Mini 592: Xyl's Mafia 1 - Game over!

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

AlyG -

3

(2extreme1, icemanE, eljcko)
icemanE -

2

(roflcopter, AlyG)
Jenter Brolincani -

1

(alvinz95)
Erratus Apathos -

1

(malthusis)
Phate -

1

(minineko)
eljcko -

1

(Erratus Apathos)

Not voting - Jenter Brolincani, Phate

With 11 alive, it will take 6 to lynch.

[AlyG]

FOS: Minineko

What with the random posts? They have no logic and are useless. Acting stupid as a cover up?

Maybe he's just having a joke cause we are so early in the game? I don't get how you coud act stupid as a cover up though <_<

Would you vote to kill the stupid person?

It depends...Anyway i think we should all unvote since we are out of the random voting stage now.

[roflcopter]

It depends...Anyway i think we should all unvote since we are out of the random voting stage now.

...

...

no. stop being dumb. my vote was never random in the first place, and from what i've gathered most of us have been out of the random vote stage from a while now. between you and eljcko i'm really starting to doubt my iceman vote, but i'm going to wait until i hear from him again and for minineko to answer my questions before i decide where its going next.

[Minineko]

some questions for minineko:

(1) if it was a small tell that is not worth arguing, what do you think is worth arguing?

(2) if you had to make a nonrandom vote, who would it be for? why?
why isn't your vote on that person instead of still being used as a joke vote?

Dunno where you're going with this, but I'll bite

(1) This is a bit of a silly question, isn't it? Things that are almost totally insignificant aren't worth arguing. Not only is icemanE's tell very minor, there is absolutely nothing anyone can say that will change my mind of it being just that: a very minor tell. What _is_ worth arguing? Uhh.. anything significant? Something based on repeated tells, odd behavior from people, the validity of a claim, etc. Lots of things.

(2) Probably icemanE, based on that signle minor tell. I haven't really sensed anything else yet. Which is why my vote is still a random player. Once you're bringing this up, there's no real harm in

unvote

ing.

[icemanE]

I like that the random voting stage ended VERY quickly in this game, it's a relatively pointless part of the game. If nothing else, my "tell" (which is obviously being looked WAY too far into, considering its even still being discussed) accomplished that.

I may or may not be slightly inactive for the next few days, final papers to write.

[roflcopter]

This is a bit of a silly question, isn't it?

i don't think so, but we obviously disagree about the importance of iceman's early tell. you haven't said anything about the other textbook scum tell he has dropped, so i'll ask a follow up question. do you think iceman presented a sufficient case against alyg for his vote? in the same vein, what is your opinion of alyg's play so far?

[icemanE]

ice's glaring scum tells and flippant attitude about them

Ha, I just wanted to point out how much rofl has overcooked his case on me. It just looks silly.

[alvinz95]

I like that the random voting stage ended VERY quickly in this game, it's a relatively pointless part of the game.

What makes you think moves in the random voting stage should be ignored because it is pointless?

[icemanE]

I like that the random voting stage ended VERY quickly in this game, it's a relatively pointless part of the game.

What makes you think moves in the random voting stage should be ignored because it is pointless?

Compared to the rest of the game, which is based on info and observations instead of random punches in the dark, its pretty pointless. Good things come out of it obviously, but discussion gets going quicker when people like Rofl over analyze a post like my first one.

[eljcko]

FOS: Minineko

What with the random posts? They have no logic and are useless. Acting stupid as a cover up?

Maybe he's just having a joke cause we are so early in the game? I don't get how you coud act stupid as a cover up though <_<

Would you vote to kill the stupid person?

It depends...Anyway i think we should all unvote since we are out of the random voting stage now.

Why, because you have 3?

[Xylthixlm]

I would like to remind you that the deadline rules for this game are unusual:

1. You will have a deadline of only

2 weeks

for day 2 and later.
2. Lynching at deadline will require a full majority, except that inactive players won't be counted.
3. You may bank deadline time for a later day by lynching early.

I strongly recommend you pick up the pace, or you will find yourselves very rushed on day 2 and later.

[Minineko]

I like that the random voting stage ended VERY quickly in this game, it's a relatively pointless part of the game. If nothing else, my "tell" (which is obviously being looked WAY too far into, considering its even still being discussed) accomplished that.

