Newbie 1455: How We Met The Mafia (Game Over!)

[GamerRaptor]

Twilight is obviously town. He voted for phok, who was mafia. Unless, of course, they agreed for twilight to vote for him, and look innocent, and get us all killed and the world will end.

I think the latter is very unlikely, considering that this is a newbie, and proffesionals only do the latter.

Anyway, I don't know who to vote for? Maurice was the best at figuring out stuff, and Mafia didn't kill him, but rather, Dessew. I'm suspecting Maurice, because being the main smart guy, and then not getting killed after uncoding who is innocent makes me... feel suspicous of Maurice. Not enough to vote, just a weird gut feeling.

Dessew, if you do anything slightly suspicous, I'm voting. It's already suspicous that you didn't get killed while uncoding who is innocent. Be careful what you do.

[MauriceMoss]

^wat? Are you getting names confused? Are you hoping to be able to try to vote anyone out by using their names randomly in posts?

[GamerRaptor]

Oh wait, Dessew? OH LOL I was thinking of Dessew. Ignore that, the last sentance doesn't have Dessew, it was supposed to be Maurice... lol

[RachMarie]

GR

[MauriceMoss]

Twilight is obviously town. He voted for phok, who was mafia. Unless, of course, they agreed for twilight to vote for him, and look innocent, and get us all killed and the world will end.

I think the latter is very unlikely, considering that this is a newbie, and proffesionals only do the latter.

Anyway, I don't know who to vote for? Maurice was the best at figuring out stuff, and Mafia didn't kill him, but rather, Dessew. I'm suspecting Maurice, because being the main smart guy, and then not getting killed after uncoding who is innocent makes me... feel suspicous of Maurice. Not enough to vote, just a weird gut feeling.

Dessew, if you do anything slightly suspicous, I'm voting. It's already suspicous that you didn't get killed while uncoding who is innocent. Be careful what you do.

You do realize I'm confirmed town?

[RachMarie]

Maurice how are you confirmed town? At this point I believe only confirmed are those who flipped?

[TwilightsCall]

As far as I'm concerned, the two most likely candidates for our last scum are Skelda and Rach.

Maurice is confirmed town. I have a really hard time picturing Raptor as scum, especially after quick hammering phok. I mean, it's possible, but I really can't see it.

So that leaves Skelda and Rach. At this point I'm leaning more towards Skelda but I'll wait for a bit more before throwing my vote down. I don't have a great case on either of them so I'm not in a rush to move things along.

Cut by Rach, Maurice is confirmed town from Night 2 shenanigans.

[RachMarie]

I will go review that I may have missed some things with being sick

[DoctorPepper]

Mod V/LA until Sunday. Economics Exam. I will contact Mala

[Malakittens]

Vote Count 4.01

Not voting(5)

- RachMarie, Skelda, TwilightsCall, MauriceMoss, GamerRaptor

Vote History:

TwilightsCall -
Skelda -
RachMarie -
GamerRaptor -
MauriceMoss -

With 5 alive, it's 3 to lynch.

The deadline is Wednesday, February 4, which is in (expired on 2014-02-05 07:00:00).

Mod notes:

Both DP and I are on V/LA~

[GamerRaptor]

Okay, Maurice IS confirmed town, but I still find him suspicous... however, I won't vote instantly for doing a slightly suspicous thing.

Skelda doesn't seem to talk much. I wonder if he's either scum, or just has a busy time schedule?

[Skelda]

As far as I'm concerned, the two most likely candidates for our last scum are Skelda and Rach.

Maurice is confirmed town. I have a really hard time picturing Raptor as scum, especially after quick hammering phok. I mean, it's possible, but I really can't see it.

So that leaves Skelda and Rach. At this point I'm leaning more towards Skelda but I'll wait for a bit more before throwing my vote down. I don't have a great case on either of them so I'm not in a rush to move things along.

Cut by Rach, Maurice is confirmed town from Night 2 shenanigans.

I think that the other scum got on phok. I think they were one of the last to join the wagon, so I'd actually see GR as a viable option.

It is very foolish to assume that scum wouldn't do any distancing. I do not think that Rach is scum, and I know I'm not scum. And I could see GR quick-hammering Phok for easy town cred, yes, I could.

And GR, "I wonder if he is scum or just has a busy time schedule?" Activity is not alignment determining. My interest level for Mafiascum has been on a record low, and once this game is over I'll be taking a break, but I also have an incredibly busy schedule. I will try and come on as much as I can for the sake of this game, but I do not think you would be wise judging me based on how much or little I am around.

[GamerRaptor]

Dude.

Quick-hammering people is not THAT suspicious that you have to repeat my name 3 times. I just joined, and then I asked why everyone was voting phok. Didn't get proper evidence. YOU even SAID YOURSELF everybody WAS IGNORING US When we asked, and then you call me suspicious for hammering a Mafia because I didn't see evidence?

