Fair point. I don't think it's that clear every game, but I think that the creature thing is actually still bizarre anyway. I would likely say that creature in those mislynched games literally didn't do anything and if he contributed a tad bit more he would be town read?In post 124, RadiantCowbells wrote:i've mislynched creature multiple times and nsg onceIn post 123, Volpe14 wrote:It's different than a player that gets past their scum range not even really putting effort in the game, that's what I mean.
i don't think it's as clear cut as you think it is
That's a bit bizarre when you think about it. Creature is in the more extreme sides but I do think that some of the point stands. (I think NSG needs to put more effort for people to really town read her, rather than literally just post, act normally or etc fwiw. She is often town read because she puts effort into solving the game and it makes her motivations more transparent?) I'm not sure if it's constructive to discuss this to be fair, I don't have a problem with more nightless games I think even with the above they are balanced enough and fun, I would just have a problem with making nightless games the new standard across the site but I don't think that's likely to happen, ever.
Nightkill as far as I've seen in forum mafia, is pretty standard and ingrained. I don't think it's going away.
We don't even have enough nightless games around currently in my opinion (I don't really consider Nightless Jester because I think jester changes scum hunting too much), so I think criticizing them to that extent might be overdoing it. I think more often than not they are balanced but I could see for the above them being unfun often enough for scum if most games were to become nightless.
)