Yes, but that doesn't nullify it, as it was unintentional. Err, thanks though, I guess.

i don't think so, but we obviously disagree about the importance of iceman's early tell. you haven't said anything about the other textbook scum tell he has dropped, so i'll ask a follow up question. do you think iceman presented a sufficient case against alyg for his vote? in the same vein, what is your opinion of alyg's play so far?

icemanE's first post sort of baffles me. Part of the reason I'm not really comfortable using it as a big tell against him is that I don't know what to make of it. It sticks out more as strange than anything else, to me.

If you're referring to post 18, I assumed that was partly random.

Though I'm not denying the possibility of an AliG/rofl scumteam, I think all evidence iceman has posted it favor of it is nonsense.

Meow.

[Minineko]

Oh, missed a part. My opinion of AlyG so far? He's been kinda useless, but not necessarily scummy. I hope he can make himseld more useful soon

MrrRRowl.

[icemanE]

icemanE's first post sort of baffles me. Part of the reason I'm not really comfortable using it as a big tell against him is that I don't know what to make of it. It sticks out more as strange than anything else, to me.

Just out of curiosity, which of my posts did you find strange? I think they're all fairly straightforward:

3: The bummer post
18: Vote for AlyG in the random stage, slightly OMGUS because he made a big deal of nothing.
24: Laughing at Rofl
26: Proposal that they're might be a link between Rofl and AlyG
36: Explaining to AlyG that 2 votes is technically the start of a bandwagon, and that my one vote on him isn't anything to freak out about.
41: I think this is the one you might have found strange. "One player can make the other look bad by buddying up with him, even if the other player denies it. That's the difference: no matter how good one player is, if the other is bad enough, he'll make both look scummy. Based on the small amount of evidence we have so far I'm not entirely convinced that you're both scum, but that's the scummiest thing I've seen so far this game so I'm going with it." But I don't see anything strange about it.
43: Asking this questionof EA: "Where's evidence of myself buddying with a townie, out of curiosity?" Which was never answered.
45: Laughing at Minineko for criticizing me for not posting more in the first player post of the game. Which I still think is funny.
54: Saying I'm glad the random stage ended quickly.
56: Laughing at Rofl again.
58: Repeat of 54.

What's strange?

I'll tell you what's strange! You forgot to Meow in post 53!

[Minineko]

Did you read my post? I said the first one. That would be #3.

And #63, for your reading failure.

Meow.

[icemanE]

And #63, for your reading failure.

What?

[icemanE]

Also I'd like to hear from:

2extreme1
alvinz95
Erratus Apathos
Jenter Brolincani
malthusis
Phate

[Xylthixlm]

I am looking for a replacement for Phate, as he has not posted in the thread.

[2extreme1]

Also I'd like to hear from:

2extreme1

What would you like to hear? I've stated my opinions and really don't have much more to say in the matter

[AlyG]

FOS: Minineko

What with the random posts? They have no logic and are useless. Acting stupid as a cover up?

Maybe he's just having a joke cause we are so early in the game? I don't get how you coud act stupid as a cover up though <_<

Would you vote to kill the stupid person?

It depends...Anyway i think we should all unvote since we are out of the random voting stage now.

Why, because you have 3?

I'd like it to be noted that all votes on me are NOT random, so there goes that question. And i asked to unvote because many people have votes that are now pointless and not needed.

[Erratus Apathos]

Eljcko and Iceman continue to set off my scumdar. Iceman for leaving eljcko off his list of people who need to post more; Eljcko for outright ignoring post 42.

And that's a damn good incentive for a scumbag to buddy up with a townie. Welcome to WIFOMville, population: you.

Where's evidence of myself buddying with a townie, out of curiosity?

That's not at all what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that Aly's attempts to buddy up with rofl isn't evidence against rofl, but you're trying to use them against him anyways.

[icemanE]

leaving eljcko off his list of people who need to post more

Eljcko has posted on this page. Alvin has only posted twice, so that's why he's on the list and Eljcko isnt.

[Jenter Brolincani]

I'm back.

AlyG, from my minimal experience, always looks scummy, and rofl has done little to nothing wrong. There again, neither has iceman.

Basically nothing actually scummy has happened yet in mine humble opinion.

However, I want activity and the only way to provoke that is with voting.

vote AlyG

I'll remove it if people start properwagoning, but I think the pressure is of use.

[Xylthixlm]

Rule 8 exists because I am an evil bastard, and will therefore be strictly enforced.

[Khelvaster]

I think we might just have the quickest win ever--

EA, Aly, and rofl as the three scum. EA's piling up of defense of Aly, combined with the Aly-rofl tag-team, makes me think of a quick three-day win.

Vote: Aly