Guns & Roses V [Game Over]

[Gún]

Sorry, could you explain your point more clearly, I don't see where I picked a fight with Hiraki?
They voted me, I let them know that they voted wrong. If anything, i'm doing it so that they don't have the blood of the innocent on their hands if they're town.

Sorry, I'm usually not the one writing out the words in these sorts of things... Rosé's the one that's good at it. Smartest hunter I ever met, and the prettiest too...

You had your reasons 'bout why you thought Hiraki's vote was bad, but they're a little rough, like the sort of rough that starts up a bar fight. Like you really wanted him to know, but then you take a step back and say nah, you wanna dip out of the fight. And it makes you look like the good guy because you're not willin' to step up to something bad like that. Dunno, maybe you weren't trying to fight him, but it looks like you wanted to get under his skin.

Make sense?

[Bell]

It sounds like you're always or normally a hydra with Rose?
Yes, but no.
Hiraki has thick skin IMO. They can handle it. Probably.
If hiraki is tvting me there's not much to gain by asking them about why they think I was being inconsistent or lying or both. It's just not true and there's not much I can do with it.
If it's SVT, lol, I can't do anything with that either because nothing I could say would change their mind unless they decided to make a show of changing their mind.

[Bell]

roleplayers

A common enemy of the people, but not a good reason to vote somebody~

[Iconeum]

Rawr!

[Iconeum]

Hello, all. I've come over from the artofproblemsolving forums as a few of us have been trying out the games here and have reported back positive things. Normally, we begin with some RQS, and so I'd like to propose that approach here to get things rolling:

1. What is your mafia experience like?
2. Do you prefer playing as mafia or as town?
3. How would you rate your scumhunting ability?

====

My own answers:

1. I've played in the region of 10 games.
2. I enjoy both for different reasons. For me, playing as town is more about solid logical play, whereas playing scum is more about emotional awareness.
3. Distinctly average. I think I often manage to identify one scum, sometimes two, but rarely an entire team by myself.

1. Absolutely terrible. I fucking hate this game.
2. Yes
3. What

is

scumhunting? How does one

define

scumhunting?

Do I scumread RQS? Why yes, yes I do.

[Iconeum]

I will also VOTE: iconeum

DrippingGoofball, do you find that your preference for playing town leads to a difference in your approach?

Hiraki, so you would normally — or at least more often than not — end Day 1 voting for mafia?

VOTE: Mr Sandman

[Hiraki]

It sounds like you're always or normally a hydra with Rose?
Yes, but no.
Hiraki has thick skin IMO. They can handle it. Probably.
If hiraki is tvting me there's not much to gain by asking them about why they think I was being inconsistent or lying or both. It's just not true and there's not much I can do with it.
If it's SVT, lol, I can't do anything with that either because nothing I could say would change their mind unless they decided to make a show of changing their mind.

1) the fact that I have thick skin doesn't give you justification to try and insult me
2) this isn't how town thinks

[Bell]

It sounds like you're always or normally a hydra with Rose?
Yes, but no.
Hiraki has thick skin IMO. They can handle it. Probably.
If hiraki is tvting me there's not much to gain by asking them about why they think I was being inconsistent or lying or both. It's just not true and there's not much I can do with it.
If it's SVT, lol, I can't do anything with that either because nothing I could say would change their mind unless they decided to make a show of changing their mind.

1) the fact that I have thick skin doesn't give you justification to try and insult me
2) this isn't how town thinks

1. Said you were bad at this, i.e., that you were bad at reading town for town, because I told you the truth and you voted me for it. Which means you either didn't interpret me correctly or are scum.
2. Is there actually a way for me to respond to this that won't sound horribly smug.

[Bell]

I stand by my sucking up oxygen statement.

Pass.

[Tanner]

ico, is there anything else behind your vote other than scumreading RQS?

[Iconeum]

ico, is there anything else behind your vote other than scumreading RQS?

i think the way they added a 3rd vote onto my wagon was pingy, even tho i'm probably a bit biased there

but still

[Iconeum]

Bell is pingy as well

Easily given townreads, refusal to engage when called out

[Tanner]

i can work with that, talk to me about bell. perhaps i'm

also

a bit biased, but i don't see early townreads as pingy?

as for refusal to engage, that also struck me as an ~odd~ thing town does more often than scum - stepping down before it turns into a shitfight *and* risking the obvious accusation of running away and refusing to engage.

do you have an opinion on my 21, both in terms of reasons to think bell is +town and in terms of me giving "easy" townreads?

[Iconeum]

VOTE: johnnyfarrar

i am slightly +town on bell for post 16. it struck me as an anti-town thing to say, however it rings like one of those anti-town things that scum are less likely to say. if it's accurate, his post felt like a "warning" to scum about albert - that i imagine scum would probably keep to a scum pt.

i had no problem with post 16

[Iconeum]

bell had like 3 town and 1 scumread after 22 posts (total ingame posts this entire game had at that time)

[Iconeum]

i know i've usually got some 'easy' early reads, but 3 town and 1 scumread after not even a page worth of posts?

[Iconeum]

tho i suppose you could argue that it isn't beneficial for scum to be sticking to reads at all like that, thus its more likely to come from town

[Tanner]

i wasn't asking if you have a problem with 16, i was wondering if you could see/agree why i thought 16 was +town, though looking at it now, it's probably a dumb question and i'm assuming the answer is no.

bell had like 3 town and 1 scumread after 22 posts (total ingame posts this entire game had at that time)

i didn't take his scumread of dunn to be serious (considering it was made after dunn had posted only once).

@bell

, could you clafiry?

i don't think he's exactly sticking to his reads, hell, he walked back from his hiraki townread within the page. i don't think early reads themselves are that brave or revolutionary, but the ~event~ of townleaning hiraki and then going back on it makes me think it's more likely to be genuine town thought rather than preplanned fake reads.

[Iconeum]

that is a solid thought

[Uncrowned]

HOLY SHIT ITS DIEGO BRANDO

VOTE: Hiraki

[Uncrowned]

oh nice ico is town

mind if i buddy you quickly?

[Tanner]

that is a solid thought

?

[Iconeum]

that is a solid thought

?

i wasn't asking if you have a problem with 16, i was wondering if you could see/agree why i thought 16 was +town, though looking at it now, it's probably a dumb question and i'm assuming the answer is no.

bell had like 3 town and 1 scumread after 22 posts (total ingame posts this entire game had at that time)

i didn't take his scumread of dunn to be serious (considering it was made after dunn had posted only once).

@bell

, could you clafiry?

i don't think he's exactly sticking to his reads, hell, he walked back from his hiraki townread within the page. i don't think early reads themselves are that brave or revolutionary, but the ~event~ of townleaning hiraki and then going back on it makes me think it's more likely to be genuine town thought rather than preplanned fake reads

.

[Iconeum]

oh nice ico is town

mind if i buddy you quickly?

[Iconeum]

hey bud

what exactly did i do to get townread?