Gut impression says this is not a readslist expressing a scum agenda which is what I was checking for here. The fact that all the pressure is on the dethy might make this less reliable but I think committed stances on the players outside of it are more valuable than stances inside of it because there's more wiggle room in the larger bunch where scum have to be more strategic about their reads.
I dont think that my day 1 play particularly revolved around the dethy, so if you want to see non-dethy focused Luke, you can look at my iso. I even made a full game reads list when firebringer asked me to.
Even today, my scum read on experience and my prior focus on you were also pretty dethy-agnostic, and you two just ~happen~ to both be dethy people.
Gut impression says this is not a readslist expressing a scum agenda which is what I was checking for here. The fact that all the pressure is on the dethy might make this less reliable but I think committed stances on the players outside of it are more valuable than stances inside of it because there's more wiggle room in the larger bunch where scum have to be more strategic about their reads.
I dont think that my day 1 play particularly revolved around the dethy, so if you want to see non-dethy focused Luke, you can look at my iso. I even made a full game reads list when firebringer asked me to.
Even today, my scum read on experience and my prior focus on you were also pretty dethy-agnostic, and you two just ~happen~ to both be dethy people.
Looking for your current stances was what was important to me and I felt I'd get more value from putting you on the spot. If you're scum it forces you to commit to putting names in a certain order rather than keeping options open. Scum when they assemble a readslist have to do a balancing act of trying to make it seem plausible while also working to advance win condition with it. I wasn't necessarily picking on you in particular but you happened to be around and I figured I'd try to get a read on you this way.
In post 4958, Lukewarm wrote:
My experience experience is that he used to effort as both alignments, and the writing style of that post was more standard. I actually lost a game in elo to scum!experience (as the deciding voter)
I also had a game where I incorrectly scum read him for lack of analysis, and his response was that I was using "old meta" on him. (I do think that this game is even more egregious ftr)
I don't know where his wim has gone. I actually hate that I can see this coming from town him now that I know who he is. I still lean scum, but I will be shaking my head in disappointment, not shock, if he flip green
i still effort as both alignments, just when i actually have a good grasp of the game.
and this game isn't one.
on the other hand, it's been a long time since i've had a game which i feel like i actually had a good grasp of. which might be due to me no longer having the time that i had in the past during my zenith
In post 3800, Sunflower wrote:
fire was like shell game's out! but u gotta study for your quiz. play shell game later. and i was like ok. and then i never returned to shell game until now LOL. that's mb
anyways im gonna continue reading if there are no further objections towards my completely nonexistent d1 play thx
People are saying the Gypyx thing is not a town slip but it does make them more likely to be town, right? Mafia would be talking about the Best Friend Neighbors (the actual role name) in their pt.
Why were you so sure this was the townslip in quesstion when you don't see it as a townslip?
I have reading comprehension?
I saw the gypyx post, had the "I wonder if they would be more likely to have missed this as town, because scum chat?" thought.
I then saw yours and dunn's conversation right after, which ended up mirroring my own thoughts. Including your opinion that it was unlikely to be faked because of the comments on experience, and also dunn's opinion that it is something that could have been genuinely missed.
My opinion might change when I re-read day 2, once I am back home, but from randomly phone reading in short bursts through out the day, nothing you've done today has really stuck in my brain.
I don't feel like that is a fair assessment. I've pushed what I thought were 2 different slips. And tried to figure out several players who didn't realize Hermit Crab was a claimed role without making it too obvious that that was what was happening.
Just a touch off given they seem to be doing the Homer Simpson fade into the hedges once everyone was going ho about the experience and gypyx shiny wagons.
In post 5019, morph the cat wrote:
Just a touch off given they seem to be doing the Homer Simpson fade into the hedges once everyone was going ho about the experience and gypyx shiny wagons.
It is not lost on me that they passionately defended themselves from my case on them point by point and thoughtfully answered my questions but vanish as soon as the heat is off them.
But with what wolfbae said about their post in the neighborhood I’m trying not to assume the worst.
I think the scum in the dethy is between Sunflower and experience and don’t really have a preference for who we eliminate first. I think Sunflower is scummier overall but I would kick myself if experience is scum and gets a mis-elim before dying after the shit he’s pulled toDay.
fire was like shell game's out! but u gotta study for your quiz. play shell game later. and i was like ok. and then i never returned to shell game until now LOL. that's mb
