The Scummies, 2011... Live! (ish)

[Parama]

I won 2...

in my heart

[Mr. Flay]

Funnily enough, if you HAD won two, you'd have kept Mafia Scum as your title.

Try harder next year.

[SleepyKrew]

Thanks for answering my question Flay (even though I'd asked it in a roundabout way and you weren't even talking to me)

[Parama]

Funnily enough, if you HAD won two, you'd have kept Mafia Scum as your title.

Try harder next year.

>Professor Paragon
>Mafia Scum

[zoraster]

Anyone who actually judged Best Mechanic willing to PM me? I'm looking for closure, so you know this will be fun.

[SleepyKrew]

Parama, if you're talking about Vi, Professor Paragon is her actual title.

[SleepyKrew]

Is there anyone who won more than one besides Reck and Spy?

Thor

[Parama]

Parama, if you're talking about Vi, Professor Paragon is her actual title.

It was her scummies title originally because she won two.

Then peeps decided to keep it because it was fitting.

[SleepyKrew]

So... what's your point?

[Faraday]

Mafia MetaMafia was his point.

[UncertainKitten]

So, wait, Psychic not only got nommed but won? I'm somewhat surprised. That was sorta...special gamewise.

[SleepyKrew]

Mafia MetaMafia was his point.

That explains why I have no clue what he's talking about.

Carry on.

[Vi]

Mafia MetaMafia was his point.

Yeah, Team Mafia might have had a chance in other years but zorotter was competing against the HIGH PRIEST OF MR. FLAY.~

[Oversoul]

New banner look eh

I don't know if I like the font. :C Detracts from the look of the banner in my opinion.

[Mr. Flay]

Mafia MetaMafia was his point.

Yeah, Team Mafia might have had a chance in other years but zorotter was competing against the HIGH PRIEST OF MR. FLAY.~

Huh? How did I get involved in this discussion?

[Kublai Khan]

I think we're all agreed that it's mostly Flay's fault.

[zoraster]

Magua won that category I thought? Not that marketplace mafia wasn't cool. But Team Mafia deserved to win; there is no doubt in my mind. I'm still upset that it did not, but I don't think hashing it out in public is really the right call. I have no desire to take anything away from another talented mod, which is what it could comes across as in this thread -- thus the request for a PM conversation.

As for psychic mafia winning, it was the town that won that, not the actual game. And given that the town steam rolled a fairly well thought of group of guys, it doesn't seem unreasonable that they won there.

[Mr. Flay]

I think we're all agreed that it's mostly Flay's fault.

Oh okay, got it.

zoro: I'm around on FB chat if you want.

[Amrun]

Magua won that category I thought? Not that marketplace mafia wasn't cool. But Team Mafia deserved to win; there is no doubt in my mind. I'm still upset that it did not, but I don't think hashing it out in public is really the right call. I have no desire to take anything away from another talented mod, which is what it could comes across as in this thread -- thus the request for a PM conversation.

As for psychic mafia winning, it was the town that won that, not the actual game. And given that the town steam rolled a fairly well thought of group of guys, it doesn't seem unreasonable that they won there.

For what it's worth, I agree with you. I was outnumbered.

[zoraster]

but then my name will be known! Ahhhh! Or... wait. I think I revealed it when I was drunk and MS was out.

[UncertainKitten]

@Zora: Well, I mean, I was part of the winners, it's just...I dunno, not the best memories of the game. Ythill was probably who most would consider the most talented of that scum team and he really dropped the ball.

OH WELL I GOT A SCUMMY BANNER SO I'LL QUIT LOOKING GIFT HORSES IN THE MOUTH =D

[zoraster]

Magua won that category I thought? Not that marketplace mafia wasn't cool. But Team Mafia deserved to win; there is no doubt in my mind. I'm still upset that it did not, but I don't think hashing it out in public is really the right call. I have no desire to take anything away from another talented mod, which is what it could comes across as in this thread -- thus the request for a PM conversation.

As for psychic mafia winning, it was the town that won that, not the actual game. And given that the town steam rolled a fairly well thought of group of guys, it doesn't seem unreasonable that they won there.

For what it's worth, I agree with you. I was outnumbered.

Thanks, Amrun. But I'm not so much looking to blame individual people -- Judging isn't easy -- as I am to chat to try and gain understanding at the reasoning. I've been nominated before. This is the only time I've been upset by not winning.

[Amrun]

Others argued that it wasn't really a new "mechanic," just kind of like an out-of-game hydra. They said it didn't inherently change the way the game was played, in the thread, and I just ... well, totally disagreed.

[AGar]

Zoraster, as one of those who did vote against it, you can PM me if you want my perspective on why I chose the way I did. I'm not going to just throw it out there and hash it out in public - especially seeing as you don't seem to want that again - but I'm more than willing to share my opinions with you.

[Vi]

Magua won that category I thought?

That's the joke. Mr. Flay missed it too but everything is his fault so etc.