Skelda is defiantly trying to get fingers.

VOTE: Skelda

[Skelda]

I never said it was "that suspicious" GR. I just said I wasn't going to blindly townread you because of it.

Honestly, I'd rather not be alive in LyLo, since I have a feeling I am going to be lynched. I've had this feeling ever since I saw phok flipped scum, so if you all want to kill me now, better now than tomorrow.

And repeating your name three times was irrelevant. It is just the way I am typing, accusing me over that is idiotic.

[GamerRaptor]

Everyone was suspecting you, then you pull all your fingers on me for no reason. YES, I hammer'd at the last moment, but that's because I didn't have enough evidence.

You even said so yourself, and after TC briefly explained good reasons about phok, you don't vote. This is HIGHLY suspicous, and agreeing with me, then pointing fingers at me for voting scum.... ugh.

He was still scum.

Incase anyone wants evidence that Skelda is scum so they can quote this later, I've put them in this spoiler here.

Spoiler:

-Got called Suspicous by many people
-Didn't vote obvious scumbag
-Talks about people ignoring him for evidence, then points fingers at me for understanding it.
-None found me suspicous, and still talks about me in his post.
-Not on lately, and says that "isn't a reason"
-Just plain obvious

[Skelda]

The only point you have against me is that I didn't vote for phok. Honestly, GR, I'm getting the vibe you are misguided. With that being said, phok was far from obvious scum. Honestly, GR, I was surprised that phok flipped scum and while I am glad you caught one somehow, I am worried you are going to blindly kill myself and Rach and lose.

With that being said, yes, it probably makes sense to vote for me just because I didn't vote for phok. And look, I've basically been forced to reconsider all of my reads upon phok flipping scum. If anything, how not prepared I was for that should say something about whether or not I was scum with phok.

And things like many people finding me suspicious is not a point against me. I still don't understand how you caught phok, if I'm honest, since there has been very little persuasion and more just blindly expressing suspicion. And yes, my lack of activity is not going to be used against me. But I fully expect to be lynched today, that would not surprise me at all after standing by phok.

[GamerRaptor]

blindly kill myself and Rach

What does Rach have to do with this?

Alright, I think Skelda is hinting at mafia buddys. For one, I never ever suspected Rach.

[GamerRaptor]

Darn, I previewed to check the bold, then forgot to finish it.

THEN, you STILL keep pointing fingers at me for "magically knowing it was phok"

Didn't I get evidence of him being scum from TC?

Stop acting scummish. Your points are very unvalid, and they make you look more and more scummish.

[MauriceMoss]

Actually with two confirmed town we can't lose.

[MauriceMoss]

Oh wait......

I'm really not this dumb I swear.

[TwilightsCall]

As much as I dislike Raptor's reasoning, I think Skelda is still where my vote is going to have to go. Rach has at least put the effort into posting some sort of reasoning with her votes, which Skelda hasn't really done. Plus, his play is actually startlingly similar to phok's.

Votes without providing reasons. Phok? Check. Skelda? Check.
Playing mostly UTR. Phok? Check. Skelda? Check.
Artificial/uninformed attempt at distancing after the lack of N2 scum kill. Phok? Check. Skelda? Check.
Lack of initiative in defending themselves. Phok? Check. Skelda? Check.

Now, I will give that Skelda is actually posting and responding to comments, even if it is just Raptor's comments, which is considerably better than what we got from phok. That being said, I'm going to avoid actually voting for now because I'm not interested in baiting another quickhammer, and I'm interested to see if Skelda has any more reads/opinions that he'd like to share.

And to Raptor: let's pretend we lynch Skelda, and he flips town. Do you have any suspicions on anyone else?

Maurice, Rach: thoughts at all?

I'm down for lynching my top scum reads and all, but I would like to get a bit of a wider perspective before we lock into anything.

[GamerRaptor]

If Skelda is (somehow) town, then Rach would be a good target, considering that Skelda said that we were "blindly killing myself and rach" so either Rach is mafia, or Skelda is, or Skelda is an idiot.

They aren't both mafia, because phok was mafia, and there's only two mafia. So, that means that it's either Skelda or Rach. Skelda seems to be VERY suspicous, so it's him, I bet.

[RachMarie]

I would like Skelda to explain that statement more myself,

[MauriceMoss]

I have to keep checking the first post to see who is who. Overall I think all the people gamer raptor has played have been more questionable to me. All of them pinged me for different things. And GR really isn't making great points.

Skelda, on the other hand, is trying to walk the line (trying to say no one looks suspicious so they don't turn on him) and seems to have been caught by his "GR blindly kill myself and rach and lose" which includes the only possible mafia doesn't make any sense.

Rach has seemed off to me the whole game but maybe she's just been busy.

Overall I think skelda is a better lynch.

VOTE: skelda

[RachMarie]

Really tired right now with my cracked tooth which is getting worse, will be getting to the dentist later this week so going to bed early will check on this game later