Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Kokichi Oma]

and why couldn't embargo help us?

you also know there's 2 resolutions to choose from right?
which im assuming are the gold/crab thing and the embargo

Why not have all options out on the table?

[Kokichi Oma]

If you disagree with the choices Titus makes today, vote against her resolutions and convince everyone to put someone else in these positions tomorrow.

No, now you're just trying not to take blame if it's wrong. Can you tell me what the harm of advancing and having gold on the discussion is? Why wouldn't we want to advance and why wouldn't we want to have Gold as a discussion for banning?

Tomorrow, if I am around, Gold ban will be suggested. I would rather save that one for night 2, when people would presumably have earned some gold and would be looking to spend it.

I'm not trying to avoid the blame, again, if people feel that I have been wrong, let them not vote me to host tomorrow. Hell, I'll say right now, I think Joey_ or Nero are good hosts. We're going to be held accountable just like any politician.

Fine, but I just disagree with this. It's likely mafia has to use gold for something. And it's likely they will use it N1.

[Kokichi Oma]

Now that's over with, let's all be friends again and lynch Creature.

[brassherald]

and why couldn't embargo help us?

you also know there's 2 resolutions to choose from right?
which im assuming are the gold/crab thing and the embargo

Why not have all options out on the table?

Fine:
Ban Gold, Ban Crabs, Ban Silk, Embargo City states permanently, Embargo a player, Peacekeeping, Protect natural wonders, protect world wonders, Fund the arts for everyone, fund science for one person.

Those are our choices.

I think we have mentioned each.

[Kokichi Oma]

Ban Gold, Ban Crabs, Ban Silk, Peackeeping Brass, Fund Arts for Everyone, Fund Science for Brass.

How is that hard at all.

[Nero Cain]

just to clarify something but may not mean anything at all...the gold that's being proposed to be banned is a luxury resource. It makes ppl happy in the game. It is NOT the same as gold that you use to buy shit with. Although, you DO get like +2 to gold (+3 with some building) for each gold resource.

[Kokichi Oma]

How did Embargo come up before any of those after the 3 you chose?

[Kokichi Oma]

just to clarify something but may not mean anything at all...the gold that's being proposed to be banned is a luxury resource. It makes ppl happy in the game. It is NOT the same as gold that you use to buy shit with. Although, you DO get like +2 to gold (+3 with some building) for each gold resource.

Yeah, I know. But, I'm thinking more of the lines of the corruption that comes with Gold in the game.

[Nero Cain]

Why are we not protecting our natural wonders? Am I really the only hippie here?!?

[Nero Cain]

Yeah, I know. But, I'm thinking more of the lines of the corruption that comes with Gold in the game.

Have you ever played Civ? I don't really think that's a thing. Although, I don't think I've ever really sat down and read a mechanics thing.

[brassherald]

I don't know that I can use science advancement. Which is why I put fund the arts as my non-ban choice.

Again, my belief is that Banning gold would be more valuable day 2.

And Nero seems to have played Civ V lots more than me because I didn't remember that about gold in there. I have just been using the Civ VI model, which I believe replaced gold with... maybe silver?

P-edit protecting natural wonders is permanent, and if it is not pro-town, I would be concerned with putting a permanent thing in place so early.

[Kokichi Oma]

I've last played Civilization 5, so I figured it was the same. But, maybe not.

https://www.civfanatics.com/civ3/strate ... c-edition/

[Kokichi Oma]

Why are we not protecting our natural wonders? Am I really the only hippie here?!?

I'm guessing we don't have one yet?

[brassherald]

The corruption could just be flavor text. You will see when the actual resolutions to vote on come out, I believe.

[Kokichi Oma]

@Mod in terms of science advancement can it be used by anyone or is it more specific than that

[Kokichi Oma]

I've last played Civilization 5, so I figured it was the same. But, maybe not.

https://www.civfanatics.com/civ3/strate ... c-edition/

Civilization 3**

[Nero Cain]

I've last played Civilization 5, so I figured it was the same. But, maybe not.

https://www.civfanatics.com/civ3/strate ... c-edition/

That's about Civ 3 not Civ V. :/

[Kokichi Oma]

That's what I meant. So corruption isn't a thing at all in Civ 5?

[Nero Cain]

pretty sure its not thought there are other Civ players here too that may know more than me.

[brassherald]

Nope, not in Civ 5, that was my first one and I did not know it was a mechanic ever.

Also not in Civ 6 FWIW.

There may be mods to add it in.

[Nero Cain]

@Brass

Why are we not protecting our natural wonders? Am I really the only hippie here?!?

this was mostly a joke b/c IRL I'd consider myself a bit of an environmentalist.

Based on the list that you gave I'd pick peackeep and fund arts? Like, in the game I'm against the ban of luxuries and embargoing city states. Outguessing the mod is a bit dumb but if I took a stab I'd say that luxuries and wonders give the players bonuses but its prob for all players (both scum and town). Embargo a player I bet is a roleblock.

[Titus]

If you disagree with the choices Titus makes today, vote against her resolutions and convince everyone to put someone else in these positions tomorrow.

No, now you're just trying not to take blame if it's wrong. Can you tell me what the harm of advancing and having gold on the discussion is? Why wouldn't we want to advance and why wouldn't we want to have Gold as a discussion for banning?

Tomorrow, if I am around, Gold ban will be suggested. I would rather save that one for night 2, when people would presumably have earned some gold and would be looking to spend it.

I'm not trying to avoid the blame, again, if people feel that I have been wrong, let them not vote me to host tomorrow. Hell, I'll say right now, I think Joey_ or Nero are good hosts. We're going to be held accountable just like any politician.

Fine, but I just disagree with this. It's likely mafia has to use gold for something. And it's likely they will use it N1.

Then we'll know what it is and save ban gold for later.

[Joey_]

That's what I meant. So corruption isn't a thing at all in Civ 5?

Not in civ5, i thought you were softing something about corruption honestly

[Kokichi Oma]

Titus is very likely scum ftr.

[Joey_]

Funding art could be fun no? It applies to everyone so we cant really screw the town that much