Mafia 2

[OcularGold]

unvote: sk, vote: porro

its unlikely mith is doing a lepton gambit - theres no reason to come out like this if he were. it's not las if he was about to be lynched..

[quercitron]

Vote: Porro

[Sketchwick]

vote porro

Looking back at the player list I see we have lost no docs, so it's not a bad idea for a cop to come out when they got 2 guilty results and one is confirmed. Plus I am fond of voting for the same person as a mason.

sketchwick

[Internet Stranger]

Unvote: Whoever
Vote: Porro

weeeee! bandwagon![/b]

[Porro]

Oh bloomin' charming.

Mith comes out with some dubious nonsence about me being mafia (he thinks but erm he's not really sure so he won't actually vote for me himself, etc. blagh blagh).

And what happens. Do people critically check his story? Scrutinise it with logic, look back at posting history to see if his (vague) story looks likely.

NO

we have a good old-fashioned crap logic (TM) bandwaggon.

Vote:mith

for trying to get me killed, whilst still trying to maintain the "well I'm not quite sure what sort of cop I am" defence, so he can try and weadle his way out of starting a bandwaggon for an innogent.

Bah.

Don't all rush to lynch me, check back over the thread, see if I (or mith) have acted suspiciously, or acted in the interests of the town. If you can't be bothered to do that, then at least give me time to look back and check. What have you got to lose by giving me time to do that? Alternatively if you want to rush to kill a townie then :0P

[Porro]

Ok, here's something for you bandwaggoners to think about (and it didn't take very long to check the thread either:

So far 3 people have been lynched, i.e.

The Master - Fibonacci
Pika - Townie
JDTay - Avagadro

I voted for all 3 (post 85,p4...post 135,p6...and post 209p9)

mith voted for the first 2 (post 86,p4...post 123,p5), but was on the alternative sketchwick bandwaggon rather than JDTay's.

I think the fact that I've voted for two different mafia families is reasonable evidence to substantiate my innocence. So is mith an erroneous cop, or a member of the Avagadros?

[mith]

Blah, I hate this position.

On one hand, if I'm paranoid, I risk getting an innocent lynched, as well as myself.

On the other hand, it would be a really weak role, so I am inclined to think I am sane.

Sorry in advance if I am wrong, Porro, but I'll have to go with the odds.

And if I am wrong, there will be no Lepton Gambit. Lynch me. My role isn't of much use if I'm paranoid.

Vote: Porro

[mith]

I was on the sketchwagon 'cause I started it (after he voted for you, I believe). I still suspect him, but I decided to check you last night on a hunch.

Anyway, if I were really a member of the Avagadros with JD, I wouldn't get near him; he's too likely to get killed.

Still might be erroneous, but like I said, it seems less likely right now, having gotten one correct result.

[mith]

(Posting this in all active games, nothing to do with my role)

Please send future emails to mithrandir@spl.at

c4 is down, blah.

[Internet Stranger]

Now that I think about it, I thought this was a straight up mafia game. Why would Mith be some sort of half cop?

Unvote: Porro
Vote: Mith

I wanna hear more from Mith.

[Polotet]

Just because it's normal doesn't mean all roles have to completely standard. I believe mith.

Vote: Porro

[Porro]

Oh this bandwaggon is even lamer than I thought!

mith said

2nd night I got JD as Mafia, and last night I got Porro as Mafia; however, I have no idea what my sanity was, and even with JD turning out Mafia

Well, hello!

If he got JD as mafia, how come he didn't even FOS him, never mind vote to lynch him.

~slaps bandwaggon members repeatedly~

Wake up and smell the cow droppings!

You people have played mafia before haven't you?

[Porro]

Looking back at the player list I see we have lost no docs, so it's not a bad idea for a cop to come out

I just read that again and thought 'that's a bit of a mafia tactic', i.e. encourage the docs to protect a known subject (mith) so the mafia are free to bump off anyone else thay fancy, totally unhindered.

Furthermore, IMO it's not often a good idea for a cop to come out early in a game. Partly for the risk of tying up the docs.

Whatever mith is, if I was a doc I wouldn't protect him tonight, but then I've bothered to actually consider what he said, and weigh the evidence rather than jumping on a bandwaggon because I was mafia, or a bored townie or didn't like to think for myself or some other feeble reason, so I expect all the dopes that have a doc roll will protect mith forevermore until the rest of the town, including them, are slaughtered by the laughing mafia.

Due to the above quote

unvote: poor misguided mith
vote: sketchwick dirty mafia scum

[Porro]

IS, help me out here. I want advice on how to be even nastier to these irritating fools

[Internet Stranger]

Thinking that Sketchwick is mafia because he said something stupid is not exactly the best way to proclaim innocence. He does it every game.

Damn, you were doing so well too. Oh well.

Unvote: Mith
Vote: Porro

[Porro]

Oh come on IS.

Is sketchwick really that dumb??? If he is, I wasn't to know!!!

There's nothing but the word of a mafia traitor to lynch me on, and you've all fell for it! You lot really are thick, thicky, thicky thickpots :OP

'ahem' woops 'gulp'.

Watch your back IS, you'll be next

Bye all

[mikegoo]

Alright...Porro has a point...mith says he investigated JD found him guilty and then ignored the JD bandwagon.

On the other hand the JD bandwagon needed no help to get the lynching done.

Mith's role would be really dumb if he got bad results which I think he was/is smart engouh to realize which is probably why he came out now.

The only problem is I'm not so sure I trust mith's honesty here...the role seems a bit off.

Ok now i have to go with cost analysis... one possible innocent vs. confirming a useful role ... either way we get a mafia ...easy enough then

vote: porro

[mikegoo]

oooops forgot to

unvote: sk

then

vote: porro

[Luna]

so I expect all the dopes that have a doc roll will protect mith forevermore until the rest of the town, including them, are slaughtered by the laughing mafia.

Funny you would say that, they would have no reason to protect me unless you actually are Mafia.

[Porro]

unless you actually are Mafia

I'm astonished. Was my last post too subtle or something?

[Internet Stranger]

'ahem' woops 'gulp'.

Watch your back IS, you'll be next

Bye all

This kinda sealed it for me.

[Porro]

There's nothing but the word of a mafia traitor to lynch me on

In case you thicky thickpots didn't realise, that was me letting the world know that mith is a mafia traitor.

Yes mith, you know, that other player in this game. I know it's confusing for some of you because he sometimes calls himself luna (I think it's that cross-dressing thing he's got going on).

Sorry if some of the words in my posts are more than one syllable long, I'm not deliberately trying to make life hard for you thickies, I just find it hard to drop to your level

[Porro]

This kinda sealed it for me.

My fate had already been sealed by that point.

Unfortunately, I appear to be the only one who realised it. In hindsight, perhaps I should have tried to get some unvotes before the mod swooped, but silly me was too honest, thinking I was already as good as dead.

Love you all really

Ta ta from thicky

[Porro]

Just in case there's any children watching

cross-dressing

That's when someone get's dressed when they're in a bad temper, so don't concentrate on what they're doing, and put their clothes on inside out.

[groza528]

"I denounce you!" shouted mith, to Porro. "Before this very crowd I dare say that according to the previous night's deductions, there is a chance that you are somewhat likely to be Mafia scum! Die, scum!"
Porro fought valiantly, but alas, in the end it was for nought. For the town did listen to luna who claimed to be mith, and strang up poor, innocent Porro. Innocent? No, for Porro was indeed a Mafioso.

Porro Avogadro lynched. Please send night 5 choices if applicable.