Discworld Mafia - Called

[malpascp]

Vote: PeregrineV

for making double posts

[Cherry Nog]

Vote: PeregrineV

for making double posts

what does that make drmyshotgun's triple post?

[BloodCovenent]

double standards.

unvote:
Vote: malpascp

[SlySly]

Time for some questions.
1) Is there anybody in this game that you trust implicitly coming into it?
2) What is your favorite animal?
3) If you were given the choice between vig or cop, which would you choose?
4) How do you feel about these questions?
5) Describe your emotional state right now.
6) There were Three Stooges. Name the capital of Latvia.

1. SlySly
2. The serpent Oroborous
3. Vig
4. Not good
5. Meh
6. Deez Nuts

[Calcifer]

VOTE: Mitillos.

[Calcifer]

Mitillos, PeregrineV, and Kimor is the scumteam.
Game over.

[Calcifer]

Wait, my mistake. Misread Mitillos's initial post.

Cherry Nog

, PeregrineV, and Kimor is the scumteam.

UNVOTE: Mitillos, VOTE: PeregrineV.

[Xisiqomelir]

Wait, my mistake. Misread Mitillos's initial post.

Cherry Nog

, PeregrineV, and Kimor is the scumteam.

UNVOTE: Mitillos, VOTE: PeregrineV.

How do you deduce Cherry Nog to be scum?

Similarly, while Kimor's questions are of dubious utility at best, why is he scum, and why is he scum with Peregrine, who has openly regarded them with disdain?

[PeregrineV]

Vote: PeregrineV

for making double posts

So, this implies you have read my posts.

In which I answer the 6 questions, and call Kimor scum for asking them.

You have ignored the 6 questions, and not even given an opinion on them, even after you've seen them asked, and answered by me and others.

Why would I be wrong in thinking you are scum with Kimor?

[PeregrineV]

Wait, my mistake. Misread Mitillos's initial post.

Cherry Nog

, PeregrineV, and Kimor is the scumteam.

UNVOTE: Mitillos, VOTE: PeregrineV.

So, once again, implying you have read the game.

I see nothing that we all have in common, except the questions. Kimor asked them, Cherry and I answered them.

And, I'm voting Kimor for them.

But, you do not mention that I am bussing him. You don't say it, but want others to "fill in" that connection on their own. You didn't come out and say it because you know it does not exist.

But the fact you are trying to create it without being accountable for actually saying it means your probably scum.

Man, I wish all my games were this easy.

[PeregrineV]

@Shotgun & Xisi- Welcome to townville!

[qwints]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: PeregrineV

For being the only one to choose cop. Obviously he doesn't want to appear dangerous. Also for declaring two people as town so early.

[Mitillos]

@Thor: Still waiting for an asnwer to my question from post 14.

@SlySly: No vote? Not even a random one? Why not?

@Calcifer: It's always refreshing to see someone who believes they figured everything out by page 2, without giving any justification whatsoever. How about some actual arguments?

@PeregrineV: What qwints said. Why are drm and xisi obv-town?

[PeregrineV]

@PeregrineV: What qwints said. Why are drm and xisi obv-town?

21 and 32

[PeregrineV]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: PeregrineV

For being the only one to choose cop. Obviously he doesn't want to appear dangerous. Also for declaring two people as town so early.

Interesting.

Militos didn't have a favorite. What does that mean?

And how does having a role preference affect my appearance of dangerousness at all?

See, I can't tell if you are staying in RVS with your first 2 sentences, yet contradicting yourself with a legitimate reason to vote in your last sentence.

Seems like you are trying to see what sticks.

[Thor665]

@Thor: Still waiting for an asnwer to my question from post 14.

You are, aren't you?
You remain a town read - when someone makes a case on you maybe I'll bother to explain it, but I wasn't aware I needed to convince you that you were town.

@SlySly: No vote? Not even a random one? Why not?

More importantly no reaction to the serious votes on him.
It's because he's scum.

