Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Surye]

Shit Farside, I think I cannot get an item because technically I have the 1-up mushroom right now. The transaction will fail.

But I am able to buy a regular mushroom during the night (I think), so

2 coins

is all I need.

Gimbo's claim seems to have a life of it's own, it's evolving. Now you are a Toad that started with an item. That would have been the right thing to say from the start, why did you not?

Oh, I know why, because then we would pressure you to give the 1up to a much more likely town player, and lynch you, and revive you if you turn up town.

He seems to be trying to play us.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
TheSweatpantsNinja (2): sideney, iamausername
Gimbo (2): Alabaska J, somestrangeflea
armlx (2): killa seven, FaerieLord
populartajo (2): Rogue Shenanigans, farside22
Cream147 (2): armlx, Phoebus
Xtoxm (2): DragonsofSummer, alvinz95
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
Surye (1): Celebloki
Mr. Incrediball (1): Riceballtail
somestrangeflea (1): Dead Rikimaru
farside22 (1): TheSweatpantsNinja
Phoebus (1): Gimbo

Not voting (6): Xtoxm, Surye, mr. incrediball, MafiaSSK, Pepsidude, Cream147

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch.

[Gimbo]

Ok guys, I think I majorly fucked up. I think the clause that you can't have 2 items at a time just screwed me over.

Fuck, fuck, fuck, hold on, I'm gonna think this thru and pm the mod for information.

[Surye]

Oops, browser refreshed weird,

Mod: Delete this and the extra post please?

Mod: Extra post deleted.

[populartajo]

Everyone is Toad (or is someone that looks like toad, but not a toad). Someone doesn't have a toad role = scum.

Wait, where did you get this from?
........
Im missing where is the description of the 1UP mushroom. Was it a secret item?

[farside22]

@populartajo: Look in bold at lawrencelot story.

Right, still two to go, but I'll start Day 1 anyway. If Xtoxm and Alabaska J don't post soon, I'll give them a prod.

Peach wanders through the town. "

That's funny, everyone looks like a Toad, even myself. I wonder how many of them really are Toads.

." .

IE everyone looks like a Toad, but not everyone is a toad.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

@populartajo: Look in bold at lawrencelot story.

Right, still two to go, but I'll start Day 1 anyway. If Xtoxm and Alabaska J don't post soon, I'll give them a prod.

Peach wanders through the town. "

That's funny, everyone looks like a Toad, even myself. I wonder how many of them really are Toads.

." .

IE everyone looks like a Toad, but not everyone is a toad.

Not everyone who isn't a toad is scum. Every role is dressed as a toad.

Call this wild speculation... but I would expect to see mario in this game, and I seriously doubt he would be anti-town.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Surye, gimbo's claimed a confirmable role, no reason to lynch him. I agree, if he lynch town, he should revive the lynch, because then it doesn't matter if he gets killed or not.

Now, moving on:

A few people have said, "oh, pooling coins is a good idea, just not today." The differences between today and the next day are:

A. Scum will have time to talk and figure out what their coin claims will be.

B. There is going to be more scum relative to town (because of nightkills)

C. Scum, via nightkills, will hold more coins than however many they have today.

Those are all good for the scum and bad for us. Now, if you oppose pooling and using altogether, fine, but if we're going to do it, today is the best time.

[iamausername]

@populartajo: Look in bold at lawrencelot story.

Right, still two to go, but I'll start Day 1 anyway. If Xtoxm and Alabaska J don't post soon, I'll give them a prod.

Peach wanders through the town. "

That's funny, everyone looks like a Toad, even myself. I wonder how many of them really are Toads.

." .

IE everyone looks like a Toad, but not everyone is a toad.

Not everyone who isn't a toad is scum. Every role is dressed as a toad.

Call this wild speculation... but I would expect to see mario in this game, and I seriously doubt he would be anti-town.

And we know for sure that Princess Peach is in the game, and she is pretty much guaranteed to be pro-town.

[Riceballtail]

First post claims there's a Mario and Luigi role.

[Phoebus]

And we know for sure that Princess Peach is in the game, and she is pretty much guaranteed to be pro-town.

We do?
Sure she's not a mechanic?

Well done Gimbo and much better farside... *sigh*
I just hope that mushroom isn't dropped...mod seems to have gone off for the night...
There doesn't seem to be any indication of day use powers.

This is giving me a headache.
But forget it for now.

Where's cream gone off to?
Let's wagon him.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

And we know for sure that Princess Peach is in the game, and she is pretty much guaranteed to be pro-town.

We do?
Sure she's not a mechanic?

Rule 26. You can't attempt to NK a mechanic. There would be no one to fix your car.

Boom tish.

[Gimbo]

Ok everyone, LISTEN UP:

My original plan was to buy myself a mushroom and get myself thru the night unharmed and the next day, use the 1-Up mushroom to revive one of the 2 dead.

However, I forgot about the fact that the 1-UP mushroom is an item and that means I won't be able to get myself the normal (protection) mushroom until I use this one.

