Mafia 28: THoMioST - Game over!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think now would be as good a time as any for our investigators to compare results and for us to narrow down the list of people who might be scum.

We probly have only 2 normal scum left meaning they aren't investigation immune so we should be able to win from there.

[Thoth]

Hmm, I did not want to claim, but after an innocent investigation result I'm afraid I may not last through the night. As I have some info that probably is useful I think I should make a claim.
Before I do that I want one answer from Cadmium though: who did you watch over on Night 3?

[Save The Dragons]

Is everyone in agreeance that results should come? I agree it's a good idea, but I don't really want to do it if people are against it.

[SpeedyKQ]

Unvote ratpfink,

because of vikingfan's claim.

I too think revealing investigations now would be wise.

[vikingfan]

All right here are my results. Keep in mind, I only investigate on even-numbered nights, so I only have 2 results so far. Ratpfink should have 3, so I will be investigating tonight(help me out here, doc)

STD(pro-town)
Gaspode(pro-town)

I do not receive actual roles, just whether or not they are pro-town.

[Save The Dragons]

N1: Cadmium has a sword, helmet, etc.
N2: Corasto has a hammer, one end being sharp, one end being blunt.
N3: Quailman has some tarot cards and a crystal ball.
N4: Pooky doesn't have anything.
N5: Gaspode has lotions and bandages.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Quailman, got any results to show us?

As you can tell from STD, I don't have anything!

[Save The Dragons]

What is your role?

[Save The Dragons]

Not that I'm pushing you to claim. I'm just curious. If you want to, you can, but you don't have to if you don't.

[ratpfink]

What is with Quailman's crystal ball & tarot cards?

He comes out firing at two townies, which doesn't seem very seer-like, if that's what the items are supposed to mean.

[Quailman]

I tried to see Thoth in my crystal ball last night. I saw him with ratpfink. Ratpfink's defense of him sounded awfully scummy, so I figured they were both scum.

I am afraid I don't get a very clear picture, though. MoS has a bodyguard, so is probably important. I knew this from the start. I tried to warn people off him before he had to use his power day 1. Gaspode and Corsato don't seem evil to me. I knew that one night Fuldu went to the home of someone who did not die, so I figured he was OK (cop or doc).

I don't think I'm very good at using these, or maybe the whole concept of a crystal ball is fuzzy. And Tarot cards? Right.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

So this brings us to:
Known Roles:
ratpfink (replacing Flying Dutchman) (investigator with vikfan)
Mastermind of Sin (Our Lord Master)
vikingfan (replacing NanookTheWolf) (Investigator with rat)
PookyTheMagicalBear (poor penniless peasant)
Quailman (seer)
Save the Dragons (replacing Phoebus) (investigator)
Thoth (investigated by Rat)
Corsato(blacksmith)
Cadmium (knight protector)

Unclaimed/Uninvestigated
Flanagax
SpeedyKQ (replaced ScottHall)

At this point we should lynch Flanagax since he's the one of the 2 that did not vote for Coron the night before.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote

vote Flanagax

[Flanagax]

unvote

Maybe I should've voted for Coron on Day 4. But I felt that voting for Coron during the final two votes would have been the more haphazard option. If nothing else, I wanted Coron to have any available time to explain himself. My reason for not voting was out of fear of lynching an innocent. Obviously, I was wrong. Perhaps bandwagonning actually works in some cases. What I want to know are the differences with the Coron bandwagon and the other bandwagons we've seen.

[Talitha]

VOTES

Thoth (3)

- (Cadmium, Quailman, vikingfan)

Flanagax (1)

- (Pooky)

Not voting: Corsato, Flanagax, ratpfink, Mastermind of Sin, Save the Dragons, SpeedyKQ, Thoth

6 votes to lynch.

[Thoth]

At this point we should lynch Flanagax since he's the one of the 2 that did not vote for Coron the night before.

I don't think that is a very good reason for lynching someone. I also don't see why we should go with one of the unclaimed/uninvestigated players. To me Cadmium is a lot more attractive target. He was basically forced into this claim as he was found armed by Phoebus. Now we also happen to have 2 other (half)-bodyguard roles.

I'll probably vote for him, but I first want him to answer my question from a few posts up.

[Save The Dragons]

Flanagax...first of all, Coron's the godfather of the mafia, so there's a difference. Second of all, it's not so much your lack of voting, it's Speedy's voting. Speed would have been voting for the godfather at that point if he were mafia. As possible as it is Speedy could have seen Coron as a sinking ship, it's not very likely.

However, I do think you're more than you appear to be, and by process of elimination, probably scum.

Vote Flanagax

I get this strong suspicion Pooky's leading us. Based on his attitude, I've got a gut feeling that Pooky isn't all he appears to be.

[Cadmium]

Before I do that I want one answer from Cadmium though: who did you watch over on Night 3?

I picked the right person that night, Peacebringer. Yet nothing happened, he got killed anyway.

To me Cadmium is a lot more attractive target. He was basically forced into this claim as he was found armed by Phoebus. Now we also happen to have 2 other (half)-bodyguard roles.

I'm not sure what exactly the bodyguards do, but it looks like half the time, they investigate and the other half they protect (like a doc?). That's not comparable to my ability, actually killing the attacker. Plus, we don't know what STD might find when investigating one of them. Maybe they also have armour. Although I understand your reasoning, I think you're making a mistake lynching someone over this.

Anyway,

unvote: Thoth

I think Speedy and Flanagax should claim too.

[Quailman]

I agree.

unvote: Thoth

[Thoth]

I picked the right person that night, Peacebringer. Yet nothing happened, he got killed anyway.

OK, time to claim as well. I'm a priest. On odd nights I can pray for someone's life, basically acting as a doc. On even nights I can get someone to come to confession and confess about the night before.

Night 4 I let Cadmium come to confession and he confessed he didn't do anything night 3. The second part of the PM suggested some doubt about him telling the truth, but that was rather vague.
So:

vote:Cadmium

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote

vote cadmium

in that case it's highly probable that Cad/Flanagax r our last 2 scum

Me and Speedy are masons who happen to be incredibly poor and own nothing(ok fine we're a buncha lazy ol peasants)

[Save The Dragons]

unvote

Unless there's some intricate web of scumminess between Thoth, Rat, and Vik, it's safe to say Cadmium looks like a knight of Ness. PK FIRE! Sorry.

Vote Cadmium

Flanagax, Speedy, feel free to claim anytime.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Speedy's my mason buddy which makes Flany da last scum ^^

[ratpfink]

Vote Cadmium

, seems to be clear cut.

[Quailman]

Did vikingfan and ratpfink know each of other before their claims? And who's the duke that they are bodyguards for?