In post 1164, RedFlavor wrote:Claiming that you are afraid of getting PRhunted is basically claiming that you are a PR. But if you were really cautious of getting PRhunted you would not mention being cautious of getting PRhunted, because saying that you are cautious of getting PRhunted is basically telling scum to kill you.
No? I'm cautious of pushing anyone because they might drop PR tells. Where did I refer to myself getting PR hunted in that post?
Come On People, i'm obviously town!
I literally quoted Gamma saying he was afraid of people dropping PR tells and used a smiley. There is no way that this could be interpreted as a serious crumb rather than a joke.
Yeah and guess what? I'd dropped a crumb as a joke in a past game with Mathdino as well, Tit for Tat. So it's logical to expect him to comb for that sort of crumb as well, which seems to be what he did from reading further down.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
In post 1391, Mathdino wrote:If it's a joke, then it shouldn't be HIS ACTUAL ROLECLAIM.
Why's that?
Humor is humor. I'd make that joke no matter WHAT my role.
I hate it when people argue this. NSG pulled the same shit of "oh I totally act the exact same as PR, VT, and scum" which is just straight up false. When you're a PR, you play with a different mindset. I played this one like shit and figured
- if CT flips scum, probably gg scum even if I get shot
- if CT flips town, at least I'm not getting killed tonight and can gamesolve tomorrow
You play more survivalistically, you're incredibly aware that the game could be decided on whether or not you get NK'd.
And you don't fucking openly crumb your role. People say they'd do that but they straight up don't.
Gimme some time to metadive and if that looks right, then sure.
Tbh I kinda prefer to just resolve 1v1s on the spot with a pre-ordained lynch order afterwards, since there are more townies alive to talk about the decision. If one of them had the chance to flip information (like mafia roleblocker) or if there were a mechanical benefit to lynching confscum, then sure, but as it is, lynching the partner today just kills a townie.
I'm actually gonna read the game like we'd lynched Smart and you'd been NKed, and see who makes the most sense as Smart's partner. If it's Penguin I'm okay voting Penguin, if not then this will take some thought
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
In post 1401, Gamma Emerald wrote:So it's logical to expect him to comb for that sort of crumb as well, which seems to be what he did from reading further down.
This is not what I'm arguing, he obviously SAW it as I expected everyone to see it. I'm talking about him intentionally ignoring the possibility that I just wanted to make a joke because of some bullshit about how "a real cop wouldn't joke crumb their role".
In post 1680, Something_Smart wrote:I noticed that you thought I was a gunsmith; that was more or less my plan. When I said "I know Espe's role" I (like Ari) thought he was a BG, but after he claimed miller I realized I could spin it into a cop crumb, so I spent the rest of the day implying that I was a cop (hence me putting so much emphasis on "maybe there's another role that will make miller make more sense"). I switched to JK kind of on a whim when EE claimed to have checked me.
this was as a 1-shot BP
smart does not crumb his actual role as PR, he crumbs in a way that draws or dodges the nightkill accordingly
this is playing smart
there is 0 fucking reason to think that mafia wouldn't just fucking shoot him straight up in this game for openly crumbing C-O-P
you know damn well that almost everyone in this game would, as scum, shoot you for that
"I just want to play mafia, not Economics Wonderland." - cytheflyguy
In post 1401, Gamma Emerald wrote:So it's logical to expect him to comb for that sort of crumb as well, which seems to be what he did from reading further down.
This is not what I'm arguing, he obviously SAW it as I expected everyone to see it. I'm talking about him intentionally ignoring the possibility that I just wanted to make a joke because of some bullshit about how "a real cop wouldn't joke crumb their role".
literally correct though
this game is more evidence for that rule
"I just want to play mafia, not Economics Wonderland." - cytheflyguy
In post 1409, Mathdino wrote:there is 0 fucking reason to think that mafia wouldn't just fucking shoot him straight up in this game for openly crumbing C-O-P
"There is 0 reason to think that mafia wouldn't shoot someone for making a joke."
Gamma. Listen to his argument here. Even he admitted that it was clearly a joke AND that his first thought was that I was VT trying to draw the NK... and now he says there's no reason to believe that scum won't kill me.
In post 1409, Mathdino wrote:there is 0 fucking reason to think that mafia wouldn't just fucking shoot him straight up in this game for openly crumbing C-O-P
"There is 0 reason to think that mafia wouldn't shoot someone for making a joke."
Gamma. Listen to his argument here. Even he admitted that it was clearly a joke AND that his first thought was that I was VT trying to draw the NK... and now he says there's no reason to believe that scum won't kill me.
fucking wat
on this site, scum kills people for making jokes like that, full stop
AS A VT
making that joke would've been a great play, because it's clearly fake, but it's also the kind of thing that gets you killed
AS AN ACTUAL COP
that would be fucking stupid, because there's no reason to believe scum wouldn't just shoot you for even a joke
"I just want to play mafia, not Economics Wonderland." - cytheflyguy
This is a complete misrep. He thought it was that or scum dropping a crumb to point to as their proof of claim. What he's saying I believe is that you can't say it was a joke and then point to it as your crumb. That's just playing both sides.
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
<Embrace The Void>