Prey Mafia - Game Over

[Papa Zito]

Don't see how a full claim actually helps us. You either believe BEF at this point or you don't.

I don't want further song and dance on this point. Pinning him down on a claim here and now helps us evaluate. I don't see how anyone can really be comfortable with how fish has acted here, especially given context of what happened last night in the hood and the NKs.

[Papa Zito]

also mimic

[Varsoon]

Hahah it's on the 50, Zito.

I'm not comfortable with it but I can understand where he's coming from with it because I've lived it more than once real recently.
It's not optimal play at all and I'm ashamed I played that way, myself.

[Xtoxm]

VC 2.5

[3] Persivul:

BrightEyedFish, skitter30, Almost50

[2] BrightEyedFish:

Persivul, Elbirn

[5] Not Voting:

Varsoon, Chara, Papa Zito, implosion, mcqueen

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

The Day 2 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-02-11 18:00:00)

Mod Note:

Your mod is V/LA Friday, Saturday, Sunday. I should have mobile wifi to lock the thread if needed but I can't do any VC or lynch until I get back. the worst is our back-up mod and will be on hand for any issues and perhaps a VC or two.

Spoiler:

[Varsoon]

Pretty late on that Mimic, Bosstoxm

[Elbirn]

BEF/Varsoon/Chara

If I'm right you three have to buy me a pizza postgame

Thanks ♡

[Varsoon]

Those are pretty good townreads, yeah?

[Chara]

BEF/Varsoon/Chara

If I'm right you three have to buy me a pizza postgame

Thanks ♡

so you think both of Fish's buddies are hard defending him?
and that Fish claimed

this

badly with daytalk? and safeclaims?

[Chara]

it feels like the holistic half of the list is townreading Fish and the logical half wants him lynched. but i thought Elbirn was more of a holistic player so the list has me the most confused from him.

at this point i doubt we'll get a lynch without a claim. if it outs his PR so be it, and it will be provable or it won't be.

[Chara]

Varsoon: on the mcqueen townread. his ISO is just really towny to me as a whole and i don't feel like towncasing him but i will if you're very concerned i could be dismissing scum mcqueen as town of if you're concerned about me having the read.

[mcqueen]

i don’t know how you still have a town read on me when i haven’t done anything today. tomorrow I have a lot of downtime. I promise I’ll read up and give my thoughts. Sorry for active lurking

[Elbirn]

BEF/Varsoon/Chara

If I'm right you three have to buy me a pizza postgame

Thanks ♡

so you think both of Fish's buddies are hard defending him?
and that Fish claimed

this

badly with daytalk? and safeclaims?

it feels like the holistic half of the list is townreading Fish and the logical half wants him lynched. but i thought Elbirn was more of a holistic player so the list has me the most confused from him.

at this point i doubt we'll get a lynch without a claim. if it outs his PR so be it, and it will be provable or it won't be.

Hi I'm Elbirn and my playstyle is not holistic or logical, its openly shitposting and occasionally saying smart things or having spot on hunches but dont count on it. I'll be frank, it was just a funny thought I had that I wanted to put out there for smart guy points in post game if I called it, maybe see how you three feel about my grossposting *worlds biggest shrug*

I do absolutely think that it's not out of the realm of possibility for both scum buddies to hard defend or to make really bad fake claims. I dont know much about you or how you play, but I feel like its the kind of thing Varsoon would do and then schmooze his way out of if hes scum and it comes back to bite him on the ass.

I am interested as to how you know scum have fake claims provided?

[Chara]

The following is public knowledge: the setup consists of a town faction (Human) and a single groupscum faction (Typhon), where "groupscum" is defined as having more than one player. Typhon will have daytalk and safe claims. It is not public knowledge whether other alignments exist in the game.

[Chara]

i don’t know how you still have a town read on me when i haven’t done anything today. tomorrow I have a lot of downtime. I promise I’ll read up and give my thoughts. Sorry for active lurking

you were towny day 1, i don't really see why i'd stop townreading you just because your activity disappeared. activity isn't AI.
hope to see your thoughts tomorrow though.

Elbirn: i don't know you that well either, so i suppose that's fair. it just seemed an odd team for you to come up with even with your issues today with Varsoon.

[Elbirn]

The following is public knowledge: the setup consists of a town faction (Human) and a single groupscum faction (Typhon), where "groupscum" is defined as having more than one player. Typhon will have daytalk and safe claims. It is not public knowledge whether other alignments exist in the game.

Fair enough, thought I could catch you out on that one if you hadn't realized but eh meh bleh slips are bullshit anyway

I just want something to do today and I feel like nothing gets resolved if it doesnt involve BEF and we somehow only have 4 days left

[skitter30]

BEF/Varsoon/Chara

If I'm right you three have to buy me a pizza postgame

Thanks ♡

why am i not in this scumteam?
ie you think varsoon and chara are sketchy for defending bef, but so have i?

[Elbirn]

BEF/Varsoon/Chara

If I'm right you three have to buy me a pizza postgame

Thanks ♡

why am i not in this scumteam?
ie you think varsoon and chara are sketchy for defending bef, but so have i?

Because you're not scum, silly-willy

[BrightEyedFish]

BEF, what are your reads?

If I had to choose a scum team, right now it would be:
Persivul, Elbirn, and Skitter

I have a few TRs but I am still undecided on most.

[BrightEyedFish]

any other reason would be a condition on your own role, which you should already know.
so i don't understand the point of your question. you aren't a newbie as far as i can tell.

Which reminds me:

@BEF: If you are Loyal/Disloyal you targeted someone scum/town and got reflexively blocked for it.

I don't have any loyal/disloyal modifiers.

[skitter30]

Bef i think you kinda need to claim now - this whole thing is making the game stall and we dont have that much time left

[BrightEyedFish]

Bef i think you kinda need to claim now - this whole thing is making the game stall and we dont have that much time left

Most people are wanting a claim and since I derped it up I will claim.

Day Neighborising Motivator

If my action is successful I will gain a PT with my target until the following dawn and I motivate them for the following night.

[Papa Zito]

And your target?

[BrightEyedFish]

And your target?

I still don't feel comfortable outing my target as it will not help town atm.

[Papa Zito]

I don't possibly see how that's true.

I also don't see how this role was supposed to confirm you as town in any context.

[skitter30]

Idk how it was supposed to conftown him but i don't think it comes from scum!him most of the time