Open 448: Diffusion of Power (Game Over! Scum Win)

[TheReverend]

JESUS THE SUSPENSE IS KILLING ME

[Jackal711]

VOTE COUNT 6.Final

rapidcanyon (1) - Majiffy
Majiffy (2) - rapidcanyon, TheReverend
TheReverend (0) -

Not Voting:

With 3 alive, it's 2 to lynch.

As of Post #1299,

Majiffy

was lynched. He was a

Town Cop

TheReverend

,

Town Cop

, endgamed Day 6.

rapidcanyon

,

Mafia Goon

, survives.

The scum team of

rapidcanyon, Abaddon, Paschendale

wins!

[Jackal711]

Complete Role List:

Psyche - Night 1 Doctor
Majiffy - Night 1 Cop

Cogito Ergo Sum - Night 2 Doctor

DoubleJD - Night 3 Cop
TheReverend - Night 3 Cop
FourTrouble - Night 3 Doctor

The Acting Method - Night 5 Cop
Sotty7 - Night 5 Cop
malpascp - Night 5 Doctor
CF Riot - Night 5 Doctor

Paschendale - Mafia Goon
rapidcanyon - Mafia Goon
Abaddon - Mafia Goon

[Jackal711]

Night 1 Actions:
Majiffy (Cop): Investigate DoubleJD (Town)
Psyche (Doc): Protect Eidolon
Mafia Kill: Psyche (Success)

Night 2 Actions:
Eidolon (Doc): No action submitted.
Mafia Kill: CF Riot (Success)

Night 3 Actions:
FourTrouble (Doc): Protect DoubleJD
TheReverend (Cop): Investigate TAM (Town)
DoubleJD (Cop): Sotty7 (Town)
Mafia Kill: TAM (Success)

Night 4 Actions:
Mafia Kill: DoubleJD (Success)

Night 5 Actions:
Sotty7 (Cop): TheReverend (Town)
Mafia Kill: Sotty7 (Success)

[Jackal711]

Scum QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/xSWwy2uqHJGBL
Dead QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/VGkZXpaiUDSSa

[Jackal711]

Thanks everyone for playing. I thought town had it after back-to-back scum lynches Day 2 and 3. Rapid played an awesome scum game, his cop fakeclaim with the guilty on Abaddon was well played.

[TheReverend]

Yeah seriously, well played rapid. As soon as I done your iso I knew I was voting majiffy. You're an excellent scum.

maj, I really don't like the insta-vote on lylo day, you made it too easy for rapid. Can't see how you ever think I'm going to vote for rapid when you make that play. Having said that, I don't think it made much difference, it just helped me come to my final decision quicker.

Thanks jackal for modding.

[CF Riot]

Good game Rapid. You won this one with the night game and your bus of Abaddon. If you check the dead QT you had everyone fooled. I gotta quit defending all the scums in games I replace into.

[FourTrouble]

Well played rapid, congratulations on the win.

[TheReverend]

Me and maj lost this between us. I shoulda looked up maj or rapid with my cop and kept my mouth shut if I got a inno, since it was pretty obvious that it was gonna be me, maj and rapid lylo. That was a bad mistake on my part.

Reading the scum QT is interesting, not least venrob attacking rapid for tunneling and bussing. But it was all this d1 and d2 action that had me convinced rapid was town. Had he not been so gung ho at the two scum, I'd still be trying to decide who to lynch today.

Glad to see the deads didn't really have a clue either. It's not like I made a stupid decision here at lylo. My stupid moment came when I looked up TAM and not one of rapid or maj. That single action cost us the win. Sorry for that town.

[DoubleJD]

Lame, i waffled hard in the dead thread. Shoulda just trusted my gut, then i coulda been all like "TOLDYA SOES". Lame

GG guys

[Majiffy]

It wasn't an insta-vote, you tard. Did you even read the post times like I told you to?

ITT Reverend proves he's the moron I was saying he was since the beginning.

[TheReverend]

Yes I read the post times, you utter genius and wonderful person. Nowhere did you make any attempt to show me that rapid was scum, you just threw a vote in without any discussion whatsoever and hoped for the best. May I say how much I like your new avatar. So anyway, my brilliant friend, I think your town tactic of being rude and unhelpful is a very good one, and is a sure way to ensure solidarity at lylo when it really matters. I strongly believe that your in depth analysis today was important, you are certainly an asset to the town. I really look forward to the next game we play. God let me be vig.

(imo, voting one hour after after thread opens at lylo and before either of the other two players post, I consider this to be "insta", but I recognise we may differ in opinion here)

[Majiffy]

Well

I

was voting scum.

You derp.

