Mini Normal 1996: Floral Mafia [Endgame!]

[Gamma Emerald]

I like the reasoning but I wouldn't nail Katherine as scum based solely on that yet.

it was a joke then?

This and katherine's previous posts look like shy scum.

why is 38 bad then

[MariaR]

VOTE: katherine
Too many already.
btw I'm super excited about this playerlist

This being Gamma's only post so far looks terrible.

Why?

I'm so excited *lurks*

ehhh could've been busy irl etc etc
doesn't seem that good a reason
Pedit: Even if he agrees with the read doesn't mean he can't think my reasoning is shit gamma

[Luca Blight]

idk how to take Havos change if he said it was before the game that would've made it now saying he did it while he was posting could mean self conscious scum but the tone so far feels like town who genuinely didn't want to fuck something up.
Whew sr and a tr so far Maria you are on fire
Pedit: I don't think you should give tips regardless and let us see the reaction

This feels like fake sorting - reading too much into something NAI while drawing a vague conclusion -

"could be scum, could be town"

.

[Gamma Emerald]

Can we not excuse d1 quickhammers

I won’t be. Disclaimer or not I’ll be pushing a lynch on anyone who quick hammers without a claim. Unless it’s a scum flip, I’ll reward bad play if it benefits town.

I mean it could be scum ending discussion early so not even that is excusable

[MariaR]

It's not NAI because he said he changed it while posting. It would've been NAI if he said he changed it before the game

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't think there's enough reason to scum read mumble. I do appreciate activity but I feel like you're definitely trying to take control of the game and I also don't like how you pointed out you could be aggressive as scum also.

VOTE: mumble

VOTE: Tchill

ew

Well I guess only the first part of the post is objectively false the 2nd part is just a matter of opinion

What second part? The part about kts taking control? That's not why I voted, I voted for the inconsistency.

[Gamma Emerald]

Feeling like Harry Potter mash MS version.

Oh man what happened there

Gamethrowing town character-claiming and giving scum extra NK for the remaining nights.

I mean in Overwatch town didn't lynch the lovers in 5p lylo so lolmu

[Gamma Emerald]

Luca Blight can also join the townclub. If there's scum on Tchill it's Gamma.

pedit: If we lynched Tchill and he flipped scum, I probably wouldn't townread KTS for it. Them being scumbuddies could explain him continuing to hard-townread KTS even after KTS himself dismissed his point, but that's kinda meh. He'd stay null.

Excuse me? What about my vote looks like a bus?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm townread ... Tchill for particular reasons.

You're wrong

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: katherine
Too many already.
btw I'm super excited about this playerlist

This being Gamma's only post so far looks terrible.

Why?

I'm so excited *lurks*

ehhh could've been busy irl etc etc
doesn't seem that good a reason
Pedit: Even if he agrees with the read doesn't mean he can't think my reasoning is shit gamma

Well what happened was I had to get off to clean the house then I went to bed

[Luca Blight]

It's not NAI because he said he changed it while posting. It would've been NAI if he said he changed it before the game

It's not particularly AI because he equally could have changed it as either alignment - as scum because he doesn't want to draw as much attention to himself; as town because he doesn't want the game being sidetracked by the same issue again.

Hence why you weren't able to draw a useful conclusion from it.

[MariaR]

It's not NAI because he said he changed it while posting. It would've been NAI if he said he changed it before the game

It's not particularly AI because he equally could have changed it as either alignment - as scum because he doesn't want to draw as much attention to himself; as town because he doesn't want the game being sidetracked by the same issue again.

Hence why you weren't able to draw a useful conclusion from it.

Hence why I asked questions after to get a better answer but this is just leading to a dead end

pretty sure kath is still a decent vote although I'd lynch Ausuka too

[MariaR]

Only issue with Ausuka scum is it somewhat points to Tchii scum and ehhh on that.

[Luca Blight]

My problem wasn't with your question, though - it was with the useless conclusion you drew from it.

[MariaR]

Luca Blight can also join the townclub. If there's scum on Tchill it's Gamma.

pedit:

If we lynched Tchill and he flipped scum, I probably wouldn't townread KTS for it.

Them being scumbuddies could explain him continuing to hard-townread KTS even after KTS himself dismissed his point, but that's kinda meh. He'd stay null.

The Luca tr comes out of no where "Oh look a towny who made a wall post that seems to have reasoning lets tr that" The bolded is interesting cause the first thing that came to mind was "Partner with Tchill who knows he'll flip scum and is trying to not credit KTS"
The hedge here is the bad type of hedge too
Pedit: That I tr him?

[Luca Blight]

The useless conclusion being:

"could be scum, could be town"

.

----

I didn't get the impression this was much more than a null read at this point.

[MariaR]

No I tr Havo I thought I made that very clear

[Ausuka]

Luca Blight can also join the townclub. If there's scum on Tchill it's Gamma.

pedit:

If we lynched Tchill and he flipped scum, I probably wouldn't townread KTS for it.

Them being scumbuddies could explain him continuing to hard-townread KTS even after KTS himself dismissed his point, but that's kinda meh. He'd stay null.

The Luca tr comes out of no where

Where is it supposed to come from? It's page 8. What he posted makes sense and appears to come from a town mindset.

"Oh look a towny who made a wall post that seems to have reasoning lets tr that"

...What I did was literally just townreading Luca. That's it. There's absolutely no reason why that means I'm scum here. Like maybe if you were scumreading me for not giving reasoning I could at least understand it. But what you're doing here just makes no sense at all.

The bolded is interesting cause the first thing that came to mind was "Partner with Tchill who knows he'll flip scum and is trying to not credit KTS"

... what. KTS isn't even voting Tchill. No, he doesn't get towncred because he pushed him for like a page at the start of a game.

I'm pretty happy voting this for now actually.
VOTE: MariaR

[MariaR]

while he was posting could mean self conscious scum but the tone so far feels like town who genuinely didn't want to fuck something up.

Whew sr

and a tr so far

Maria you are on fire

[Luca Blight]

Yeah, that's not very clear - the first line looks as though you're sitting on the fence, and the second doesn't make it clear who you're referring to.

It's also a flimsy reason for anything other than a tentative town-lean at best, imo.

[Gamma Emerald]

Luca are you intentionally being obtuse
she was tring Havo and SRing katherine

[MariaR]

Luca Blight can also join the townclub. If there's scum on Tchill it's Gamma.

pedit:

If we lynched Tchill and he flipped scum, I probably wouldn't townread KTS for it.

Them being scumbuddies could explain him continuing to hard-townread KTS even after KTS himself dismissed his point, but that's kinda meh. He'd stay null.

The Luca tr comes out of no where

Where is it supposed to come from? It's page 8. What he posted makes sense and appears to come from a town mindset.

"Oh look a towny who made a wall post that seems to have reasoning lets tr that"

...What I did was literally just townreading Luca. That's it. There's absolutely no reason why that means I'm scum here. Like maybe if you were scumreading me for not giving reasoning I could at least understand it. But what you're doing here just makes no sense at all.

The bolded is interesting cause the first thing that came to mind was "Partner with Tchill who knows he'll flip scum and is trying to not credit KTS"

... what. KTS isn't even voting Tchill. No, he doesn't get towncred because he pushed him for like a page at the start of a game.

I'm pretty happy voting this for now actually.
VOTE: MariaR

1)hey look you finally posted reasoning on your luca tr as you should've done in the first place! It's a start.
2)I can think you're scum for any reason I want I don't get how you think not making sense=scum
3) Also should've been stated in the first post
Well at least I got to squeeze something out of you

[northsidegal]

-

[northsidegal]

-

[northsidegal]

-