Non-Reviewed Game [game over]

[davesaz]

replace out

[Ankamius]

VOTE: Davesaz

[Wisdom]

lol

[MariaR]

pedit: Because her tone comes off extremely genuine and I don't see Sab getting into a fight with DT as scum and sticking to that read the whole game with such confidence. It seems more like town who's still somewhat upset. Along with the fact that a scumteam with Sab would inform her that she's getting wagoned. Out of all the wagons she was also the easiest to wagon. I believe she got to L-1 in 1 or 2 pages?

Lots of scum tunnel on a single player, it's common
Given how much she cared about getting wagoned, whether anyone informed her is irrelevant
All wagons after Enigma were equally quick and easy.

1) Sure they do, but the certainly behind her tone makes me think she believes it.
2) Don't think I fully think I understand what you're saying here.
3) The Enigma wagon got stuck. The others didn't.

I'm more confused on why you think that me and Sab can't be TvT but maybe I was just obvious of your opinion on my town game.

[Wisdom]

vote dave and maybe ill consider you tvt

[MariaR]

Do you think that replaceout was scummy?

[Wisdom]

replaceouts are nai

[Vedith]

replaceouts are nai

[MariaR]

fair.
VOTE: Dave
it's not Sab so!

[Dunnstral]

I don't believe in compromise lynches so I won't be participating in one

[Elsa Jay]

This jumping everywhere is fucking with me so much. Killing a slot that also replaces out is... Horrible too.

I hate unexplained and possibly tactical possibly IRL replace-outs.

Can anyone tell me why Dave is the prime choice, replacement not withstanding?

Pedit: Welcome back to the shitshow Dunn.

[Ankamius]

first I've heard of davesaz being a compromise lynch?

[Wisdom]

dave isnt compromise, dunn.

[Wisdom]

Elsa read Ank's points and also what i quoted from his last post. "Youre scumreading me for being myself" is scum frustration

[Ankamius]

dave's posts in the first like 5-10 pages are stand out scummy from everything else

light only started being scummy towards the back end of that range and a bit beyond that

[Elsa Jay]

davesaz is scum because his ISO is not good

by not good I mean there's a ton of that same type of posting in there

pointless question
weird engagements

etc.

This... Seems decent then. Frankly it's just weird now that he replaced out the second stuff happened.

Actually, I think this exact situation happened hefore with Dave. Yeah... It's not AI but I can't really see a way a new person can save that slot unless it's like Almost or something.

VOTE: Dave

[Ankamius]

davesaz is scum because his ISO is not good

by not good I mean there's a ton of that same type of posting in there

pointless question
weird engagements

etc.

This... Seems decent then. Frankly it's just weird now that he replaced out the second stuff happened.

Actually, I think this exact situation happened hefore with Dave. Yeah... It's not AI but I can't really see a way a new person can save that slot unless it's like Almost or something.

VOTE: Dave

posts like this are why I'm not hardtownreading you btw

[Ausuka]

Subject: NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

I'm gonna give you some self-meta, calmly and relatively gently.
It represents RL information and consequently is the truth.

I play as myself. This is not a persona, no mask, no fake outrage or ignorance, nada. It's actually unfiltered me.
I don't jump to conclusions. Jumping to conclusions can cause serious damage. I do make intuitive leaps but I don't put things on the line based on mere intuition.
I don't make stuff up -- no fake claims or fake results from me. I may occasionally exaggerate to make a point but I won't go all-out on said exaggeration.
If you're innocent I'm the guy you want on your jury. The facts have to make sense before I'll vote guilty.
If you're the prosecutor on a guilty defendant and at least minimally competent, I'm the guy you want on your jury. If the facts prove your case, I won't allow the guilty to walk.

When I'm scum and thus forced to lie, I'm painfully bad at lying. The reason I play is to get better at it. And to get better at detecting lies from others.

There you go, the plain unvarnished truth about me. It really upsets me a lot that site meta pretty much forces people to scumread me for it. I'm the opposite of site meta -- being careful is being me, not being scummy.

i feel like the same kind of sentiment dave expressed is also expressed here? and if he wasn't being genuine about it he probably wouldn't have replaced out.

the awkward interactions thing is something i don't really see, when i think about davesaz here vs his other games? the pointless questions thing I get but also I feel like town!dave could do that. i don't really townread him all too much, and it wouldn't be tragic if we lynched him today but, i still want sabrina rn. there's nothing to me that indicates she isn't aware of her wagon - quite the opposite, in 1094 she says that she's not reacting to her wagon because she's not scared of death. I don't see why scum, if they're feeling demotivated, don't go through with continually pushing on about one person specifically in order to articificially create content even if most of the points are NAI. Like idk I see essentially zero desire to scumhunt in her ISO and I can't really see that for anybody else.

[Fuscosco]

Im used to dave and questions. here though, they didnt lead ANYWHERE.

[Fuscosco]

they looked like filler-ish, I was gonna wait until tomorrow or something to see if he was just busy.

I respect Dave as a player too much to jump to an early conclusion without talking about it.

[Ankamius]

I didn't get that impression from sabrina at all

[Wisdom]

replaceout is nai, ausuka. He will prolly replace out when pushed for those things regardless of alignment. Disregard it.

[StarwingBeauvoi]

It's bad to jump on yet another wagon when one is sick (slightly), rushed, and unsure whether it is wise to be wise.
Replacing is null.

Maria's points are somewhat persuasive, neither terrible or wonderful.
Her claim is the exact kind of silliness someone would have made up.
Sabrina's posts are close to pointless. (One point, I grant.)
Yet her play is no better for scum than town.

Thus: UNVOTE:

[Wisdom]

maria still feels like tmi on sabrina. Sabrina's posts dont warrant the strong townread she has.

[Fuscosco]

she hasnt come out with anything.