Unless something while I'm catching up makes me more suspicious, I think I like this alternative:
Vote: pman5595
After seeing Kitten's large post, I'm starting to get a strong town read on her. I'm glad she took the time to explain her thinking, because, while I don't agree with it, it makes sense.
Oman wrote:I am so unhappy with every person that unvoted Kitten. I am so disappointed in everyone that doesn't have the guts to stay at L-1.
People like you are the reason mafia is becoming a stagnant festival of repeated words.
Okay..?
Ythill wrote:I'm sorry, I'm really not sure what you're asking. I said that scum was more likley to skim over night-talk rules than town, because scum commonly have a more detailed ruleset for the night phase. So when asked about the night phase, a good scum player will go back and check the rules to see what a townie should know. Understand?
Yes. Now I do. Sorry.
Oman wrote:That is, when she is attacked, she doesn't defend herself so much as attack her attacker. It's this sense of "calling me scummy is a scumtell".
Examples?
Okay, I don't have time to finish catching up, but I should have more time in the next few days. Anyway, I currently dislike all of the three biggest bandwagons. (Leaf, Kitten, and Ellibereth)
Leaf - Several of the things he's getting attacked for are things that I've gotten attacked for in the past when I was town. Most of the other points aren't convincing either. When I was more inexperienced, I used to ask lots of question during the RVS similar to Leaf's so him doing the same thing doesn't bother me at all. After thinking it through, the only point I actually think may have merit is the one regarding the night talk rules now that I get it.
Kitten - I really liked the first part of her wall post. The bandwagon on her is also too large for my liking.
Ellibereth - Despite him not contributing much, I actually have a strong town read on him. I dislike the size of his bandwagon also because I don't understand any of the reasons for it. His non-contribution is something I've seen town do more often than scum. We also seem to have similar ideas on certain topics.
pman looks like the best lynch to me.
"You miss 100% of the shots you don't take. -Wayne Gretzky"
-Wickedestjr