Night Watch Open 95 - Game Over before 703

[Crazy]

In my previous game with bionic, he played like this. I firmly believe that his vote on TCS' wagon

was

for what he said it was, to gauge reactions. I don't see his vote on Iceman as OMGUS, either. So, yeah, Bionic's got a weird meta, and it's pretty close to mine when I'm actually active.

As for lurker wagons, OP isn't bad, and I wouldn't be a bad wagon either if you were going for that. The Panda Stomper Wagon is utter rubbish; anyone can see that he's off the site and needs to be replaced. I'll give a

Vote: Camn

and an

FoS: TCS

for that.

[orangepenguin]

heres my first PBPA of the game... and OP gets the honors,
1) confirm
2) defends crazy in RV
3)sarcastic random vote.
4) another sarcastic post
5) hider claim...
6) not really sure, guess ill have to go back and read in context.
7)talks about wiki, still added nothing to the game.
8)says he doesn't like TCS coment... so instead of pressuring, he makes a joke about it. i have seen this done a lot by scum.
9)ERWOP
10)uh oh... actually questions, TCS, but thats because TCS says OP is scum.
11) more game strategy.

So all in all, we are nearly ten pages in and Orangepenguin has added no useful content to the game. i even asked him what his thoughts were, and he adds a one liner about not lynching lurkers.

OP who are your top three suspects and why?

UNVOTE VOTE Orangepenguin

My one liner about lurkers wasn't even a response to your comment.

10) I only questioned him because his reasonings were stupid and random, and sounded like they were jokes. Not because he said I was scum, even though that caught my attention.

My top three suspects?
You/cammn/TCS. I don't really have a top suspect, but the four of you look kind of suspicious. cammn mainly because I disagree with his insistence to lynch lurkers, TCS because his odd reasonings (which might be omgus, but irregardless..c'mon!), and you.

[afatchic]

i didn't mean for it to sound like i thought the one liner was an attempt to answer my question. i just meant that i asked you a question, and yet instead of answering it, all you can do is add a one line comment on strategy. which shows that you are here, yet ignore my question.

other than an OMGUS what do you have against me?

[camn]

Its not an insistence.
Its a life choice.

Plus.. addition fail.

My top

three

suspects?
You/cammn/TCS. I don't really have a top suspect, but the

four

of you look kind of suspicious.

[orangepenguin]

Its not an insistence.
Its a life choice.

Plus.. addition fail.

My top

three

suspects?
You/cammn/TCS. I don't really have a top suspect, but the

four

of you look kind of suspicious.

Heh, I guess. I don't think that it's a valid argument against you, moreso that I disagree on that.

And was it a addition fail? Or did I purposely left out my real top suspect? (or more likely, penguins = bad at math )

[Jex]

Vote Count

3 - bionicchop2 (orangepenguin, icemanE, The Central Scrutinizer)
1 - The Central Scrutinizer (StrangerCoug)
1 - Crazy (Xtoxm)
1 - icemanE (bionicchop2)
1 - orangepenguin (afatchic)
1 - camn (Crazy)

Not Voting

ortolan, Haschel Cedricson, camn,

It takes 6 votes to lynch

Deadline is Nov 28th

Haschel Cedricson replaces pandastomper85

FYI I won't be a very active mod over the weekend because I have family coming to visit.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Greetings, everyone.

Before I read this game, I want bionicchop2 and ortolan to give me a summary of the game so far.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Greetings, everyone.

Before I read this game, I want bionicchop2 and ortolan to give me a summary of the game so far.

So... what's the over/under on those being his scum partners?

Welcome to the game, HC.

[bionicchop2]

Greetings, everyone.

Before I read this game, I want bionicchop2 and ortolan to give me a summary of the game so far.

I don't do homework for other students. Some people made some posts. Some people made some responses. It is your job to interpret them. If you want my full summary of the game.

Just kidding. I have written a synopsis of my thoughts here. Enjoy.

[bionicchop2]

Greetings, everyone.

Before I read this game, I want bionicchop2 and ortolan to give me a summary of the game so far.

So... what's the over/under on those being his scum partners?

Welcome to the game, HC.

I'll accept whatever offer you are putting on the table.

[Xtoxm]

Greetings, everyone.

Before I read this game, I want bionicchop2 and ortolan to give me a summary of the game so far.

So... what's the over/under on those being his scum partners?

Welcome to the game, HC.

Shall we lynch him to see?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

You should all be well aware at this point that I'm totally for lynching HC or bionic.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Ortolan, maybe less so; he just got lumped into post 232 because HC singled him out in addition to bionic... which honestly, if HC is scum, probably makes him town.

But let's not overtalk this.

[Xtoxm]

Oh, your comment was serious?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Well, not entirely. If we lynch HC, I think we have a better than 3/11 chance of lynching scum... so the cute little thought experiment I'm having is, if HC

is

scum, why does he choose those two people?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

And does that clear them, or make it a 50/50 shot...? Is he trying to get us to clear them? Is he looking for a signal?

[Xtoxm]

For all we know he rolled a die. I don't think there's anything to take form it, I think it's random.

I can see PS scum, but Bio looks good to me.

[bionicchop2]

OP

- you seem to be the only person with your random vote still hanging around. Please update us on your current top suspect.

[afatchic]

OP

- you seem to be the only person with your random vote still hanging around. Please update us on your current top suspect.

Goodluck with that, i asked as welll and got very little.

[icemanE]

I'm still fine with bio.

[bionicchop2]

I'm still fine with bio.

Nice fluff post.

[afatchic]

I'm still fine with bio.

care to explain why? we have like 4 pages of actual info, i know you haven't already found the lynch for today.

[icemanE]

I've read what's been posted since my last post, and nothing there has convinced me I should unvote bio.

[Haschel Cedricson]

I don't do homework for other students. Some people made some posts. Some people made some responses. It is your job to interpret them. If you want my full summary of the game.

Just kidding. I have written a synopsis of my thoughts here. Enjoy.

I just want the main bullet points.

Well, not entirely. If we lynch HC, I think we have a better than 3/11 chance of lynching scum... so the cute little thought experiment I'm having is, if HC is scum, why does he choose those two people?

I'll gladly share my reasons for asking those specific players. After, of course, ortolan gives a summary.

I'm not asking much. Just three or four sentences listing the most important events of the day.

[bionicchop2]

I don't do homework for other students. Some people made some posts. Some people made some responses. It is your job to interpret them. If you want my full summary of the game.

Just kidding. I have written a synopsis of my thoughts here. Enjoy.

I just want the main bullet points.

Then you can read and make your own. I am not your puppet. 10 pages is about 30 minutes of your time.

If you have any direct questions, I will answer them, but I will not summarize the game for you. I expect all players to read the game in its entirety.