Mini Normal 2288: Reposting Same Picture As Flavor Are Lame

[Firebringer]

I think geraintm is a pretty good scum equity slot

Expand

[Firebringer]

The most annoying thing in this game for me by far atm is Penguin's approach to me
It feels like you're taking everything I say and interpreting it in this really Level Zero negative way, like you're deciding you don't like it and then attaching a quick 'zing!' afterwards
I remember there being a little bit of this from you the last time we played but nowhere near to this degree
I don't know what I've done to piss in your cheerios but I'd appreciate at least an attempt at understanding a perspective that's different than your own

I can kind of see that.
Penguin can u give more to ur Klick read?

[PenguinPower]

read the next post?

[Firebringer]

VOTE: andante

If I was scum and this was town I would've killed this immediately since everyone kept saying obvtown so it reads as suspicious they're still here

FYI it's the day I do both jobs so I prolly won't be back til very late if at all today

ummm andante was def not obvtown yesterday.
i don't even think andante is strong town but im reconsidering it based on my wrong solve yesterday.

this is low effort thinking and i don't even think its right. I think only 2 people had andante as "obvtown"?

[Firebringer]

read the next post?

Wow penguin expecting me to actually read the game.
Which newbies and allies is klick buddying exactly?

[GamerGryff]

VOTE: andante

If I was scum and this was town I would've killed this immediately since everyone kept saying obvtown so it reads as suspicious they're still here

FYI it's the day I do both jobs so I prolly won't be back til very late if at all today

but...you aren't scum so even if this was town...how does that logic track?

i agree with the second part though I'm not sure everyone was obvtown...pretty sure warmpuppy was pretty vocal about scum!andante

My point is that from my perspective this would've been the perfect kill for scum, ergo, since she's not dead, she's scum

Well... with all due respect, you're wrong.

My two strongest townreads ARE Gryff and Kowah at the moment, and I think them being new to MS has a lot to do with WHY those townreads have developed. I feel fairly confident in my ability to read people when they're being people and not gamers trying to approach Mafia in accordance to the MS site meta. I have a history of having rather accurate reads on players who are either new to the community, or older but not trying particularly hard. Or if you don't want to hear me talking about my read accuracy, I can at least back up the fact that I tend to express confident reads on newer players.

The thing you are scumreading is a thing that I do as town. I would probably do it as scum as well. But it definitely happens as town.

I'm actually not new, I'm old, rusty, and have never been good so I might as well be but I'm not new, I'm an old fart who joined iirc sometime in the early 2010s on my old main, course, I was a kid then and I'm not now

Where was I going with this?

[PenguinPower]

read the next post?

Wow penguin expecting me to actually read the game.
Which newbies and allies is klick buddying exactly?

read klick's next post!

[GamerGryff]

VOTE: andante

If I was scum and this was town I would've killed this immediately since everyone kept saying obvtown so it reads as suspicious they're still here

FYI it's the day I do both jobs so I prolly won't be back til very late if at all today

ummm andante was def not obvtown yesterday.
i don't even think andante is strong town but im reconsidering it based on my wrong solve yesterday.

this is low effort thinking and i don't even think its right. I think only 2 people had andante as "obvtown"?

Oh I 100% andante is not obvtown

Maybe I'm misremembering but it feels like a lot of people were calling her obvtown

Or maybe it was just that the same people were saying it over and over, I don't have the time to check right now

[PenguinPower]

wow firebringer expecting me to actually explain myself

[Firebringer]

i apologize penguin friend. I will adjust expectations going forward.
And only now ask questions after i actually read every post so im not just being lazy.

[Firebringer]

i think klick reaction to the wagon push on gryff was town but r u saying it was scum ally defending? Cause i don't see that or i guess ur saying its either ally or newbie protection.

which technically gryff is older player so not really 'newbie' but i guess same reasoning applies?

[Firebringer]

I would like to talk to shirou more today.
Hey shirou u get that thing i sent u

[redFF]

My point is that from my perspective this would've been the perfect kill for scum, ergo, since she's not dead, she's scum

from your perspective

[redFF]

just because i and a few others have said andante is town, doesn't automatically make her a good kill. she pushed half the playerlist day 1 and dominated the posting during day 1 so why not keep her around if they don't see her as a threat

[Kowahbunga]

just because i and a few others have said andante is town, doesn't automatically make her a good kill. she pushed half the playerlist day 1 and dominated the posting during day 1 so why not keep her around if they don't see her as a threat

Because that's active scum hunting if she is town and eventually that gaze is going to make it's way on to them and that means everyone will be under pressure as long as she is in the game.

[Lazy Shirou]

*checks watch*

11:30 AM. Shirou is still scum.

*checks watch*

11:40 AM. Herta is not voting who they think is still scum.

Idk man PP feels kinda town

I think it may be a red role PM issue, he's gotta check for support before wagoning someone

[redFF]

just because i and a few others have said andante is town, doesn't automatically make her a good kill. she pushed half the playerlist day 1 and dominated the posting during day 1 so why not keep her around if they don't see her as a threat

Because that's active scum hunting if she is town and eventually that gaze is going to make it's way on to them and that means everyone will be under pressure as long as she is in the game.

thats one way to think about it i guess

[Lazy Shirou]

firstly, sorry for not having been around at the end of the last day, i was in a white van driving round the country.

VOTE: Klick

I will be taking no questions at this time.

i am going to assume you have way more tucked up your sleeve about this. to me it feels like a pretty strong night action.

having seen the two deaths, i can sense a theme running through all the roles

Lazy Shirou just setting off my scumdar btw. i've got nothing more than that on them, but they feel off

geraintm
- does nothing all day 1, explaining that he thinks day 1s are pointless and that's his playstyle, he's not going to do much
- comes in day 2 making an excuse for not being around in day 1, despite already explaining that he thinks day 1s are pointless.
- fishes for a PR on his first post of day 2

VOTE: geraintm

I shouldn't give town points for this but I feel so depraved of people with similar povs that you can get a golden star for today

I was also wondering if geraint is scum if neither gryff or kowah is

[Herta]

*checks watch*

11:30 AM. Shirou is still scum.

*checks watch*

11:40 AM. Herta is not voting who they think is still scum.

Idk man PP feels kinda town

I think it may be a red role PM issue, he's gotta check for support before wagoning someone

That's probably it.

[Lazy Shirou]

I would like to talk to shirou more today.
Hey shirou u get that thing i sent u

Yes i felt ur love for me

[Herta]

I was also wondering if geraint is scum if neither gryff or kowah is

What are the associations there?

[Lazy Shirou]

Ok herta is actuaĺly prob scum, I cant be that scummy to you but dont receive a vote

VOTE: herta

[Herta]

Tell me about geraintm.

[Herta]

Did geraintm make the kill last night?

[Lazy Shirou]

you think im super scummy but wants to engage me rather than case/vote me it's so cute

I will grant ur wish i just need some time since im on mobile and posting is a pain