In post 379, MuttonChopMagic wrote:I hard town read gamma
smd not gonna make a diorama
I think his wagon has at least two scum
who? dunno yet, but we'll find out dun dun dun
In post 380, MuttonChopMagic wrote:gamma is shitposting yes
and his play isn't blessed
that's pretty nai for him though
and from experience that's a primed scum hammer throw
shitposting can't often be misconstrued as scummy
take transcend, though anyways, usually only by dummies
What is this contradiction?
You say his behavior is NAI yet you hard town read him?
that's not what a contradiction is
I didn't town read him for shitposting ya wiz
In post 382, Crush wrote:I Like: Ginngie, Lore, PMysterious, WhyMafia, FourTrouble, Egg (in no particular order). Scummiest so far is Gamma.
I didn't vote because I did not catch up yet. Lets go for:
VOTE: Lexa
I'll be more active tomorrow.
Reasoning?
Lexa and Platinum are the only votes on Gamma on who I have no read. But since Gamma voted for Platinum it seems more natural (?) for me to vote for Lexa. I want to hear more from Lexa to solidify my read on the Gamma wagon.
I kind of understand what you're getting it? But shouldn't you ask Hernandez opinion on stuff then?
In post 382, Crush wrote:I Like: Ginngie, Lore, PMysterious, WhyMafia, FourTrouble, Egg (in no particular order). Scummiest so far is Gamma.
I didn't vote because I did not catch up yet. Lets go for:
VOTE: Lexa
I'll be more active tomorrow.
Reasoning?
Lexa and Platinum are the only votes on Gamma on who I have no read. But since Gamma voted for Platinum it seems more natural (?) for me to vote for Lexa. I want to hear more from Lexa to solidify my read on the Gamma wagon.
Assuming you want to know why I voted gamma?
I liked gin's suggestion of having dueling wagons and I didn't want to lynch transcend so I hopped on gamma to see what happened
So what do you think of the players that hopped on the wagon?
And do you have any strong reads yourself?
In post 379, MuttonChopMagic wrote:I hard town read gamma
smd not gonna make a diorama
I think his wagon has at least two scum
who? dunno yet, but we'll find out dun dun dun
In post 380, MuttonChopMagic wrote:gamma is shitposting yes
and his play isn't blessed
that's pretty nai for him though
and from experience that's a primed scum hammer throw
shitposting can't often be misconstrued as scummy
take transcend, though anyways, usually only by dummies
What is this contradiction?
You say his behavior is NAI yet you hard town read him?
that's not what a contradiction is
I didn't town read him for shitposting ya wiz
In post 382, Crush wrote:I Like: Ginngie, Lore, PMysterious, WhyMafia, FourTrouble, Egg (in no particular order). Scummiest so far is Gamma.
I didn't vote because I did not catch up yet. Lets go for:
VOTE: Lexa
I'll be more active tomorrow.
Reasoning?
Lexa and Platinum are the only votes on Gamma on who I have no read. But since Gamma voted for Platinum it seems more natural (?) for me to vote for Lexa. I want to hear more from Lexa to solidify my read on the Gamma wagon.
I kind of understand what you're getting it? But shouldn't you ask Hernandez opinion on stuff then?
In post 382, Crush wrote:I Like: Ginngie, Lore, PMysterious, WhyMafia, FourTrouble, Egg (in no particular order). Scummiest so far is Gamma.
I didn't vote because I did not catch up yet. Lets go for:
VOTE: Lexa
I'll be more active tomorrow.
Reasoning?
Lexa and Platinum are the only votes on Gamma on who I have no read. But since Gamma voted for Platinum it seems more natural (?) for me to vote for Lexa. I want to hear more from Lexa to solidify my read on the Gamma wagon.
Assuming you want to know why I voted gamma?
I liked gin's suggestion of having dueling wagons and I didn't want to lynch transcend so I hopped on gamma to see what happened
So what do you think of the players that hopped on the wagon?
And do you have any strong reads yourself?
Only strong read is egg town at the moment, haven't seen much else explicitly jumping out at me
Tho Tbh I've been focus on a game in my home site but I just got mislynched at p197 so this now become the priority
In post 391, texcat wrote:What's your fascination with Theta? She's barely posted. Hardly anything to form an opinion on. What do you think is insanely awkward about her 4 posts?
Her language is very halting. I get the sense she's scared to post, scared to fuck up.
Then look at 291. The words "okay wait," followed by her question, express concern. But there's no attempt to weigh in. Feels like she's pretending to care about Gamma's lynch. Contrived emotion, surrounded by a lots of nothingness.
In post 379, MuttonChopMagic wrote:I hard town read gamma
smd not gonna make a diorama
I think his wagon has at least two scum
who? dunno yet, but we'll find out dun dun dun
In post 380, MuttonChopMagic wrote:gamma is shitposting yes
and his play isn't blessed
that's pretty nai for him though
and from experience that's a primed scum hammer throw
shitposting can't often be misconstrued as scummy
take transcend, though anyways, usually only by dummies
What is this contradiction?
