Earth's Struggle - Game Over!

[Starbuck]

Vote: DGB

DGB's big push on Nobody Special is very suspicious now that NS flipped town.

...what? No, it's not. Were you

expecting

a scumlynch D1? You're just trying to bandwagon.

Vote: Starbuck

Are you seriously asking me that question? Did you see how hard DGB was pushing for NS? It's like she knew he'd flip town.

[ZazieR]

Vote: DGB

DGB's big push on Nobody Special is very suspicious now that NS flipped town.

...what? No, it's not. Were you

expecting

a scumlynch D1? You're just trying to bandwagon.

Vote: Starbuck

Are you seriously asking me that question? Did you see how hard DGB was pushing for NS? It's like she

knew

was certain he'd flip

town

scum.

Another possibility perhaps?

[MehPlusRawr]

NS was in RVS for all of 25 posts, then said

I HATE YOU ALL

when he started getting voted for not leaving it. He continues bandwagoning for no reason, and then says

Oh, you guys.

You'll be

sorry.

which was enough for me to vote him.

[Starbuck]

I think you are confusing scummy with V.I.

[ZazieR]

@Starbuck
I mention you in two posts. One was even only for you. And instead of responding to them, you respond to MPR? I feel ignored

And MPR, any suspicions now? And when will you give content without being questioned for it?

[Starbuck]

I see the above. I didn't think that needed a response?

Where's the other?

[ZazieR]

Another player that has caught my attention is Starbuck due to her DGB votes. So I've got one question for you:
You've played with DGB before. How is this DGB-scum instead of DGB-town?
Also, what do you think of those players who didn't state reasons why they wanted NS lynched?

Here^^
And yes, it would have been nice if it had been addressed as it also questions why it's DGB-scum and not DGB-town.

[MehPlusRawr]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Togeloo

Out of Togeloo and Nobody Special (the 2 top suspects atm), I like Togeloo scum. The post jokeclaiming scum is just fishy as where Adrien C is. He directly complies to the prod made to ask Dripping Goofball about the late train/voting (which I like as possible scum too). Additionally, he's confused at all of the NS, CSL, BM, etc. acronyms when all he needs to do is check the player list. atm, he's the scummiest imo.

I'm fairly certain that at least one of SharkFinn and toowhateverhisnamewas is scum. Shark was a lot more pro-town than this in KoL Mafia as... town, and this vote is so forced it could easily be a bus. IIRC, tooasdfasdf also had some scummy moments that I can't remember right now and am too lazy to find.


I'll post content when not questioned when I'm not lazy.

[Starbuck]

Another player that has caught my attention is Starbuck due to her DGB votes. So I've got one question for you:
You've played with DGB before. How is this DGB-scum instead of DGB-town?
Also, what do you think of those players who didn't state reasons why they wanted NS lynched?

Here^^
And yes, it would have been nice if it had been addressed as it also questions why it's DGB-scum and not DGB-town.

Again, I apologize for not addressing it. People do miss things. No need to for the snark that I'm feeling coming off from you.

Because DGB normally has some semblance of sanity when it comes to who is or isn't scum, even right from the get go, NS was too much of an easy lynch.

I always feel people should state reasons as to why they want to lynch someone. I dislike anyone who jumps on a bandwagon without one.

[Adrien C]

I didn't ask BM about his extra item because, at the time, I didn't think discussing items would probably be the best idea.

[TheLonging]

I didn't ask BM about his extra item because... actually this is a terrible time to respond to that quote, cause now I can't remember my reasoning. Possibly because I thought he had an extra item, or maybe because I didn't even notice. And CSL didn't? The way I read them, it seemed like he answered them. And it's not like CSL-scum I know as well, it seemed like he actually answered in a pro-town manner. And, I thought that NS was scum for continuing to exist in a state of perpetual RVS, but Toogeloo bothered me so much more.

[animorpherv1]

@Zazie: I don't get it. Explain and I wil answer. If it's me living, IDK why.

vote:DGB

for elading the NS wagon.[/b]

FOS: CSL & Battle Mage

[ZazieR]

Good. Then please vote Shark with me, MPR. I forgot to state that my view on Toogy has changed quite a bit.

@Starbuck
First of all, I'm not being snarky. I could make a snarky comment now, Ohohohohoho.
Anyway, could you elaborate on what you mean regarding the part of DGB. I'd also like to know why you aren't calling players out then for not mentioning reasons.

1) Why do you vote NS right after DGB wants votes on him?
2) Would you have voted him anyways? What was the one post that made you decide, "OK, enough is enough."?
3) You voted for him pregame but hardly mention him during the game until now right?
4) Why is NS more scummy than Ani?

1) DGB is town, and then NS votehops.
2) Yes. Let me find it for you after this post.
3) Yeah, because he's scum
4) Vote-hopping and not giving a logical reason as to why he is voting them. That screamed scum against me in Newbie 824. Look at it.

Regarding 1: Your accusation was that CSL was following DGB. Though this wasn't the case. CSL was explaining this, yet you still kept the argument going. And now you suddenly believe him?
Regarding 2: He never gave you the post.
Regarding 3: 'Yeah, because he's scum' really explains why he hasn't talked about NS before he voted him, doesn't it?

