Mini Normal 2314 - The Mafia Have a Cop [END]

[JacksonVirgo]

although the fact we're informed of the mafia cop makes me think it's either a red herring or there's some other more complex role interaction

It was labelled as a complex game

[JacksonVirgo]

Mafia could have a Traitor this game to warrant the Cop. I can’t really think of any other reason the Cop knowledge would be there.

It doesn't really matter at this point in the game

[JacksonVirgo]

Highkey dont like the speed of gammas wagon

BUT also i think gammas scum so likeee

Anyways hu tao looks the worst on gamma wagon #imsogood

This reads incredibly awkward

[JacksonVirgo]

the answer to that question was simple:

i'm not a miller here, which is clear from the beginning, even if you have to say only in hindsight, which is fine. it's early game, it was a great source to get people to react on it from.

answering that question then, which I did later just not directly to you, would have just ended it there.

Yeah, I am the real Miller fr fr

[JacksonVirgo]

I'm actually a Informed Macho Cop-Enabler Miller and I'm informed that the Mafia know that my role exists.

[JacksonVirgo]

ah damn, are Marci and Gamma scum together? Could just be Marci white knight.

gonna avoid that thought for now because it's just paranoia, but i got big pings from that marci. looks like a performance, but i can see them posting like that as town.

And im kinda okay letting others solve for Marci.

I've gotten the same pings from Marci but I think it's isolated from Gamma, I don't see a pairing per se

[JacksonVirgo]

Also it's weak pings, just feels awkward as I said earlier

[JacksonVirgo]

Hu Tao
jjh027
Geraintm

Unabombah (free seat for them here for now)
Roden
Gamma Emerald

The Bulge
Nono
JacksonVirgo

Neutral but slight under the nulls^

Doctor Drew
Marcistar

Xegarus

Town

-

Lean Town

-

Light Town

-

Neutral

-

Light Scum

-

Lean Scum

-

Scum

I gave you a smooch and you have the balls to not conf-town me????

[JacksonVirgo]

honestly bulge and jacksonvirgo are both people who i dont even remember what they've said

Wow congrats, it's like the game just started or something

[JacksonVirgo]

Yeah, it’s Drew and Jackson

Yeah I agree

[marcistar]

Highkey dont like the speed of gammas wagon

BUT also i think gammas scum so likeee

Anyways hu tao looks the worst on gamma wagon #imsogood

This reads incredibly awkward

Sure it does, keep telling yourself that xoxo

[JacksonVirgo]

Flavor Leaf (1) - I'd honestly consider giving up one of my three Genie-wishes for having the ability to 100% accurately read this player. Just so I could either death-tunnel or townblock him every time. I think I am rather good at sorting anyone in end game though, and scum!Boon might either underestimate me, or keep me around for too long just for their own entertainment..

This feels fake

[marcistar]

Youre so underwhelming i was waiting for some big massive conclusion

VOTE: jackson

[JacksonVirgo]

That sounds an awful lot like it’s not my problem. Your expectations are not what I have to live up to

[Hu Tao]

I'm actually a Informed Macho Cop-Enabler Miller and I'm informed that the Mafia know that my role exists.

Found the traitor

[The Bulge]

Since it’s going over people’s heads, and they ain’t clicking the link, I’ll explain.
I joke claimed Miller based on a recent game, with players in this game and our mod, I claimed Miller first post.

Yeh i dont like this. Firstly it doesnt look like a joke claim. Nothing obviously a joke about it. Not even a reference or a emoji or anything.
Second you didnt make it in your first post, you went back to say "oh btw miller". And not like a minute or two later but hours later. I feel like if it were a joke, you might have not botthered to go back to it if the moment was lost.
Also lastly I specifically asked what the nuance was, I was asking how is your current claim different than what you said in another game.
The answer by the looks of it should have been "this isnt a claim" but you didnt respond.

So yeh i'm not taking this as a joke claim.

Also, the logic y’all trying to push is a town misplay but it’s being shifted like a scummy thing.

It really isnt. Sure it can be town misplay but it absolutely can be scum too.

Wheres the rule that states theres only one cop? Claiming miller, and early which is the norm, can mean if there is a town cop that they dont waste their time and also can plant the seed which could keep you alive longer should there be a wagon.

You were the first to bring up the thought of their being a traitor also, so i feel if you were miller the question of "should claim miller immediatly" should have been questioned. Especailly hours prior to the claim.

All in all im getting scummy vibes from all this.

not loving the stubborn approach here, the whole is it a joke/is it not a joke lane is a weird way to go with this. could be playstyle but could be forced combativeness.

[The Bulge]

I'm already feeling good about certain slots this early.

VOTE: Gamma

to me this vote seems like sheeping trs onto the beeg wagon so that they dont have to take responsibility themselves

but like

idk i feel like gammas pretty scummy
so idk if this would be an aligned interaction or not

what do you mean by sheeping trs?

aligned between who? gamma and hu tao?

[The Bulge]

gamma can be town

[The Bulge]

I like Gamma's reaction to early votes

VOTE: Bulge

That’s a spicy take and not just for being unpopular. Why?

I just like your vibe atm. And I don't mean that I think it leans townie or scummy, more so that I think it's good that you're continuing to engage with the game in a natural way even after early pressure.

I'm voting Bulge because he kinda talked around the Miller claim to do some related role speculation instead and then dropped off. It didn't seem like a sincere attempt to interact with anyone, and I don't get the feeling he cared about what he was talking about. He said a lot but still said so little that actually meant anything.

i read the miller claim as a joke from the start. and the mech stuff was a direct response to una's question, tbh i was expecting a little more back and forth from that. but idk what you were expecting me to "care" about on page 2

i agree that gamma has been engaging naturally w the game, tho i do think that is well within her scumrange

[The Bulge]

honestly bulge and jacksonvirgo are both people who i dont even remember what they've said

i claimed mafia cop in my first post, nobody cc'd

[The Bulge]

Yeah, it’s Drew and Jackson

Wtf stop stealing my op reads these are an original one of a kind masterpiece

i remember one game where i sr'd flavor leaf and wanted to do a big case but i was lazy and falling behind and struggling to catch up and then other people started to sr him and i was upset it wasn't me who cased him even tho i was making no effort at all to do so. and then he conftowned himself to me.

[The Bulge]

in case you were wondering

[The Bulge]

here, reading soon)

Hi, are you cop again?

We are out of rvs, why this question?

hmmm

[The Bulge]

I

crumbed my role like CRAZY in that game as well.
I got to slip in some talk of Universal monster-movies or something. Talked about a TUB in some context and all..oh the times.

A

nd yet..somebody..was able to convince people to not trust me and discredited my crumbs even though I had a very clear cut and consistent

m

eta of doing it back then.

W

ouldn't do it nowadays - mainly because I've gotten a bit lazy crafting secret messages for the future. Especially since most people are not going to believe them anyway.

W

h well.

[The Bulge]

Xegarus (2) - absolutely no scumread from this to me. Obv. only 3 posts so far, so would love to see MORE, but as of now..
I know HOW you could twist this as scum posing, but I'm almost certain this is a townie playing a simple approach to the only provocative thing that had happened so far.
Flavor Leaf, Doctor Drew

i'm reading along these lines as well but where you see simple approach i see forced content.

Hu Tao (1) - Out of all the players reacting, or reacting to reactions around FL's claim and play so far, this is the one that for whatever reason felt most like scum to me. Couldn't nitpick and clarify the nuances to anyone if asked to. Just something that feels right to me.
UnaBombaH

feeling mighty similar about hu tao as well