AGar wrote:Axelrod wrote:AGar wrote:Axelrod: That is unimportant at this point in time.
Unimportant how? Seems like that would be one of the more important things we could get out in the open.
Maybe I'm missing something. Can you say what reason is there for you (or anyone) who knows that a particular role is in the game, not to say? I don't see how that negatively impacts the person who says. If they subsequently get killed, at least that information would be out there and confirmed at that point. It's almost like a Cop result (baring shenanigans of some kind).
It matters not right now whether or not I may or may not be able to clear another player at this or a later point in time. If you have a further line of reasoning to pursue this avenue, bring it forth. But I'm going to more than likely ignore future advances down this route by you, as you seem to have no other reason for doing it than blatant rolefishing.
Okay, 1st, you don't know what role-fishing is.
But 2nd, and more importantly, you STILL seem to be missing the point. Let me try this another way.
So far, you have said (and do please correct me if I'm wrong) that you have been mod-informed that Poseidon is in the game. That's all you've said.
SD claimed Poseidon. You are assuming, not unreasonably, that Poseidon is Town because, well, mod told us that Greek Gods are Town.
Now, this really hasn't told us much of anything about your role, has it? I don't think it has. Which is good. My ENTIRE POINT is that this is the kind of information people can give us that DOESN'T reveal anything else about their own role/abilities. And yet, it can act to "clear" people later when they claim those roles.
Let's say you had some OTHER roles that you knew were "in the game." Saying those other roles similarly doesn't say much of anything about your role/abilities. What it does is get this info out there in the event you DIE. You don't need to wait until someone claims a role that you know is in the game. You could do it NOW. The effect is the same, and there's no risk of you dying and taking said info to the grave with you.
You know what, forget it. I don't think this is really going anywhere anyway.