So, Tl, do explain how these were answers.
Two other questions left:
-Why did you ask about Heaven in general?
-Why the need to state that CSL and DGB were wrong?


No question for you, Ani. It was a comment.

[MehPlusRawr]

Good. Then please vote Shark with me, MPR.

You're voting Shark? Cool. I love joining wagons on people I think are scum but am bad at starting my own. They never seem to take off.

Vote: Sharkfinn

[CSL]

V/LA from playing until my head clears. The mod should be able to know why.

[GhostWriter]

You guys are idiots. I claimed Mere Human, before it was in anyway indicative of Alignment/role.

VOTE: Chronopie. You can die now.

Reasons pl0x

Actually, reasons pl0x all.

I'd rather focus on more under-the-radar folks. Like Chronopie. Who has a lot of posts that either deal with nothing, pretend to deal with something but deal with nothing, or deal with things that are obvious and do not matter and thusly deal with nothing. On top of that, Chronopie shows up to "defend" themselves, ask what do they need to answer/explain for everyone, and then proceed to not do it. VOTE: Chronopie. You can die now.

I gave them a while back.

[AdumbroDeus]

Vote: DGB

DGB's big push on Nobody Special is very suspicious now that NS flipped town.

...what? No, it's not. Were you

expecting

a scumlynch D1? You're just trying to bandwagon.

Vote: Starbuck

After he started pulling a you... frankly I was.


Congrats Nobody Special, you have just earned VI status.

OK so CSL and DGB were wrong about NS.

Vote: Toogeloo

Toogeloo is still probably town.

Vote: DrippingGoofball.

Also, there being nobody to vig ani makes me sad. That means we probably will have to lynch him eventually.

Aaaaand...

Vote: Chronopie

^Shit. Forgot about that.

unvote; vote: Chronopie

Eh. That's what you get when you were so focused on watching your best friend's performance at a school, and then the aftermath.

Yeah...my mind is busy.

VOTE: DGB

All of you, explain your votes, NOW.

I gave them a while back.

An answer in light of the current situation, please, as opposed to just going off yesterday's intelligence.


How about NK analysis for example, does that change your suspicions about him at all?


At the very least, you should explain why nothing that's happened recently changes your opinion at all.

Vote: DGB

DGB's big push on Nobody Special is very suspicious now that NS flipped town.

...what? No, it's not. Were you

expecting

a scumlynch D1? You're just trying to bandwagon.

Vote: Starbuck

Are you seriously asking me that question? Did you see how hard DGB was pushing for NS? It's like she knew he'd flip town.

It's cause nobody special's play after he was fingered was incredibly suspicious, almost to obvious-scum level. There's a reason why I referenced to Chrono's play in SE mafia, he basically did exactly what Chrono did. The fact that NS DID puts him/her firmly in the VI category.


There are intelligent ways to break bandwagons and there are bad ways. NS's way was REALLY bad.

Some VI play is impossible to distinguish from scum play until after the flip, and frankly this was one of them.

Vote: Midnight's Sorrow

Oooh look, I'm so cryptic.

So... you complain about people voting without explanations... and then you do the same thing. Why?

[Toogeloo]

You guys are idiots. I claimed Mere Human, before it was in anyway indicative of Alignment/role.

VOTE: Chronopie. You can die now.

Reasons pl0x

Actually, reasons pl0x all.

My reasons are still pretty much the same as before. You are lurkish, attached yourself to NS's lynch so nonchalantly, and you are active when the discussion turns off topic.

[AdumbroDeus]

You guys are idiots. I claimed Mere Human, before it was in anyway indicative of Alignment/role.

VOTE: Chronopie. You can die now.

Reasons pl0x

Actually, reasons pl0x all.

My reasons are still pretty much the same as before. You are lurkish, attached yourself to NS's lynch so nonchalantly, and you are active when the discussion turns off topic.

Sorry, I intended to include a seperate quote there, similar to ghostwriter.


Basically, same deal, what if anything, does the information we have toDay change about your opinion on Chrono?

If so how so? If not, why not?

[Haylen]

Vote count here tomorrow after work.

[Chronopie]

mmm... cake.

Birthday cake = good.

be back tomorrow.

[Rena]

Chronopie, Sharkfinn, AlmasterGM, Midnight's Sorrow, MehPlusRawr, AdumbroDeus

Tomorrow I will find the town out of the above list!

Tonight I will sleep!

[ZazieR]

Chronopie, Sharkfinn,

AlmasterGM, Midnight's Sorrow, MehPlusRawr, AdumbroDeus

Tomorrow I will find the town out of the above list!

The bolded players are. I'm so proud of myself, I've already done my good deed for today ^.^

[Toogeloo]

Well, personally, I think the first day we had sucked ass. We really didn't gain any intel to work with, and the only real wagon of the day started in the RVS and nobody wanted to budge off it despite the stupidity of the whole thing. My thought is that Chronopie was opportunistic and only a handful of people were willing to be vocal about it, while everyone else was just content to let the day slide off into whatever the hell happened.

We may as well have started the game in Night phase with so little info that we gained on Day 1. Using what I got out of it, I am sticking with Chronopie as scum.

[TheLonging]

Adumbro missed the part where I explained my vote TODAY and YESTERDAY.

Will respond to Zazie after I catch up on all my games