime is is a mime tell. So far kyle and mylynes have done that.

I don't like how Looker is desperately looking to push a bandwagon on

anyone

that he can.

[Mylynes]

Why are you suspicious? Voting without giving reason is pretty stupid and scummy imo.

I sometimes like to vote without giving an immediate reason just to see how a person reacts to more pressure.

[Looker]

I think claiming not to know what a mime is is a mime tell. So far kyle and mylynes have done that.

I don't like how Looker is desperately looking to push a bandwagon on

anyone

that he can.

I'm confused, what exactly

is

a Vig?

I wouldn't call it desperate, but there's only one way to start the game. You know that.

[Looker]

@MYLYNES:
I don't think he's going to react if you tell him that it's pressure.

[Mylynes]

@MYLYNES:
I don't think he's going to react if you tell him that it's pressure.

Why not?

[Looker]

Pressure implies no intention to lynch.

[Rhinox]

Rhinox is likely scum.

ummm... why?

Doesn't matter why - refute it.

ok...

Rhinox is likely

not

scum.

fixed.
bout the best I can do until there is a reason...

[xRECKONERx]

On my phone - more content coming later.

[xofelf]

Yeah sorry about that.. being home on break means i have to babysit kids a lot so i don't always get a chance to drop in here.

Looker, you seem to have a problem getting names right. not just Mylynes, but mine as well. if it makes it easier, just use Elf. but it's xofelf kthx.

alright, i'm not sure much about anyone at the moment.(as fucked up as the last game was, it was easier to know who was who as i had played with many of the people before.)
I'm going to take some time when i wake up more and have eaten to read over things again and see what i come up with.

[xRECKONERx]

Rhinox is likely scum because of Kise's post.

[flinter]

@all references to previous 141:
I honestly don't know what the hell was going on in that game. From my perspective, there were about 6 mimes (all from SA), hence my withdrawal from that game. I really don't see how being in a game that didn't even get to day 2 makes me any better at telling mime from scum than anyone else?

but in that game, you had analyzed already when we were this far. Here, you have no intention of doing that, and the only thing you do is throwing your vote around, and defending yourself, basic scum behaviour.

Looker, darling, I think I have found a pretty cosy bandwagon for us two. Would you join me?

[XScorpion]

In that game my "analysis" was of a bunch of SA trolls.
I'm really not eager to repeat the same things I did last game, given that they didn't even help.

[VP Baltar]

Cat has been prodded.

[flinter]

In that game my "analysis" was of a bunch of SA trolls.
I'm really not eager to repeat the same things I did last game, given that they didn't even help.

no dear, it is very simple.

analysis is part of your gameplay, not of the subjects of your analysis. The change in your posts (no analysis, defenses like this) have to do with a change in gameplay.

Very simply put, the change in posting style has to do with you having different motives, imo, mafia motives. In stead of trying to find scum, like there, you are here busy to avoid attention.

[XScorpion]

So just to be clear, you're voting me because I haven't made an analysis of the players I find scummy yet?

[Gerty]

Mod - if the mimes achieve their win condition, does the game end?

If town, this is you throwing in the towel. If mime, this is you trying to butter everybody up to feel sympathetic for your faction. I'm not getting a goonie reading from you so there is no

If Mafia

scenario I can come up with.

That isn't Rhinox throwing in the towel at all. He is quite obviously trying to work out the best way for town to win.

Raffle. You all really think I'd make myself obv-Mime like that? This is an open set-up... being voteless is not present here.

The problem with this defense Kise, is that any other explanation requires you to be even more stupid than if you're obv-mime. Explain how your claim isn't incredibly stupid as either scum or town. Your behaviour doesn't make much sense at all, but it still matches a mime motivation better than any other.

There is no partner, Rhinox; it's a gambit.

I don't believe it's a gambit, and I'm a bit curious that Looker seems so sure that Kise is town gambiting.

Kyle, I don't understand how your mime-jester correlation affects your voting. What did you

think

they were? Why did you unvote?

It's also hypocritical to vote Kyle for not picking up on the jester thing, considering your initial reaction to Kise's claim was:

I say we lynch you. (If you're not going to vote, of course)

The case on kyle99 is weak. It's plausible he missed that they were jesters when reading the role PMs. I did the first time I read it, and only caught it the second time.

Even worse than those making the weak case on Kyle is this:

Vote: Kyle99

Right now I am suspicious of Kise and think vig killing him sounds like a good idea. I'm also suspicious of Kyle99 and cat.

Just jumping on the easy bandwagon, without giving reasons.

Vote: Mylynes

.

This explanation for not giving a reason

I sometimes like to vote without giving an immediate reason just to see how a person reacts to more pressure.

is rubbish. Kyle already had several votes, was already feeling the pressure and was already defending himself. You don't add your vote at that stage unless you actually want him lynched.

XScorpion also jumped on the easy Kyle bandwagon. I can't comment on the meta case flinter has on him, but she is right that he hasn't been very pro-town so far.

[kyle99]

@Mylynes

You state that you think I'm scummy, but the only thing even somewhat scummy is not no what a mime was, which was the same mistake you made. Either say what other rational you have for voting, or unvote.