Labyrinth Mafia (Endgame)

[WhemeStar]

Scum scum hood?

Nah

Why not

[Scioness Sajj]

Defies its purpose

[Wisdom]

Ive seen a game that had it

[Scioness Sajj]

I guess it's not impossible but don't think it's likely

[Wisdom]

true

[Scioness Sajj]

Lol right just read the flip

[Randomnamechange]

Sajj is likely town because scum redirected Nancy to Sajj on N1.

Think about that from scum's perspective. If Nancy had been cop investigating scum, scum appear innocent. If Nancy had been cop investigating town, town appears innocent (no difference is made). If Nancy had been vig shooting scum, town dies instead. If Nancy had been vig shooting town, no difference is made. If Nancy had been a protective role, scum guarantees protector isn't on their nightkill.

It's very unlikely that scum redirect Nancy to one of their own. Thus, Sajj is town.

how has no one pointed out horrifically awful this logic is

[Scioness Sajj]

Explain?

[Wisdom]

other than the fact we dont know sajj didnt make up her "oh i just got the loud thing", i thought that was a decent point

[Shoshin]

then who is scum shoshin? I refuse to consider Nancy and tw and wheme are unlikely

Nancy is not scum, agreed.

That leaves TW, Wheme, Random, and you. I don't know who the scum are in that group, but that's where they are.

[Shoshin]

you make the most sense as scum with chick and in general
I dont particularly care about why you claimed bg

The fact that I'm a protective role was proven by Reality... Like, how do you explain the fact that I protected Nico on N2?

[Shoshin]

As for the hood, why are we assuming that Chick and Random didn't fake being in a hood together? Why couldn't Chick be in the same hood with Reality/Wheme? And Random just be scum who isn't even in a hood?

[Shoshin]

That's much less of a stretch than saying that I'm a scum doctor who claimed bodyguard and then protected Nico the same night that scum tried to kill Nico...

[Shoshin]

I guess it's not impossible but don't think it's likely

I'm glad that you've started to think in terms of probability.

[Randomnamechange]

ok if nancy is town vig directing to someone who is scum is bad
if she's a protective or investigative, it's good because it could take her off of town onto scum creating a false positive or stopping a protection onto their target

[Randomnamechange]

As for the hood, why are we assuming that Chick and Random didn't fake being in a hood together? Why couldn't Chick be in the same hood with Reality/Wheme? And Random just be scum who isn't even in a hood?

because of chick's fucking flip jfc

[Scioness Sajj]

I don't think reality and wheme would lie about being in hood with chick

[Shoshin]

other than the fact we dont know sajj didnt make up her "oh i just got the loud thing", i thought that was a decent point

]If Sajj made it up, who did scum redirect to? It wasn't Nico. It wasn't TBG. It wasn't Shepard. So who?

[Shoshin]

I don't think reality and wheme would lie about being in hood with chick

Reality and Wheme don't know who is in their hood.

Reality thought that I was in the hood but had been lurking to get information. Or something like that. Like, there's no reason to believe their hood is exclusive to Reality and Wheme.

[Shoshin]

If Wheme flips scum, then I'd agree that Random is probably town. Otherwise, I'm not counting Random out.

[Scioness Sajj]

ok if nancy is town vig directing to someone who is scum is bad
if she's a protective or investigative, it's good because it could take her off of town onto scum creating a false positive or stopping a protection onto their target

yeah but it was n1 action
it's more likely i'm lying about being targeted than it is for scum to know nancy's role

[Shoshin]

ok if nancy is town vig directing to someone who is scum is bad
if she's a protective or investigative, it's good because it could take her off of town onto scum creating a false positive or stopping a protection onto their target

Random's spewing nonsense.

Scum don't redirect a random townie to themselves. They just don't.

[Scioness Sajj]

I don't think reality and wheme would lie about being in hood with chick

Reality and Wheme don't know who is in their hood.

Reality thought that I was in the hood but had been lurking to get information. Or something like that. Like, there's no reason to believe their hood is exclusive to Reality and Wheme.

???
I don't remember reading about it?

[Shoshin]

Sajj isn't lying about being targeted. Like, if she were lying, who did they redirect to? We know with absolute certainty it wasn't any of the dead townies. TBG died. Nico wasn't blocked. And Shepard wasn't blocked. So it was Sajj.

[Shoshin]

I don't think reality and wheme would lie about being in hood with chick

Reality and Wheme don't know who is in their hood.

Reality thought that I was in the hood but had been lurking to get information. Or something like that. Like, there's no reason to believe their hood is exclusive to Reality and Wheme.

???
I don't remember reading about it?

The entire reason that Reality thought I could be scum is because she thought I had access to their neighborhood. If she thought that, it means she thought it was plausible that scum had been lurking in their hood. And that means the scenario I've just outlined above is possible.