Elennaro wrote:I never said you should lynch lurkers without giving them a chance to defend themselves. And anyway, the only town power role who should really try to remain hidden is the doctor, and he could play active townie just as well, it should be really easy for him, because he has no knowledge the town does not have (unless he prevents a kill, and even then it doesn't mean anything in games with a vig). Lurking should not be a good way to keep a low profile. But, of course I'd rather lynch a probable mafia than a lurker.
What's wrong with lynching liars, by the way? I mean, of course exceptions must be possible, but what is wrong with it in general?
Lets say there i'm a watcher, ok?
Now, I know u targeted the guy that died last night, ok?
So I claim cop and say that I have a guilty on u, and ask u to claim.
if u claim miller, then I'll know your scum because miller doesn't target, if u say I can't be cop because ur not scum(ur vig or cop or something), then I'll know u may be telling the truth.
now, after that happens, if u claim miller, and I claim watcher and tell everyone that I just wanted to check if u r scum or vig.
after that happens, a guy with a Lync all Liars policy would lynch me next day(this day lynch the scum) just because I lied...
get it?