In post 1078, Menalque wrote:I can get behind a pink lynch but I think it makes more sense to do gamma first
I think if gamma!scum it's v likely that pink!scum
I think if pink!scum it's harder to draw conclusions about gamma!scum
why do you prefer pink?
In post 2172, Menalque wrote:Why the hell are we talking about lynching RP when gamma is still alive?
There’s my whole case which a whole bunch of us were on board with
There’s the fact that PB got nightkilled
There’s the fact that a red flip on gamma strongly implies scum!creature, a slot that I am genuinely baffled by how it can be so full of nothing and yet townread
Like does creature normally do this much absolute fuck all as town?
And gamma also helps us sort RP. I still think that gamma red basically clears RP bc he was pushing hard there so early on
I was getting ready to refute the vote tally thing but...hunh. I guess I haven’t voted before now.
It’s kind of immaterial, as I’ve been pushing Chemist since at least D2. I was also prepared to vote DP and RP at various points, but did not for good reasons.
The problem is that I’ve been behind and outdated for a while. As for having never seen someone post outdated reads...get out more. It’s unusual, but hardly original.
Do you think this development implicates Pine if Creature flips scum?
Fyi this doesn't mean I'm quite ready to attempt to solve the game yet, that's going to be tomorrow
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
I’m missing a few pages in the 50s but am effectively caught up. It was my intention (after the night I fell asleep at my desk) to finish those pages and post the complete thing, but it didn’t happen, so I dumped the now-outdated work in progress into the thread.
Thought process and insight are always valuable, even if outdated. I’m not sure what bug is up your ass about this, or if you’re just being obstreperous.
But I don’t think chem!town is v useful going into lylo
So I’d rather vote gamma who has I think better odds of being scum (or I think even if you’re not as sold as me the you have to say similar) but whose flip has much more informational quality
I think I agree with this. If gamma flips town we can always push on chemist tomorrow
In post 1078, Menalque wrote:I can get behind a pink lynch but I think it makes more sense to do gamma first
I think if gamma!scum it's v likely that pink!scum
I think if pink!scum it's harder to draw conclusions about gamma!scum
why do you prefer pink?
In post 2172, Menalque wrote:Why the hell are we talking about lynching RP when gamma is still alive?
There’s my whole case which a whole bunch of us were on board with
There’s the fact that PB got nightkilled
There’s the fact that a red flip on gamma strongly implies scum!creature, a slot that I am genuinely baffled by how it can be so full of nothing and yet townread
Like does creature normally do this much absolute fuck all as town?
And gamma also helps us sort RP. I still think that gamma red basically clears RP bc he was pushing hard there so early on
What happened here @Menal
Don’t misrep, this is from before the huge gamma/pink blowout