[Calcifer]

If my reversal on Mitillos wasn't a tipoff, I was skimming.
UNVOTE: PeregrineV, VOTE: qwintz.

Mitillos, Thor, PeregrineV, xisi, and mal are all town. Scumlist unchanged otherwise. Rest currently null.

[qwints]

And how does having a role preference affect my appearance of dangerousness at all?

See, I can't tell if you are staying in RVS with your first 2 sentences, yet contradicting yourself with a legitimate reason to vote in your last sentence.

I'm giving two legitimate reasons to vote you. You chose the option that cannot kill, because you don't want people to associate you with killing because you are scum. You named two players as town in order to make them more favorably disposed to you - which is scummy. Naming town reads and saying why early on is also extremely anti-town.

[Thor665]

Naming town reads and saying why early on is also extremely anti-town.

I'm game for lynching this guy now too.

[Mitillos]

@Thor: You don't need to convince me I'm town, I already know that. You need to convince me that you are. Well, not actually need, but if you are, it would be better.

@Peregrine: I take your point about post 32, but I can't see how 21 makes drm obv-town. He is asking for people to wagon his random vote. I'd consider this a null-tell, right now.

@qwints: How is it anti-town? It's not like he's forcing anyone to share his opinion, he's presenting an argument on why X is likely scum or Y is likely town. The one thing town lacks compared to the mafia is information. Sharing information is the most pro-town thing town can do.

[PeregrineV]

And how does having a role preference affect my appearance of dangerousness at all?

See, I can't tell if you are staying in RVS with your first 2 sentences, yet contradicting yourself with a legitimate reason to vote in your last sentence.

I'm giving two legitimate reasons to vote you. You chose the option that cannot kill, because you don't want people to associate you with killing because you are scum. You named two players as town in order to make them more favorably disposed to you - which is scummy. Naming town reads and saying why early on is also extremely anti-town.

Interesting how other people's minds work, yet, we think others think the same way.

I like cop because if I investigate town, they are not dead the next morning, and I have not brought the game one step closer to lylo.
If I investigate scum, they can die the next day.

But you can ignore my actual reasoning since you didn't bother asking me or any of the other players "Why?" they choose as they did, or ask Kimor why he chose those roles to ask the questions about.

And you also forgot this:

Militos didn't have a favorite. What does that mean?

[Cherry Nog]

And how does having a role preference affect my appearance of dangerousness at all?

See, I can't tell if you are staying in RVS with your first 2 sentences, yet contradicting yourself with a legitimate reason to vote in your last sentence.

I'm giving two legitimate reasons to vote you. You chose the option that cannot kill, because you don't want people to associate you with killing because you are scum. You named two players as town in order to make them more favorably disposed to you - which is scummy. Naming town reads and saying why early on is also extremely anti-town.

How long have you been away from the site for?

[Cherry Nog]

@Thor, how were you out of RVS when you were voting someone that hadn't posted yet at that stage?

[qwints]

[quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 1#p4383731]
@qwints: How is it anti-town? It's not like he's forcing anyone to share his opinion, he's presenting an argument on why X is likely scum or Y is likely town. The one thing town lacks compared to the mafia is information. Sharing information is the most pro-town thing town can do.[/quote]

Explaining what "townie" behavior is before a baseline has been established is dangerous. Information is good, coaching scum is bad. Saying "x is town" early is scummy, explaining why hurts the town.

*Ninja edit*
@Cherry Nog - Since September 10, 2009. Started playing again two days ago. My wiki has the past games I was in.

[qwints]

Fixing formatting:

@qwints: How is it anti-town? It's not like he's forcing anyone to share his opinion, he's presenting an argument on why X is likely scum or Y is likely town. The one thing town lacks compared to the mafia is information. Sharing information is the most pro-town thing town can do.

Explaining what "townie" behavior is before a baseline has been established is dangerous. Information is good, coaching scum is bad. Saying "x is town" early is scummy, explaining why hurts the town.

How long have you been away from the site for?

Three years. Last post was September 10, 2009. Started playing again two days ago. My wiki has the past games I was in.