NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[HighShroomish]

Yeah I'm going to hammer. I was just reading though Rainbow last post. I'll also let HS expand on his question about the PJ wagon if it was going anywhere, if not I'll drop my vote.

Since nobody is opting to answer except for two people, I can't really do much with it...

[Sotty7]

What was the point of the question? I'm curious.

[kabooooom]

Try to look he was doing something I guess..

[HighShroomish]

What was the point of the question? I'm curious.

To compare to who people vote tomorrow if PJ does turn up town.

[Sotty7]

Vote: PJ

[petroleumjelly]

Well good, guess I don't have to bother with this game any more. Good luck.

Still think No Lynching was correct. People pushing for a hammer when No Lynching is

completely

acceptable reflects poorly on those pushing for the hammer vote.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 5.9

petroleumjelly (6) - Thor665, inHimshallibe, HighShroomish, Aegor, kabooooom, Sotty7

Rainbowdash (2) - Thesp, emeraldemon
Thesp (1) - Rainbowdash

Not voting (1) - petroleumjelly

With ten players alive, it takes six votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Five is Monday, 14th April 20.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-14 19:00:00)).

[Huntress]

petroleumjelly (Vanilla townie) has been lynched.

It is now Night Five.

Deadline for Night Five is Wednesday, 16th April 23.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-16 22:00:00)).

[Huntress]

And the body count keeps rising ...

inHimshallibe (Vanilla townie) has been killed.

It is now Day Six.

With eight players alive, it takes five votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Six is Wednesday, 30th April 23.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-30 22:00:00)).

[emeraldemon]

Might as well pick up where we left off.

VOTE: Rainbowdash

[Thesp]

Yyyup.

VOTE: RainbowDash

[kabooooom]

I think thesp would be scum.

but anyways..

vote:rainbowgul

[kabooooom]

Lol! speak of the devil...

[HighShroomish]

VOTE: SCOTTY

until I'm done with my huge ass analysises(?)

[Sotty7]

Vote: Thesp

I still can't get over bulb linking emo to the Garmr slot. I mean, why do that to two townies? I need to take another look back but I do remember feeling Garmr was very town during portions of the game but I can't shake this behavior.

emeraldemon can you hot link me your Rainbow case again?

Thesp, why Rainbow and not Kab?

[Rainbowdash]

Vote Thesp

Everything from before, plus the NK. The only one in the obv town group who has Thesp as scum dies. Surprise.

[Sotty7]

Unvote

Clearly I was too hasty with this. Reading bulb/ABR ISO I feel like I am completely off track. It's looking more like he is linking two players to link them rather than looking to bus.

If you weren't voting emogirl, who would you be voting?

Either Garmr or ABR.

I'm not feeling bulb throwing his whole team under the bus with posts like these.

Maestro (replaced by Rainbow) puts pressure on bulb right when he moves his vote to emo that felt very genuine to me. This was part of the reason I had a town read on this slot. Rainbow voters or pushers what do you think of Maestro's posts in this slot?

I'm trying to cram in as much reading as I can tonight as I know I have busy days upcoming.

[emeraldemon]

Sotty,

Rainbowdash, I can find plenty of instances of you defending ABR or directing away from his wagon (1788, 1803, 1808, 1843). And yet as I read your case against Thor (2114,2151) it seems largely about Thor not pushing ABR or directing away from his wagon. What's up?

This is all I've written so far. Honestly a lot of it is about PoE, I have townreads on you and Thesp, and I'm leaning town on HighShroomish, Thor, and Aegor. That leaves RBD and Kaboom.

I am still semi-paranoid about Thor (inHim did say "It's down to PJ and Thor for me" late yesterday -- 2585) and Aegor, so my main goals for today are to sort them, Kaboom and RBD as best I can. I'm happy to start with RBD.

[emeraldemon]

Lets hope she is scum.

This could just be kaboom being kaboom, but I don't like it on a gut level. Feels like scum.

[emeraldemon]

Maestro (replaced by Rainbow) puts pressure on bulb right when he moves his vote to emo that felt very genuine to me. This was part of the reason I had a town read on this slot. Rainbow voters or pushers what do you think of Maestro's posts in this slot?

It is true that Maestro questions Bulba's logic, but he ultimately sides with bulba and helps him wagon emogirl: 156, 221. Not sure if there's anything to 238. Some of it seems sorta town, nothing strong though.

