Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[armlx]

That's four votes, I belive.

No, its 5.

[The Fonz]

Five. You just put him at l-1.

[armlx]

Five. You just put him at l-1.

Sarnathed.

[skitzer]

me, Kison, armlx, Claus - who is the other 1?

[The Fonz]

Look at the bloody vote count on the previous page...

(Also, the fact that i said i wasn't voting him

because i didn't want to put him at L-1 yet

was a clue).

[skitzer]

I didn't see that the last time I checked the page!

Also, why are we so hesitant to put people at L-1. It's not like they're gonna claim...

[The Fonz]

I just want everyone to have the chance to check in and respond to my entry analysis before anyone dies. There's no rush.

[armlx]

It's not like they're gonna claim...

Gorrad did. Just saying.

[Claus]

I just want everyone to have the chance to check in and respond to my entry analysis before anyone dies. There's no rush.

unvote. FoS Porochaz

Very well. Consider that my vote still is on Porochaz though. I may put it back if people don't actually return to discuss.

[Porochaz]

This is my offical "friday theres noone really in work day so I can spend time on significant rereading" game. Tomorror lunchtime approximitely 12 hours.

[Porochaz]

Ok Im going in player list order...

so

Xdaamo

Posts 1-23 There's nothing really there... JDodge and XDaamo was the only thing that attracted my attention and even then it was lacklustre. However I feel Jdodge was in the right about you and you were the one to make the mistake by not reading.

The Game started March 24th, it took to June 7th before a decent post came. Within that he promises analysis later that day.

10 days later, he posts again, to say he likes the colour claim and then claims red.

Once again goes into lurker mode.

From post 30 (July 22nd onwards) his posts have been ok.

More later

[Porochaz]

Ok so I now have notes on skitzer, Kison and Greasy Spot, I will post them later, I decided to do them all at once rather than seperately thats why XDaamo's is there... I skipped armlx at the moment because his 200 post count made me cry after Kison 11? posts.

[Porochaz]

I drabj lots please forgive the spelling of thid apilogy.

I am sorry, I have examined all alive people apart from me and GW (ie. me) and uber poster armlx. I meant to post today, however I also meant to have an early sober night... so Im sorry

[Kison]

Well, when you do post your thoughts, if you'd not mind ordering who you think is scum, that'd be great.

Dcorb was replaced. Has anyone else

not

checked in?

[mikeburnfire]

Vote Count!
With 10 alive, it will take 6 to lynch.

4 Porochaz (armlx, The Jester, Kison, skitzer)
1 The Jester (Nightson)

Not voting: The Fonz, Greasy Spot, Porochaz, Xdaamno, Claus

[Porochaz]

Kison I do, because it a few sides of a4 and I still havent got round to armlx or myself yet however I will post a town/scum summary at then end if that'll do.

[The Jester]

@MBF: You have me on the not voting list, and I'm voting Poro right now.

[The Jester]

EBWOP: Hit submit too soon.

@Mod: You have me on the not voting list, but I'm voting Porochaz right now.

I had you on both, but it's fixed now.

[Claus]

Poro, I think I would like to see your scum list if you already have it, even if you haven't finished your re-read yet. This game needs something to kick it back into action.

[Claus]

Re-reading now.

[Claus]

Wrong thread, sorry *blush*

[Porochaz]

Ok in the interests of actually doing work here, Im going to post my notes raw... and without my analysis/kinda summary on armlx/myself so that we can start discussing...

skitzer

- 39 posts
Goes straight into character discussion
His 5th Post he mentions the low majority lynch as interesting
After lynch he goes onto say "I told you so" when he only stated it as interesting
Votes sonickid on what he calls a mild defense but only whilst GS hasnt claimed (sonikid was scum)
I dislike his jumping on and off the Greasy Spot wagon
Automatically assumes GS/Sonikid pairing
Is Fine with a colour claim - something I personally have my doubts about, but as the majority wanted it fair enough
Blue
Last number of posts I havent liked
Post 33 for, example Why is the purple stupid line relevant? I mean its the player playing not the pikmin whos ability would be in question. He has an eagerness to lynch at the expense of what others think

Kison

- 111 posts
BBM mistake
Gives newbie reasoning for an unvote
When he says some of the deaths are similar I really dont see it
Is iffy about the colour claim
claims blue
other than Im fine with

Greasy Spot

- fortysomething
The You Pikmin and Not a Stupid Pikmin stands out.
Hammers weirdly, no reasoning
Never gives a reason for it beyond he had a lot of time to defend himself
Gives reasoning that people didn't remove there votes before he hammered so its just as much there fault as it is his, I strongly disagree with this, they gave reasons.
Post 33 and beyond Ive written stuff like HYPOCRITE (for chastising someone for not giving reasoning for a vote) and :headdesk
His colour claim is purple.

Shin/Claus

Rolefishing

this is where I went onto my 4th cup of coffee so stopped concentrating

Claus
indifferent about the colour change to doesnt like it later on.
Bulbmin I feel is a bit of a convienient claim
Post 72, I dont think I was like that, I just said I wopuldnt be able to fully account for it.

UA & Jester 7 and 23
UA = nothing of value
Jester
Is ok with colour claim but doesnt know how it will help claims red
I dislike post 23
I would like more analysis from him

SpZ/UROE/Shamrock/Nightson

0/7/1/21
UROE voted sonikid
Nightson votes kirby
White, opinion on the colour claim is not given
He starts off well, his insistence on a windkirby lynch makes him look protown however he is lurking lots.

Can we get a prod on Nightson

Blazerunner/dcorbe/Fonz

- 20/18/7

BR
Crappy Vote
Dislike the conversation he has with Jdodge after said vote
Posts are detailed though.

Dcorbe
Votes windkirby
is okay with colour claim
Foot-mouth

Fonz
Made a detailed reread

---

Im sorry thats a bit bitty but I wanted to post it all now to get it out of the way and being at work I cant spend to much time on it. However my scumlist will come with my analysis on armlx which will be at lunch in a few hours.

[Porochaz]

armlx

This was done uber quick for my lunch needed to be quick

Against GS a lot. However there was one post where he did a u turn and it felt weird however it was the only thing I had fault with. He didnt make any direct comment about the colour change but it was obvious he had concerns. The one thing I noticed was he has 200 odd posts but many of them are 1 liners Id quite like to see some original analysis from him.

So scum list

This is in order from most to least...

Town

Kison
Claus
Fonz
Nightson

either

Armlx
jester
Skitzer

scum

[u/]

Xdaamo
Greasy Spot

vote Greasy Spot

if Im not already

[Claus]

Sorry, by "color change" you mean "color claim"?

[Porochaz]

yes sorry, I was typing quickly.