Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[Dunnstral]

What last scum just lets a cop number 2 live?

Well this one did

[Dunnstral]

What way would scum have to avoid my role?

[beeboy]

I think Dunnstral as scum was to some degree playing to his out. But he also presented fair logic if he believed I was 100% town and both himself and you die anyway it didn't matter. So he might as well check Raven.
Like the logic isn't that flawed tbh, maybe I am just a sucker for people calling me town though and I was supposed to roast him.

[Dunnstral]

It's really scummy that Clover is arguing this btw, because I will flip town, and they will have to try to get an elimination on somebody else

[Raven Branwen]

Yeah Raven Branwen didn't make the kill, so you can bump-off me then Clover

VOTE: Dunnstral

Why didn’t you check Clover?

I'm playing to the worst case scenario instead of the best case scenario

Best case scenario is clover is scum, and I do believe clover gets eliminated regardless

Worst case scenario is you were scum, and I believe you could have beaten Beeboy in limlo

But I would never kill Skitter. She was never voting me, that’s practically a soft clear. I honestly think you actually believe this makes sense though and I don’t understand why scum!you no kills N3. I think you’re probably town because you’re freaking sucidal self-sabotaging scum if you are.

I think Clover had the most incentive to no kill and Dru totally bought into the mafia must be dead thing and switch her suspicions from him to tin foil some 3P scumteam.

If it’s bee we autolose but I very much doubt that it is.

[beeboy]

Clover why did you quick hammer with no discussion yesterday?
I told Dunn to check you because that was basically a scum claim.

[beeboy]

I mean I am trying to figure this out, since I don't think it's impossible I don't get lynched.
So I want to make sure I make the right choice.

Level 1 says it's Dunn.
Both of you played great scum games so props to that.
But even if you played great I don't want to lose.

[beeboy]

But level 1 also made me lynch Dru so idk how much I trust level 1 right now lol

[Clover Ebi]

What last scum just lets a cop number 2 live?

Well this one did

That isn't an argument

[Raven Branwen]

If you're town I don't see how scum doesn't have a role to avoid you/the watcher. Do you really believe I'm a mafia goon who just decided to leave you alive? I'm willing to listen if you think that's the case but uh, I don't see it

If you're mafia and you killed me last night, that means MT is still alive, midway is cleared, etc. Then it's just you, beeboy, Raven. And you surely get eliminated there.

No because Skitter kill softclears me because why would scum!me ever kill a slot that was never voting me? Think. God.

[Clover Ebi]

Clover why did you quick hammer with no discussion yesterday?
I told Dunn to check you because that was basically a scum claim.

There was nothing to talk about. At most I could've made a defense but I didn't want to talk to Raven because of how uncomfortable she makes me. So I figured just no pressure was fine. I don't see how it was a scum claim.

[Raven Branwen]

Clover why did you quick hammer with no discussion yesterday?
I told Dunn to check you because that was basically a scum claim.

I was definitely not happy about that.

Btw @MT, sorry if I was a but rattled yesterday. <3

[beeboy]

VOTE: Dunn/vote]

On review I don't see why Dunn waited until the night phase to talk about checking Raven.
I don't scum read the act of checking Raven in particular.
I think he justified that to me very well.

I just think he should have spoke about that in the open

[Clover Ebi]

Raven never kills the person hard defending her and to me it just feels like Dunnstral didn't want to clear me because he knew he'd never be able to get Raven lynched.

[beeboy]

hmmm
idk I guess I could just lynch Dunn.

If the game has 2 scum then whatever?

[Clover Ebi]

Even Dunnstral himself is making the arguement that scum can't get around his role. So why does a scum that isn't Dunnstral leave him alive? They don't. This is the one read I've been confident on and I feel like most of this game has just pushed me to the side and now we're at final 5 where if I just spoke up and didn't get dru lynched we wouldn't be here

[beeboy]

VOTE: Dunnstral

Sigh can we just end this game.
Lynching Dru is still haunting me.

And I am going back to my logic that day, one of Dunnstral and Dru has to flip scum.

[beeboy]

MT isn't the kill Clover makes if leaving Dunnstral alive is worth it.
Midway is.

MT was always killing Dunnstral first.

[Raven Branwen]

I think Dunnstral as scum was to some degree playing to his out. But he also presented fair logic if he believed I was 100% town and both himself and you die anyway it didn't matter. So he might as well check Raven.
Like the logic isn't that flawed tbh, maybe I am just a sucker for people calling me town though and I was supposed to roast him.

I believe he believes it but scum!me never ever kills the slot that is 100% never voting me, so I still think it was a bad call but whatever.

[Dunnstral]

oof

Get Clover tomorrow because this fast talk is designed for when I flip town

[Dunnstral]

hmmm
idk I guess I could just lynch Dunn.

If the game has 2 scum then whatever?

Who are the 2 scum if I'm town......

[Dunnstral]

replace town with wolf you know what I mean

[Raven Branwen]

MT isn't the kill Clover makes if leaving Dunnstral alive is worth it.
Midway is.

MT was always killing Dunnstral first.

Hello bee, wifom calling?

[Dunnstral]

3389 is you saying you don't mind losing by voting me out if there's still 2 scum alive - is what I'm getting at here

[beeboy]

MT isn't the kill Clover makes if leaving Dunnstral alive is worth it.
Midway is.

MT was always killing Dunnstral first.

Hello bee, wifom calling?

When WIFOM calls I just play level 1 mafia.