Open 849 - Panic Room! -- Game over!

[humaneatingmonkey]

in my only completed game with umlaut, he was maf and his first real post was a big catchup post where i disagreed with like every thought he had

therefore if i agree with his thoughts, he is town

this logic is sound and irrefutable, no further questions

do you really believe this?

[humaneatingmonkey]

now im scummy after pointing out that umlaut is scummy

this is the bomb guys

[humaneatingmonkey]

Spoiler:

whats scum enchant like

ydrasse didn't you soulread enchant our last game? what's scum!enchant like?

how do you define a tunnel andante

@cat i didn't like questions liek these

i also disliked: his vote-hopping; interactions with prism; and case on andante
even now i don't really get his umlaut read

explain

these are just my posts
they're not even scummy

[humaneatingmonkey]

i think umlaut bomb is the solve here with partners skitter+yeet

[humaneatingmonkey]

maybe fireisredsir

[humaneatingmonkey]

@Ari
@Andante
@Enchant

are you guys willing join me?

[fireisredsir]

in my only completed game with umlaut, he was maf and his first real post was a big catchup post where i disagreed with like every thought he had

therefore if i agree with his thoughts, he is town

this logic is sound and irrefutable, no further questions

do you really believe this?

yes that last sentence was said without any irony whatsoever

[humaneatingmonkey]

question why you really think umlaut is town then

[Aristeia]

because he is mafia and umlaut is not in the scum PT with him.

[fireisredsir]

the progression doesn't make sense

he shades me slot, but stays on his RVS vote for a non-reason and later sheeps a gutread and now he's still now doing anything.

why people think this is town is bonkers

shading your slot but not voting there: i did that too! bad reason

stayed on rvs vote: idk, a little scummy maybe, but if he was maf then he was trying to look towny there and that does the opposite

sheeps a gutread: eh

not doing anything: same goes for multiple others

[humaneatingmonkey]

the progression doesn't make sense

he shades me slot, but stays on his RVS vote for a non-reason and later sheeps a gutread and now he's still now doing anything.

why people think this is town is bonkers

shading your slot but not voting there: i did that too! bad reason

stayed on rvs vote: idk, a little scummy maybe, but if he was maf then he was trying to look towny there and that does the opposite

sheeps a gutread: eh

not doing anything: same goes for multiple others

1. yes, and that's why i think you/yeet/skitter are providing cover for bomb!umlaut
2. early games are hard as scum. umlaut is very conscious of VCAs and he probably doesn't want to ping people as the bomb. also it's basically picking a fight with a loud town
3. EXPLAIN WHY THIS ISNT SCUMMY

[fireisredsir]

question why you really think umlaut is town then

i don't think he's guaranteed town, he's done some towny things and some scummy things and overall i think they even out to being a little bit on the towny side

it looks like you are coming up with reasons to justify having a read rather than having reasons inform that read in the first place. the fact that i cannot tell the difference between when you fake a case on someone for pressure and when you are actually casing someone in order to solve is p sketch. like they feel exactly the same

[humaneatingmonkey]

umlaut basically prefers to jump on an empty calorie wagon than their scumread because the wagon is more viable

[humaneatingmonkey]

this isn't a fake case

[humaneatingmonkey]

he's done some towny things

towny things being?

[fireisredsir]

1. yes, and that's why i think you/yeet/skitter are providing cover for bomb!umlaut
2. early games are hard as scum. umlaut is very conscious of VCAs and he probably doesn't want to ping people as the bomb. also it's basically picking a fight with a loud town
3. EXPLAIN WHY THIS ISNT SCUMMY

1. lazy
2. umlaut is good enough at looking towny when he wants to
3. could be. i don't see the scum motivation though

[catboi]

The day 1 herosolve attempts are going to make me lose my mind. I cannot emphasize enough that trying to worldbuild around elaborate theories is significantly more likely to be wrong and unhelpful than making more individualized reads.

Ari's herosolve reads like a bad joke which makes me doubt its sincerity.

[fireisredsir]

umlaut basically prefers to jump on an empty calorie wagon than their scumread because the wagon is more viable

are you saying the ydrasse wagon was more viable than a wagon on you? because i def disagree with that characterization

[humaneatingmonkey]

umlaut basically prefers to jump on an empty calorie wagon than their scumread because the wagon is more viable

are you saying the ydrasse wagon was more viable than a wagon on you? because i def disagree with that characterization

why?

whose wagon went up to 3 votes?

[catboi]

umlaut gets scumread a lot for bad reasons and everything so far is within his town range. Case is bad, dude. I'm not saying it makes you scum, either (I don't think you are). I recommend dropping it.

[humaneatingmonkey]

I think HEM has seen me play much better than this so I can imagine them scumreading me for not meeting that standard; sadly my willingness to effort has been pretty lacking lately (check out, like, every one of my games played this year for comparison)

this is unprompted and it's a guilty response

[humaneatingmonkey]

you guys are townreading umlaut on the belief that he's doing towny things, and when asked to explain which towny things it is, a lot of it is just weak excuses

[fireisredsir]

why?

whose wagon went up to 3 votes?

there's more serious suspicion on you even though the votes haven't piled up. idk why scum umlaut wouldn't want to get in on ground zero of that fertile soil for a wagon

i think thats too many metaphors in one sentence

[humaneatingmonkey]

everything so far is within his town range

okay then tell me who town!umlaut is

[fireisredsir]

you guys are townreading umlaut on the belief that he's doing towny things, and when asked to explain which towny things it is, a lot of it is just weak excuses

you are scumreading umlaut on the belief that he's doing scummy things, and when asked to explain which scummy things it is, a lot of it is just weak excuses