Good vs Evil, Law vs Chaos Reboot - Game Over, Good wins

[Tammy]

All right...let's do this.

I'm still paranoid about Nacho, but I did lean town on him after our wall battle. Mina's death is one thing that makes me really paranoid about Nacho, but he just reads so much more genuine than Mastin does. Feysal's description of Mastin's play and the strangeness of it is spot on. I remember when Mastin popped up and started trying to find partners, when he linked Junpei to BB after the flip, and it felt really off to me.

I just don't see how anything Mastin could say is going to change my mind. None of his walls have really said anything, so here's hoping we got it right!

If this is the end, it was a lot of fun playing with you all.

And, good job on your investigation Pine! Chesskid would have probably been a hard one to get lynched without it.

vote: Mastin

[Pine]

As you wish.

Vote: Mastin

[Nachomamma8]

Vote: Mastin

Good shit.

[Haze]

Ok, good luck Lawful dudes.

VOTE: Mastin

[chesskid3]

Unvote

Vote: mastin

[chesskid3]

ONE MORE

[Junpei]

vote Mastin

This better be right.

[Pine]

Doesn't matter if it's right. Not to you or I, at any rate.

[Seacore]

Final Day 6 Vote Count

mastin2 (7) -

Feysal, Tammy, Pine, Nachomamma8, Haze, chesskid3, Junpei

Nachomamma8 (2) -

mastin2, Moneybag

chesskid3 (2) -

Empking, Zdenek

Not Voting (1) - AurorusVox

With 12 alive, 7 were needed to secure a lynch.

The early hours of the day were sharp with both accusation and confession... and perhaps that shock stunned the crowd into silence. For hours upon hours there was little but murmers as townspeople thought aloud to themselves and few others. The offer of an admitted killer to help catch other killers... to what ends? Redemption? Distraction? But it was not an offer many could turn down.
As the day wore on, mastin2 was accused. He was dragged to the gallows and without waiting for final words, he was thrown from the wood.

The snapping of his neck was loud. And the echo seemed to resound in a strange way. As if everything that was dark and beastial had been scared away by a gunshot. mastin2 was clearly the last of the

Chaotic Evil

.

The

Lawful Good

members of the town immediately gave praise. They were saved! Together they blessed those who remained behind and went to the temple to pray long into the night.

The others retreated to their beds... tomorrow would probably go well, but one among them would pay the price.

mastin 2 -

Chaotic Evil

Commoner was lynched Day 6
Nachomamma8 -

Lawful Good

Commoner won the game and left Day 6
Tammy -

Lawful Good

Commoner won the game and left Day 6
Feysal -

Lawful Good

Wizard won the game and left Day 6

Lawful Good have successfully completed their win condition. The game continues.

I imagine night will be pretty short.

[Seacore]

Epilogue

The sun came up, and those villagers who had not gone to the temple crept from their homes. And one of their number was missing.

Chesskid3 was found dead in his home. A small vial in his hand and a look of bliss on his face. A small sniff of the vial confirmed suspicions. Honeygloom, a euphoria inducing toxin. He had chosen to end his own life rather than swing.

The villagers celebrated and were soon joined by their companions from the church.

They would not all see eye to eye, but at least they could live free from evil

Game over.

Lawful Good wins.
Chaotic Good wins.

I'll post some thoughts when I get a chance, as well as all the PMs.

Briefly, I think this was a fair success, and balanced about right.

Curious to hear your thoughts, I will certainly be running another two town at some other stage, and others are welcome to steal what they wish from the set up.

[chesskid3]

TOO MANY TOWN PRS

[BBmolla]

I suck at mafia

[Seacore]

chesskid, you lost because you left a cop alive since he claimed Day 1.

The 'too many' PRs were balanced in a few ways, one of which was two scum kills per lynch.

[Tammy]

OMG YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYA!!!! :dancingbanana:

I'm so glad we chose right! Maybe my terrible sucking at endgame streak has finally come to an end.

Chesskid, that's so hysterical!

Also, why did you guys leave Pine alive?

[Junpei]

4/6 lynches were on scum, not too bad I guess.

Chesskid, a day six loss =/= overpowered PRs.

[chesskid3]

day 6 loss with 6 scum and no town prs?

How many of the scum lynches were from PR related shennanigans

[kondi2424]

Considering only two scum were lynched due to scumhunting, I'd say this was a bit OP

[Tammy]

Well, one real cop guilty on CD

BB's catch was due to his claim. I really don't know why he claimed when he did. But, still think he would have gotten lynched that day or the next. Also, if he wouldn't have claimed LG, he might not have gotten busted.

Cop guilty on Chesskid, but Pine should have been killed long before he was able to make that investigation.

[Junpei]

I don't know, how about you tell me? You screwed up by leaving Pine alive when you KNEW that you would have to lie about your alignment.

Kondi, every lynch had something to do with scumhunting. Especially the night actions which involved scumhunting as well. The town PRs were not OP..

[Tammy]

Also, don't know why Mastin killed Mina. He could have left her alive and capitalized on my paranoia.

[BBmolla]

BB's catch was due to his claim. I really don't know why he claimed when he did. But, still think he would have gotten lynched that day or the next. Also, if he wouldn't have claimed LG, he might not have gotten busted.

Because I actually did what I claimed I did.

Except night one, my mafia bros used me to block Pine.

[kondi2424]

Let's see -

Shadoweh was a legit lynch

CoolDoG was only lynched when he was because of a guilty

BB was only lynched when he was because of role contradiction

And mastin was a legit lynch.

Not sure on MoS, depends on why the Lawfuls killed him

chesskid was caught due to guilty and likely would have lasted longer.

Town still did good, I'm not saying they didn't. I just think it was leaning on favoring town.

[Tammy]

Eh, I'd go 50/50 on BB. Too many people were gunning for him. He was only lynched in the end because of the role contradiction but he wouldn't have lasted much longer I don't think.

[Junpei]

BB
1) Didn't claim solely because of mechanics
2) Could have claimed much better

Chesskid
1) Should have killed Pine
2) Could have overall played better

Town outplayed scum in this game and the result showed it in my opinion. Take away Pines' guilty and you get a completely different outlook on how this game is balanced by you. Pine should have been shot, it's that simple.

[chesskid3]

I couldn't have shot Pine with the other PRs around.

Post MC pine HAD to be last to die
with the fuckin protection from lawful asshole around and on pine.