[TheReverend]

Lol great response. You had a choice between me and rapid. I had a choice between you and rapid.

I could provide a town case for rapid, due to him playing excellent as scum. I could provide a scum case for you, due to you playing badly as town.

I played badly, I made some costly mistakes. I'll accept my failings. But I tried to figure it out today. It comes down to that single sentence above, you looked a lot scummier than him because you were rude and unhelpful, while he appeared to be pro town and focussed. My mistake was not today, it was when I wasted my cop look up.

[Majiffy]

And your choice was moronic.

He didn't play excellent scum btw, you're just an idiot. In the future, do keep in mind that "rude and unhelpful" is not a scumtell.

[Majiffy]

Oh, and follow the flow-chart.

[TheReverend]

Noted, rude and unhelpful is not a scumtell. But it's most certainly not pro-town. Had this been a 50-50 decision for me (which it wasn't), then your attitude would've been the reason we lost, simply because I prefer to lose to rapid than you.

You can't even grant rapid the credit he deserves. You'd sooner focus your energy on arguing with me. All I can say about that is I'm glad I'm not a negative person. Maybe you should find Jesus or something.

[Majiffy]

Voting by whom you "prefer to lose to" isn't pro-town either, you derp.

Why would I grant him credit? I was calling him scum as early as I was calling you scum. If he was playing superbly as scum I wouldn't have done so, now would I?

[TheReverend]

I called him scum, I sniffed out that fake cop claim instantly, but I don't expect a pat on the back for that. And the fact you were calling me scum shows me that you were just binking random targets... if I name the entire town as potential scum throughout the game, does that mean I can claim credit when those who show up scum show up in my lists?

And I didn't vote based on who I prefer to lose to, but if it was a 50-50 decision, then I probably would. This was not a 50-50 decision because rapid looked like town and you didn't. That's why I think he played well, and why I think you played badly. I'm not pretending I played well. Your ego is so huge that even now you think you have some ground to stand proud on. Here's a fact - neither of us do. Get some dignity and recognise a brilliant scum win when it smacks you in the face.

[Majiffy]

I called him scum, I sniffed out that fake cop claim instantly, but I don't expect a pat on the back for that.

And the fact you were calling me scum shows me that you were just binking random targets... if I name the entire town as potential scum throughout the game, does that mean I can claim credit when those who show up scum show up in my lists?

That's a strawman and you know it. I didn't name the entire town, I was pretty picky with my scum reads. Your complete idiocy threw me off on you but you eventually recovered to a town read. Note when I stopped pushing for you a while back.

And I didn't vote based on who I prefer to lose to, but if it was a 50-50 decision, then I probably would. This was not a 50-50 decision because rapid looked like town and you didn't. That's why I think he played well, and why I think you played badly. I'm not pretending I played well. Your ego is so huge that even now you think you have some ground to stand proud on. Here's a fact - neither of us do. Get some dignity and recognise a brilliant scum win when it smacks you in the face.

... Still wasn't a brilliant scum win. It was a stupid Rev loss.

[TheReverend]

If you say so. I was faced with a decision... person A, who named two scum as his suspects on d1 and gave us a guiltly on scum, and who was appearing to scumhunt, or person B, who was rude to anyone who would indulge him, and made no real effort to find the scum. I'm making that same decision all day every day. You might not accept this, but that reflects on your performance as town, and his as scum.

WE lost this game maj, you and I, doing exactly what we're doing now.

[TheReverend]

JESUS LOVES YOU MAJIFFY

[Majiffy]

"Made no real effort to find the scum" is just silly rhetoric. Obviously I was looking for scum.

And maybe you should consider the situation a bit more as well; Rev-Rapid-Maj lylo is infinitely better for Rapid than it is for me. Sotty kill made no sense.

[rapidcanyon]

This was a really fun game. I had a lot of fun playing with you guys. I think the longest game I ever played - 2 months. I do think we got a bit lucky with the night actions. With all the cops and docs in the game, I figured TAM was going to get investigated and cleared at some point so I knew that mislynch was out of the question. Lucky for us, we killed him on the night he was investigated. Also, as you saw from the scum QT, Pasch didn't like the fact that I distanced from him and told me to lay off which resulted in me not even voting for Pasch despite being the biggest loudmouth about his lynch. I guess it was because I figured we couldn't rely on Venrob so I knew it was just Pasch and me. I think town played well too. CF Riot and FourTrouble were two people we identified as heavy threats but night-killing CF early helped ease the tension a bit. And it was great playing with Rev as well - you are probably going to think I am scum next game we play together.

Thanks Jackal for modding. You were really helpful and quick with the vote counts and the general handling of this game. This was a lot of fun and I'd certainly love to play in your future games if you'll have me.