This is a huge error on my part and one that might kill me.
BUT... here's whats gonna happen. I will be vulnerable tonight to be killed.

All I can ask right now is that if there are any PROTECTIVE ROLES out there, i.e DOCTORS, PLEASE PLEASE please protect me tonight as I won't be able to do so myself...

I really did fuck up, but still yet, my claim was still not a bad thing because at least (assuming no protection for me) tonight every townie knows who's mostly likely getting NKed (me) and hopefully the fact that

armlx, phoebus, cream ,tsn, iamusername

all jumped on me (positively or negatively) might be able to give town some more information so that if I die, these are the ones you guys should investigate. So in a way, we can turn a major screw-up on my part into a good thing.

[iamausername]

And we know for sure that Princess Peach is in the game, and she is pretty much guaranteed to be pro-town.

We do?
Sure she's not a mechanic?

I suppose that is a possibility, but the impression I get from the following rules is that she is:

13) Mass-claiming is allowed, but not recommended for the town in this game.
25) Bowser may try to kidnap princess Peach during the night. The town has to prevent that. When Peach is kidnapped at night, the kidnapper has to be lynched the next day or else the town will lose.
26) Princess Peach cannot get killed, only kidnapped. As you may have noticed from rule 25), Peach plays an important role in this game, so if you’re town make sure you prevent her from getting kidnapped.

Rule 13 is included because I figure that outing Peach would be a pretty significant negative consequence of a massclaim.

[Surye]

Surye, gimbo's claimed a confirmable role, no reason to lynch him. I agree, if he lynch town, he should revive the lynch, because then it doesn't matter if he gets killed or not.

Now, moving on:

A few people have said, "oh, pooling coins is a good idea, just not today." The differences between today and the next day are:

A. Scum will have time to talk and figure out what their coin claims will be.

B. There is going to be more scum relative to town (because of nightkills)

C. Scum, via nightkills, will hold more coins than however many they have today.

Those are all good for the scum and bad for us. Now, if you oppose pooling and using altogether, fine, but if we're going to do it, today is the best time.

You're missing the point. It's not that black and white, if his "role" is an item, we have other methods to verify, and possibily better utilize. Can't think of this game with regular roles.

[Lawrencelot]

Give 1 mushroom to Gimbo

Transaction failed.

[Lawrencelot]

Mod:

If transactions fail because someone holds an item, is the item returned to the gifter? or dropped?

If someone wanted to give his item to someone who was already holding one, the item stays in his possession and I will say "transaction failed". The transaction can fail for other reasons too though.

[Lawrencelot]

Also, Gimbo, please keep your use of the word "fuck" to a minimum.

[Gimbo]

sry, mod, can you reply to my PM?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

You're missing the point. It's not that black and white, if his "role" is an item, we have other methods to verify, and possibily better utilize. Can't think of this game with regular roles.

Ah, well, that's true, we could have gimbo give his item away. But now that its existence is public, it should still be used tonight if possible (if we lynch town).

[Gimbo]

Hi, btw 1-Up can onyl be used during the day, that's why I was really upset I forgot about the 1-item clause

Speaking of this, who here does NOT have an item?

Because I am willing

Give away my 1-Up Mushroom

and in exchange I want your coins (so I can use it to buy myself stuff)

Mod: ignored, you need to include the name of a player

[farside22]

Hi, btw 1-Up can onyl be used during the day, that's why I was really upset I forgot about the 1-item clause

Speaking of this, who here does NOT have an item?

Because I am willing

Give away my 1-Up Mushroom

and in exchange I want your coins (so I can use it to buy myself stuff)

Do not give away an item so willy nilly. Scum will want this so just hold off on that please. Geez you are way hyper. We will hope there is a doc in this game so if you are alive you can use that at the start of D2 if we lynched a townie. Ok?

[Gimbo]

anyone who wish to use the 1-up mushroom must first survive through the night after which the person receives it. The only way this is feasible is if a doctor/pro-town protector protects that person for the night and then the holder of the 1-up mushroom can use it.

thats why i asked the pro-town doctor role in this game to protect me tonight so that I can use the 1-up mushroom the next day since technically after D1 lynch, no actions can be taken untill D2.

therefore scums wanting to kill me tonight, don't waste your time

[Alabaska J]

Argh. Wished you had thought that out before you claimed. Oh well, water under the bridge.

unvote, vote: Cream147

. If I hadn't been unavailable I would've voted before Phoebus.

So, lemme get this straight. We are lynching Cream and doing what about Gimbo?

[Gimbo]

Ok, what we can do right now is actually choose a suspicious target to lynch as my position in this game is in danger, besides there will also be (at least) 1 NK, and there's no guaranteed that if I am alive I will revive Cream since I can only revive one person.

Unvote Vote:Surye

[Surye]

I have an idea, first things first. I know how we can confirm Gimbo's claim (of having the item, not being pro-town).

We have him trade it to someone, and they trade it back. If he can do that, he proves he has the item and we can move from there. If the person on the other end refuses to give it back, we lynch him, and it would be worth a scum for the item.

Once we've done this, we'll have more information to work with.