You say his behavior is NAI yet you hard town read him?
that's not what a contradiction is
I didn't town read him for shitposting ya wiz
So why do you town read him?
his wagon grew way too quick
sure, maybe it's a bussing trick
but he's not concerned with how he looks
not trying to appease people, not playing by the books
it's just somebody being lynched for playstyle
lynching shitposting before page 10, yall old and senile?
I disagree any of his content is inherently scummy
and as for the wagon as a whole? it's crummy
this is the kind of wagon led by red
it's easy to make someone like gamma dead
I firmly believe he's flipping green
don't lynch him please, that's mean
In post 352, FourTrouble wrote:@Ginn - you're missing the point. Lots of people have personal philosophies. They shouldn't have a place in mafia. Your approach in particular makes winning (as town) much more difficult than it needs to be.
Personal philosophy after many games of experience I might add.
I know how I work, my reads are people who annoy me, and then, usually out of the blue after 7 days, I feel like there is enough actual content, and I break gamez. You're just getting pissy I'm not doing it right now, but relax and enjoy the ride <3
You say I don't share reads right now, but you ignore my gamma vote, you ignore me loving a dueling wagon idea with Transcend and Gamma and just piss on how I'm getting people to generate content.
I'm not fucking silent, you're just not using reader comprehension.
Best advice to sort me? Bloody wait, especially when there is this many people. Just bloody trust me when I say you'll know I'm town when I want you to know I'm town. Just help me, by sorting literally everyone else instead of sorting me because I don't need me sorted.
The last thing is if you seriously get your britches in a knot this much, I can link you to two games off the top of my head where I do this and work perfectly to break games.
In post 61, Egg wrote:I think it's the exclamation point.
Really an exclamation point makes you scumread me? How would you prefer I wrote it? The exclamation point adds a specific tone I was aiming for.
A case of overreaction. This post felt really unnecessary, as most of us likely know what you were trying to get across to begin with. Maybe it just felt "a little forced". More on that after the next quote.
This was kinda just more so rude than anything. A post just saying hello is just a post saying hello. I know this is Mafia and all, but this early in the game, we barely know each other. It's almost as if you're just looking for a reason to try and lynch someone to save your behind for a night.
In post 57, Egg wrote:I don't like either pmyst's or gamma's reaction to lapsa being confirmed town. Pmyst commenting on it being "quick" feels like he wasn't happy about it. Gamma is the exact opposite, seeming to exaggarate his happiness. It's weird how both initially took pisskop's "always town" comment so seriously too. Both players have made a post I liked though (26 and 33).
Fourtrouble, why should we lynch transcend?
And why does pmyst feel town?
(I see you retracted that)
Not a fan of pisskop buddying to ABR.
Tchill, why the naked vote on transcend?
Whymafia is coming off nervous, but also noticed a couple of the same things I did.
Gamma, what is forced about saying hi?
Theta, care to elaborate on your "reasons"?
Texcat, why don't you seem happy with a confirmed town?
Vote Gamma
Why are you asking me what's forced about it? Fifth Amendment bitch!
I was happy to start what seemed like an exciting game.
Well, this seems like another case of an overreaction. Plus, pleading Fifth Amendment in a game of Mafia really doesn't work.
I'm no expert at Mafia, but overreacting to people voting you or asking you questions of this type really does not scream town at all. That, and the completely jerkish move against someone who just wanted to say "hi" really doesn't help favors.
My vote against you was originally an RV, but now I'm sticking to my guns and saying that you are most definitely scum. My vote on you stays, unless you can convince me otherwise. So, please do tell, what reason do you have on a simple "hi" being so forced?
My platinum vote was to see who'd needlessly pick at it
You read too much into it, looks forced VOTE: PMysterious
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
Like, I just said I was going to keep producing content, just not push a serious lynch till a week from now. That's not a hard stance to understand yet ABR votes it.
I don't think he thinks one can sheep the IC and think that makes any wagon a righteous wagon, he has to have an actual reason as to why he votes.
because you take one actual look at your ISO, you make social remarks and questions to people, generally shit posting content-wise and then vote me in a naked way.
You're not game solving or anything but using this as a theatric to feign contribution
@Ginn - nobody asked you to push a lynch. You've been asked questions about your reads. In my case, I didn't understand the read, so I was hoping to get your insights. I was also trying to read you, to sort your alignment. And the best way to sort your alignment is to understand your perspective on the game. But instead, you ignored my question, not because you missed it, but because you thought ignoring me was somehow pro-town.
So, it's clear you don't want to work with me, or with anyone else... you'd rather work alone. And maybe that's how you've always played. But it's also suboptimal. You're missing the forest for the trees because, in effect, you're setting a precedent that lets scum follow your lead (i.e. if you don't have to explain your reads, or answer questions, or work with anyone, then neither do scum), which makes it more difficult to identify scum (and if identified, to collectively lynch them). Now, I could get into more detail about what you're doing wrong but I don't feel like launching into an extensive mafia lesson in the middle of a game. You'll play as you do and we'll have to adapt. In 7 days, you'll imagine yourself "breaking" the game. And the game might indeed "break" because of your play but I doubt it'll be in the way you imagine.
