Mini 845 - The Amish Village (Game Over)

[don_johnson]

because the monkey with a gun thing is just a disguise for my extraordinary scumhunting abilities. seriously, why do you believe him?

[Amished]

Votecount 4-4:

VP Baltar (3): Debonair Danny DiPietro, don_johnson, Ojanen
Percy (1): magnus_orion
Debonair Danny DiPietro (1): VP Baltar
magnus_orion (2): Percy; FishytheFish

Not voting (0):

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.


Deadline in roughly 24 hours.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I actually think someone should hammer scum-Percy before he comes in and gets a mislynch on me.

DDD, seriously, you know as well as me that Percy's scum. Throw that hammer.

Doesn't much feel like the response of a supersaint to me. I also don't like the huge delay between when Fishy asked for the claim and when the claim was given. All in all I don't find the claim believable.

[don_johnson]

^^ i love this guy.

[Fishythefish]

because the monkey with a gun thing is just a disguise for my extraordinary scumhunting abilities. seriously, why do you believe him?

I don't. His claim makes him significantly more likely scum. But the penalty for being wrong and him being town is far, far greater than the penalty for being wrong and him being scum.

[magnus_orion]

I don't believe the claim either.

[don_johnson]

I don't believe the claim either.

then hammer. deadline is approaching.

[magnus_orion]

k
*shrug*

unvote
vote: VP

obviously, I'm town.

[Fishythefish]

That's not obvious at all. If VP is town, you will be too, and we lose. But if he's scum, you can easily be scum too.

*prays*

[Amished]

VP Baltar has been lynched. I'll post a end of day post in like 10 hours I'm guessing

[VP Baltar]

Well at least one of my scum suspects hammer. If your town magnus, don't blame me for the loss.

[don_johnson]

i would say that if vp flips scum, then the probability of magnus scum goes up tenfold. but let's wait and see.

mod: do we need to wait all that long?

[Amished]

I suppose not, if there's another person alive that wants to skip twilight, I'll just post my scene and lock the topic.

--edit--
can be done in thread or via PM

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Make with the scene posting, Amish boy.

[Amished]

After all that's happened with crop raiding, barn burnings and general shenanigans, the people have come to a consensus.

"VP Baltar must be lynched. I saw him using a microwave the other day!"

"No, I swear it was just an attempt to understand the mindset of the people we're hunting. I love being Amish, can't you see that?"

"I saw you pull out a little dish with noodles or something in them that was just steaming. I KNOW you used that microwave!"

And with that, the peace loving Amish sorrowfully erected the gallows again, leading VP Baltar up the stairs to the hangman's noose.

As VP was dropped and hung, a scream of agony was heard from behind you in the empty haybarn. As everyone rushes over to see what happened, you come across Percy, hanging from the rafters and a note in his pocket:

"I could not survive without my mentor; he's the only one that ever truly understood me. Now that he's gone, I no longer have the will to survive. Goodbye world, I feel sorry for you that none of you could feel the way I did since I met VP. No, it wasn't that type of feeling you Pervs!"

And with that; a feeling of hope came across the remaining villagers. One threat has been eliminated.

VP Baltar: Cult Mentor
and
Percy: Cult Mentee

have died.

Night ends in 72 hours. Please submit your night actions before that deadline.

[Amished]

Something about the town going out and getting drunk after their success. People passed out, but

magnus_orion, Vanilla Townie

never woke up.

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Not voting:
Ojanen
FishytheFish
don johnson
Debonair Danny DiPietro

[Fishythefish]

Any objections to a minimum-conversation no lynch? It's the best kind of no lynch, and no lynch is the best plan.

[don_johnson]

please explain.

[Fishythefish]

There are 4 of us. If we lynch someone wrongly, we lose. If we let the scum kill someone first, the odds improve. This applies unless someone has specific role-related information to the contrary.

[Fishythefish]

As for minimum information; the more we give our thoughts on each other, the more the scum knows who best to kill to win in lylo.

[don_johnson]

not sure why i wasn't killed. it seems scum would have thought vp was town. who was pushing the lynch, and who was scared off hammering?

i'm on a roll here. i'd rather not die. but whatever.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

not sure why i wasn't killed. it seems scum would have thought vp was town. who was pushing the lynch, and who was scared off hammering?

i'm on a roll here. i'd rather not die. but whatever.

Well then, which one of them do you think it is, Don? We've got Fishy who didn't believe the claim at all, but was too afraid to hammer which would make alot of sense from the last member of the scum team wondering if VPB is actually telling the truth. And then on the other hand we have Ojanen who managed to camp her vote despite saying, "but for lynching VP we need to be pretty damn sure" but she never unvoted despite the alleged hesitancy.

I have more but I want to hear from everyone else before I get into them.

[don_johnson]

i don't think fishy was afraid of hammering. fishy was already on the wagon and got off to stop someone else from hammering. is there a case on ojanen. i would think that if scum was on the wagon then they would have actually encouraged a hammer as they would have delighted in seeing two town players die, no?

fishy: scum should kill me tonight. i understand you, but i think we should lynch. screw the odds. we're not lynching me and we're not lynching you.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

i don't think fishy was afraid of hammering. fishy was already on the wagon and got off to stop someone else from hammering. is there a case on ojanen. i would think that if scum was on the wagon then they would have actually encouraged a hammer as they would have delighted in seeing two town players die, no?

fishy: scum should kill me tonight. i understand you, but i think we should lynch. screw the odds. we're not lynching me and we're not lynching you.

Fishy wasn't on the wagon, he just threatened a hammer to get a claim and then shifted over to Magnus after the Supersaint claim. It fits rather neatly as scum, threaten a hammer on perceived town get something that becomes dangerous to hammer so move over to a different town lynch while still encouraging a towns person to hammer the claim just in case it backfires. Of course there's a town slant as well, but the scum narrative is compelling.

[don_johnson]

hm. i'll have to reread. i was hoping to avoid that.