@Aronis: Some explanations for your reads would be welcome (plus some more reads). I can only see a bit about your BBMolla read. Why is BPC town? Also, you're kinda hedging on beast. It's unclear whether you think he's town or scum. Which is it, and why?
In post 118, BBmolla wrote:Titus give me sufficient reasoning for why you believe Beast faked the knowledge of not knowing how many scum there are
Militis said it better than me. Two fails means at least two scum. Either beast is not reading, and thus a liability or he's scum. I don't really see beast being careless in any game.
Aronis is town because of his systemic approach that has no contractions in it as far as I see.
You just like to grasp at anything people like to scumread here.
In post 126, Mitillos wrote:@Aronis: Some explanations for your reads would be welcome (plus some more reads). I can only see a bit about your BBMolla read. Why is BPC town? Also, you're kinda hedging on beast. It's unclear whether you think he's town or scum. Which is it, and why?
I do not have any more reads I'm willing to share at this time.
@Molla: Are you saying you will also reject beast's team? Otherwise, why would you ask to move to the next leader? And if so, what happened to your beast townread? Also, you still haven't answered some of my other questions:
In post 120, Mitillos wrote:Why are Aronis and Titus scum? Why are Blackberry and I town? Is your third scum choice (one of BPC/Wisdom) due to PoE, or what?
@Aronis: OK, so you won't give other reads, but at least explain the BPC and molla ones. "BPC feels pretty town" is not an explanation as to why you are townreading him, just a statement of the fact that you are doing so. Also, what do you think about beast's suggested team in post 130?
In post 134, Mitillos wrote:@Molla: Are you saying you will also reject beast's team? Otherwise, why would you ask to move to the next leader? And if so, what happened to your beast townread? Also, you still haven't answered some of my other questions:
In post 120, Mitillos wrote:Why are Aronis and Titus scum? Why are Blackberry and I town? Is your third scum choice (one of BPC/Wisdom) due to PoE, or what?
@Aronis: OK, so you won't give other reads, but at least explain the BPC and molla ones. "BPC feels pretty town" is not an explanation as to why you are townreading him, just a statement of the fact that you are doing so. Also, what do you think about beast's suggested team in post 130?
I'm tired tonight, but fyi I'm having second thoughts about bpc, sorta jumped the gun on that read I guess. I'll explain molla in a bit.
I'm kinda basing all my reads off of Beast right now:
If Beast is scum, BBMolla is town because Beast suggested me-him-Molla. When we turned that down he randomly went to Titus/Aronis/BPC. This led me to believe:
Molla - Town
Beast - Scum
Titus/Aronis/BPC - 1 Scum
Mitilos/Wisdom - 1 Scum
... I wanted to see who beast would choose again if I asked him to pick 2 people including himself. He has selected Aronis & Molla in response to my question.
Going off my theory that Beast is scum, this means:
In post 141, Mitillos wrote:@Berry: Why would that make Molla town? Why would Titus/Aronis/BPC contain exactly one scum? I'm not following this at all.
Because if Beast is scum, he wants 1
and only 1
scum on the mission. Thus, if he is scum, Molla is town. It explains why he suddenly went from Me-Molla-himself to 3 other people (Titus-Aronis-BPC) not mentioned previously.
I'm contemplating whether I should answer or not. XD
Mod
- can you confirm, that like the game, scum are NOT allowed to communicate AT ALL outside the thread (pregame or during the game)?
If you have 2 scum on the team and they both put FAIL then everyone knows there's two scum in that group. Thus the optimal strategy for scum is to have 1 and exactly 1 scum in the group or A) they risk exposing both scum or B) they both vote to succeed and the town gets a point.
Btw, I just want to throw out if this was not communicated to scum and they HAVE talked outside the thread pre or postgame that we should immediately discard the game and restart. I'm sensing some people are newer to the game and if any of the scum didn't realize this is supposed to be a rule and have communicated with each other it does change the game quite a bit.