[Sotty7]

This is all I've written so far. Honestly a lot of it is about PoE, I have townreads on you and Thesp, and I'm leaning town on HighShroomish, Thor, and Aegor. That leaves RBD and Kaboom.

Fair enough. Can you review Maestro's posts and tell me what you think? I'd also like a little detail on your HS leaning town read. A lot of people have been calling him town and I'm not sure why. I mostly ask because I just read this:

Bulbazak's Hierarchy of Reads (D3)

Town

Zdenek
Thor665
Chevre
Emeraldemon

Null

Albert B. Rampage
Rainbowdash
InHimshallibe
HighShroomish

Null/Scum

Kabooooom
Matias
Sotty7

Scum

Nero Cain
Aegor
Garmr

@Rainbowdash
The last two times we lynchee some one who was lurking, we got town. kabooooom is playing anti-town, yes, but not scummy, and I'm not about to lynch another lurker just to have them flip town. Our numbers are dwindling. We have 16 slots left in game, and 14 that are usable. Tomorrow, it's more than likely we'll be at 14. And if we still haven't caught any scum and we mislynch tomorrow, if there are six, which seems highly likely for a big game, the games over.

To people saying not to lynch the ABR slot- if I think it's scummy I'm gonna try to. And I do.

VOTE: ABR-SLOT

Says we should not lynch a lurker. Votes a lurker slot that is being replaced.

Unvote

Vote HighShroomish

Pages 62 and 66 respectively. Bulb doesn't address HS in between the list and the vote. HS in this time period votes for bulb and then ABR.

[Sotty7]

Maestro (replaced by Rainbow) puts pressure on bulb right when he moves his vote to emo that felt very genuine to me. This was part of the reason I had a town read on this slot. Rainbow voters or pushers what do you think of Maestro's posts in this slot?

It is true that Maestro questions Bulba's logic, but he ultimately sides with bulba and helps him wagon emogirl: 156, 221. Not sure if there's anything to 238. Some of it seems sorta town, nothing strong though.

You're right in that his emo vote was pretty crap. I'm pretty sure I disliked nearly every emo vote though.

[Sotty7]

Day one

Vote Count 1.19

Slandaar (10) -

Chevre

, OhGodMyLife, Aegor, Brian Skies,

Bulbazak

,

Zdenek, Matias, yessiree

,

Albert B. Rampage

,

Slandaar

Brian Skies (4) - Garmr, Sotty7, emeraldemon,

emogirl123

Chevre (2) - Zekrom25,

The Fonz

emeraldemon (1) -

inHimshallibe

emogirl123 (1) - kabooooom

Not voting (1) -

Nobody Special

Day two

Vote Count 2.14

Nobody Special (9) -

The Fonz

, emeraldemon,

Albert B. Rampage

, Aegor,

Bulbazak,

HighShroomish,

Matias, Chevre, inHimshallibe

Albert B. Rampage (3) -

Nobody Special

, Sotty7,

Zdenek

Aegor (1) - Thor665
Nero Cain (1) - Rainbowdash
HighShroomish (1) -

Nero Cain

Garmr (1) - Garmr

Not voting (1) - kabooooom

Day three

Vote Count 3.8

Albert B. Rampage (8) - Sotty7,

inHimshallibe

, HighShroomish,

Zdenek

, kabooooom, emeraldemon, Aegor, Thor665
kabooooom (3) -

Albert B. Rampage

, Rainbowdash,

Chevre

Aegor (1) -

Bulbazak

Bulbazak (1) -

Nero Cain

Not voting (2) - DisCode,

Matias

Day four

Vote Count 4.14

Bulbazak (7) -

inHimshallibe

, Sotty7,

emogirl123

, Aegor, emeraldemon, kabooooom, Thesp
Rainbowdash (2) - Thor665,

petroleumjelly

Aegor (2) -

Bulbazak

, HighShroomish
Thor665 (1) - Rainbowdash

Not voting (0)

Day five

Vote Count 5.9

petroleumjelly (6) - Thor665,

inHimshallibe

, HighShroomish, Aegor, kabooooom, Sotty7
Rainbowdash (2) - Thesp, emeraldemon
Thesp (1) - Rainbowdash

Not voting (1) -

petroleumjelly

I'm putting these here for right now. I'm not seeing anything major, but maybe they will help someone else. I was waiting for inhim to do this but it just never came about.

[HighShroomish]

It kinda irks me that while RBS's slot was in the first lynch he wasn't on any of the rest.

[Sotty7]

Rainbow's slot is voting for Cheve on the first lynch, so actually she isn't on any lynch.