Mini 722: Neapolitan Mafia (Over)

[Rogue Shenanigans]

don_johnson

.

Obvious mafia is obvious.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

EBWOP

Vote:don_johnson

I could have sworn I typed "vote".

[don_johnson]

is it the hair? my girlfriend says its the hair...

[Percy]

Vote: don_johnson

It's the hair

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Vote Count

With 12 alive, it's 7 to lynch!

Beyond_Birthday - 1 (magnus_orion)
Isacc - 1 (don_johnson)
magnus_orion - 1 (Zachrulez)
Lindisfarne - 1 (PsychoSniper)
don_johnson - 2 (Rogue Shenanigans, Percy)

Not Voting

Isacc, Beyond_Birthday, Nikelaos, Lindisfarne, McNuke, & tyhess

EDIT: Edited Percy in. Also, I will have a QT with a vote count history set up later today.

[Isacc]

Vote: McNuke

because Nukes go BOOM!

[Lindisfarne]

vote: PsychoSniper

OMGUS random-yet-not vote.

Vote me for a bag over my head? You sir are carrying a gun in your avatar. Scum carry guns. Far more scummy than a mere bag

[McNuke]

Vote: Percy

For not having any hair.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

vote: PsychoSniper

You sir are carrying a gun in your avatar. Scum carry guns.)

Slander my good sir! Lies and slander!

[magnus_orion]

consider it noted that mcnuke and zachrulez confirmed within a minute of each other.

What would that have to do with anything?

open talk prior to cofirming finishing. I am assuming scum can talk during the night, but I feel this is a safe assumption. Since they couldn't know when everyone would finish confirming, it is likely they would discuss plans prior to confirming. When they were done talking they would go to the thread and confirm. Since they finish talking at the same time, they end up confirming at the same time.

Its a possibility, but its also a possibility that its a total coincidence, which is why it didn't earn even an fos. Hence "consider it noted"

[tyhess]

Your reaching a little bit there. For one, there's a good chance that they wouldn't be on at the same time to pm each other. 2nd, one person even if by some chance that they were on at the same time, would end the conversation before the other, and thus confirm first. C, I'm guessing there's more than 2 scum in a game with 12 people.

I know you said it doesn't deserve even an FOS, but your fishing......

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Lul... This is the point where I come in and tell tyhess that he is fishing a bit himself... but lets not go into that. Neither argument holds water to the point where even those making them dont sound as if they are strong enough to warrent even a FOS.

[magnus_orion]

Your reaching a little bit there. For one, there's a good chance that they wouldn't be on at the same time to pm each other. 2nd, one person even if by some chance that they were on at the same time, would end the conversation before the other, and thus confirm first. C, I'm guessing there's more than 2 scum in a game with 12 people.

I know you said it doesn't deserve even an FOS, but your fishing......

Excuse me?
fishing? as in role fishing?
I am fishing, but I'm fishing mafia-alligned fish.
Care to explain how what I'm doing could be fishing for other alligned fish?

And your sounding a tad over-defensive of these two players, considering I haven't even attacked them.

and yes, one of the group would be before the other two, but the other two could end up confirming at around the same time. So B is negated because of C.

[tyhess]

Lul... This is the point where I come in and tell tyhess that he is fishing a bit himself... but lets not go into that. Neither argument holds water to the point where even those making them dont sound as if they are strong enough to warrent even a FOS.

ug. I'm done. Your right.

[magnus_orion]

Care to explain how what I'm doing could be fishing for other alligned fish?

Am I to understand you don't have a response to this question?

[tyhess]

Care to explain how what I'm doing could be fishing for other alligned fish?

Am I to understand you don't have a response to this question?

You may have been "fishing for scum" but it is such a reach that there's basically no way in Hell it could be right.

[don_johnson]

i think mag was just making a note here. considering the inherent untruths which fill these threads it would be foolish to not pay attention to actual facts.

*fixes hair*

[magnus_orion]

"no way in hell", huh? You have information I don't?
Reaches can be true... I wouldn't support assuming that they are true, but I also don't support saying reaches are always false.

[Isacc]

I have to agree that their "simultaneous confirms" say absolutely nothing about them. It's a moot point.

[tyhess]

"no way in hell", huh? You have information I don't?
Reaches can be true... I wouldn't support assuming that they are true, but I also don't support saying reaches are always false.

Now your spinning my quotes. "no way in hell" is a lot different from the quote that I did say, which was "You may have been "fishing for scum" but it is such a reach

that there's basically no way in Hell

it could be right.".

All I'm saying is that there is nothing to be gained from two people confirming one minute apart.

[don_johnson]

All I'm saying is that there is nothing to be gained from two people confirming one minute apart.

not yet, at least.

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Lets not fight like dogs over such a small snippit of meat. While there may be something in it... we would need far more evidence to even think of using it seriously. We wont get any such evidence if we stare at this point for seven months.

[magnus_orion]

"no way in hell", huh? You have information I don't?
Reaches can be true... I wouldn't support assuming that they are true, but I also don't support saying reaches are always false.

Now your spinning my quotes. "no way in hell" is a lot different from the quote that I did say, which was "You may have been "fishing for scum" but it is such a reach

that there's basically no way in Hell

it could be right.".

All I'm saying is that there is nothing to be gained from two people confirming one minute apart.

While I fail to see how I was spinning your quote, I think that you are taking an agreeable stance on the matter.
Which, once again, is why I said "consider it noted".
Now I'm finished with this issue as well.
I was simply bothered by how much you had reacted.

[tyhess]

Lets not fight like dogs over such a small snippit of meat. While there may be something in it... we would need far more evidence to even think of using it seriously. We wont get any such evidence if we stare at this point for seven months.

QFT

[Rogue Shenanigans]

Of course now that I look back I have just spent my last couple posts basicly telling your guys to STFU.

Not my intention... free flow of discussion and ideas is paramount to us catching scum.