Nomic: The game where YOU make the rules!

[DiplomatDC]

HEAL: 338

Proposal 339: The first player to consume 7 pieces of fruit wins. Fruits may only be consumed one at a time, with a 24 hour cooldown between consumptions. Lightbulbs are not fruit.

[DiplomatDC]

Amend 339 to say

The first player to consume 7 pieces of fruit after this rule is instated wins. Fruits may only be consumed one at a time, with a 24 hour cooldown between consumptions. Lightbulbs are not fruit.

[Irrelephant11]

HEAL: all

Proposal 340: Players may not consume the same fruit twice in a row.

Proposal 341: Any player May exchange any lightbulb for a raspberry at any time

[123456789]

HURT: 339
Make it unique fruit and I'll pass it.

HURT: 340
Why not?

I'm abstaining for the time being on 341.

[DiplomatDC]

I'll see if 339 can pass without the unique clause (yeah im kinda a bitch here)

340 and 341 seem like they need to be passed together.

[skitter30]

can I /in?

[Charles510]

I think you just did! Welcome!

[skitter30]

sweet!

how do 332 and proposal 337 interact with each other?

HEAL: 338

HURT: 339 - I feel like there's too many ways to obtain fruit given 310 and 333. I'd consider voting for the unique version though (ie they must consume 7 different types of fruit in order to win). Although I'd probably want to up the number of fruit too I think. This version makes 340 kinda pointless so

HURT: 340

HEAL: 341

[DiplomatDC]

HURT: 339

Proposal 342: The first player to consume 7 pieces of fruit after this rule is instated wins. Fruits may only be consumed one at a time, with a 24 hour cooldown between consumptions. Give DiplomatDC a lemon.

[DiplomatDC]

Edit:

Proposal 342: The first player to consume 7 unique pieces of fruit after this rule is instated wins. Fruits may only be consumed one at a time, with a 24 hour cooldown between consumptions. Give DiplomatDC a lemon.

Forgot the unique clause

[skitter30]

Proposal 343: lemons are classified as vegetables

[DiplomatDC]

Proposal 344: Vegetables are also fruit. Give skitter30 a turnip.

[2 718281828459]

I only did 334 because I thought 332 failed...

Anyway, VOTE: Yes 338

[2 718281828459]

Whoa, I read page 7 and forgot 8 existed...

HURT: 339, 341, 344. Also with 15 lightbulbs each, that could be quite profitable.
VOTE: Yes 342, but I am going to have to say VOTE: Yes 343 as well.

I would like to invest in the market. (We should keep a running total of all investors and the current trading price.)

[2 718281828459]

One last thing, I would like to spend one point to get a watermelon.

[DiplomatDC]

I'm going to inquire if 343 implicitly states that lemons are no longer classified as fruit

[skitter30]

HEAL: 342
HEAL: 344

If I have any lightbulbs I'd like to invest in the lightbulb market.

I feel like vegetables and fruits and two distinct categories, and as such, if a lemon is a vegetable it is implied it is not a fruit because it cant be both.

[123456789]

Yikes, ya'll did a lot.

Updating now...

[123456789]

HURT: 342, 344
Abstaining on 343.
Still abstaining on 341.

[123456789]

I'm going to inquire if 343 implicitly states that lemons are no longer classified as fruit

No, it does not.

[123456789]

HEAL: 342
HEAL: 344

If I have any lightbulbs I'd like to invest in the lightbulb market.

I feel like vegetables and fruits and two distinct categories, and as such, if a lemon is a vegetable it is implied it is not a fruit because it cant be both.

The thing is, in Nomic, you can say whatever you like about a thing. For instance, we currently have a rule that bees are equivalent to Watermelons. Obviously, such a rule is preposterous in real life.

Thus, in Nomic, most things have to be explicit, and this is one of those things.

[DiplomatDC]

Can he edit it to explicitly say that then? B/c I'm assuming it is his intent.

If he cannot,

Proposal 345: If Proposal 343 passes, edit it to say

lemons are classified as vegetables and no longer classified as fruit, unless future rules state otherwise

[DiplomatDC]

HEAL: Proposals 340 and 341

[123456789]

Please don't forget that proposals 337, 340, 341, 342, 343, and 344 are still active. Unless you have a reason not to, make sure you are voting! (Don't just pocket-veto the proposals by letting them expire!)

Also, spending two points to gain two watermelons.

Pedit: Why must you do this to me?
HURT: 345
I hate the

unless future rules state otherwise

clause.
Pedit2: Stop it! I *just* finished updating .

[123456789]

Can he edit it to explicitly say that then? B/c I'm assuming it is his intent.

If he cannot,

Proposal 345: If Proposal 343 passes, edit it to say

lemons are classified as vegetables and no longer classified as fruit, unless future rules state otherwise

And yes, they can, but they must do so formally, and they must do it themselves.